Art and its materials

Low relief

low relief; lowness of relief; relief

The Tuscan sculptors' system: form kept close to its ground, and so freed from the weight of stone

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordSculpture in which the figures project only slightly from a flat background.
  • In The Renaissance"What is the precise value of this system of sculpture, this low relief?" (ROB §5).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §4 says that "Low relief projects only slightly from its ground".
  • A place to readROB §5, with ROB §§3, 11 and MIC §4.

Meaning

Relief, from the Italian rilievo, a raising up, is sculpture carved from a block so that the figures stand out from a ground. Giorgio Vasari distinguished three kinds: half relief, in which the figures stand halfway out; low relief; and a third, "flattened" kind, stiacciato, which has little more than the drawing of the figure, with the slightest swelling of the surface. His examples of the last were the figures on the ancient vases of Arezzo, on cameos and on coins.1 Donatello carried the flattened relief furthest in the fifteenth century; Luca della Robbia and his contemporaries worked in a low relief that allowed their figures more body while keeping them close to the plane.

Use in the book

The fifth paragraph of the della Robbia essay is the phrase's chief passage, and it asks the essay's central question: "What is the precise value of this system of sculpture, this low relief? Luca della Robbia, and the other sculptors of the school to which he belongs, have before them the universal problem of their art; and this system of low relief is the means by which they meet and overcome the special limitation of sculpture" (ROB §5; see Special limitation).

The question is the Preface's method applied to a technique. The Preface asks of each work what is its "virtue" (PRE §3; see Virtue); here the question is asked of a way of carving, and the answer is that low relief solves a problem. The problem is stated in the next paragraph: sculpture tends to "a hard realism", to heaviness, to the competition of stone with the living body (ROB §6; see Hard realism). Low relief solves it by refusing the competition. A figure that barely rises from its ground is plainly not a body; it is closer to a drawing, defined by "refinements of shadow" (ROB §4; see Refinements of shadow; Delineation), and it can carry intense feeling without the feeling stiffening into caricature (ROB §11; see Caricature).

The essay connects low relief with three things. It lends the monumental effigies "something of its depression of surface", and so "a pathetic suggestion of the wasting and etherealisation of death" (ROB §3; see Depression of surface). It is the result of the Tuscan "system of conventionalism", which represses "all such curves as indicate solid form", "throwing the whole into low relief" (ROB §11; see Conventionalism). And it is the "science" of the school, "its exquisite and expressive system of low relief", which Luca carried from marble into pottery (ROB §12; see Homely art; Science).

The Michelangelo essay makes low relief one of three equivalent means. Michelangelo "secures that ideality of expression which in Greek sculpture depends on a delicate system of abstraction, and in early Italian sculpture on lowness of relief, by an incompleteness" (MIC §4; see Ideality of expression). Greek abstraction, Tuscan low relief and Michelangelo's incompleteness are three ways to the same end, an expression lifted above the literal (see Abstraction; Incompleteness; Equivalent of colour). The Giorgione essay finds low relief's kinship with poetry: among the instances of one art aspiring toward another is "the analogy between a Greek tragedy and a work of Greek sculpture, between a sonnet and a relief" (GIO §4; see Anders-streben). The sonnet and the relief can be read as kin: both small and bounded, both winning intensity from their limits. Leonardo, as a boy, "constructed models in relief, of which Vasari mentions some of women smiling" (LEO §5; see Passing of a smile).

The phrase can be read as Pater's chief example of a limitation chosen and turned to strength. The low relief gives up the full roundness of sculpture, and gains by the loss the qualities of drawing and of feeling.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "low relief" or "lowness of relief" occurs, with the paragraphs in which a sculptured relief is named, in the order of the book; "relief" in the sense of comfort or release (PIC §11, MIC §4) or contrast (WIN §36) is not listed.

  1. ROB §3The Tuscan sculptors worked for the most part in low relief, giving their effigies its depression of surface.
  2. ROB §5Low relief is the means by which the Tuscan sculptors overcome the special limitation of sculpture.
  3. ROB §11The Tuscan system of conventionalism throws the whole into low relief.
  4. ROB §12Luca united the expressive system of low relief to the homely art of pottery.
  5. MIC §4Ideality of expression depends in early Italian sculpture on lowness of relief.
  6. LEO §5Leonardo constructed models in relief, some of women smiling.
  7. LEO §8Leonardo kept Verrocchio's love of reliefs, like the cameos on Saint Michael's girdle in the Virgin of the Balances.
  8. GIO §4There is an analogy between a sonnet and a relief.

In this edition

The note at ROB §4 says that "Low relief projects only slightly from its ground. On a work like Luca's marble choir loft, the strength of a shadow varies with the depth of carving and direction of light. Pater treats that variation as a means of suggesting movement." The Introduction says that "A relief can catch a gesture just before it passes." The note at ROB §2 says that Luca's glazed terracotta "was used for both reliefs and sculpture in the round, so the term describes the material independently of the depth of carving".

Source note

1. Giorgio Vasari, Lives (1550), Introduction to the three arts of design, "Of Sculpture", chapter X.