Time, flux and the moment

Passing of a smile

passing of a smile; smile, smiling, smiled

The most fleeting expression caught in low relief: what the Tuscan sculptors keep that the Greeks purged

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA smile crossing a face, appearing and going.
  • In The Renaissance"The whole essence of their work is expression, the passing of a smile over the face of a child, the ripple of the air on a still day over the curtain of a window ajar" (ROB §4).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §4 says that Pater treats the variation of shadow in low relief "as a means of suggesting movement".
  • A place to readROB §4.

Meaning

A smile is the most transient of the face's expressions, and the "passing" of one is the smile in motion, seen neither before nor after but as it goes. The phrase names a moment too short to be held, and the essay claims that low relief holds it.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the second sentence of the fourth paragraph of the della Robbia essay: "The whole essence of their work is expression, the passing of a smile over the face of a child, the ripple of the air on a still day over the curtain of a window ajar" (ROB §4; see Essence; Expression).

The sentence gives two images of expression, one human and one natural, and they have the same form. A smile passes over a face; a ripple passes over a curtain. Each is a slight movement across a surface, made visible by a change of light and shadow, and each is gone almost at once. That is exactly what low relief can show, since its means are "those last refinements of shadow, which are almost invisible except in a strong light" (ROB §4; see Refinements of shadow): a surface that barely changes, catching a light that barely moves. The child and the window ajar give the images their tone, innocent and domestic, the expression of a house on a still day.

The phrase answers the Greek law three paragraphs later. Allgemeinheit purged from the individual "all the accidents, the feelings and actions of the special moment", all that "endures but for a moment" and "is apt to look like a frozen thing if one arrests it" (ROB §7; see Allgemeinheit). A passing smile is the special moment itself, and the Tuscan sculptors keep it. They avoid the frozen look not by leaving the moment out but by carving it so lightly that it seems still to pass.

The smile is one of the book's recurring images, and the other smiles define this one by contrast. Leonardo, as a boy, made models in relief "of women smiling" (LEO §5); "the smiling of women and the motion of great waters" were the ideas that touched him most deeply (LEO §10); the Saint John of the Louvre has a "treacherous smile" (LEO §25); and La Gioconda's is "the unfathomable smile, always with a touch of something sinister in it, which plays over all Leonardo's work" (LEO §30; see Unfathomable smile). Leonardo's smiles are adult, knowing, held; the Tuscan child's is innocent and passing. The Giorgione essay makes the smile one of the "animated instants" of the highest dramatic poetry, "a mere gesture, a look, a smile, perhaps—some brief and wholly concrete moment" (GIO §20), and the Winckelmann essay records the Christian recovery of "the gift of smiling" (WIN §46).

The phrase can be read as the della Robbia essay's answer to the Conclusion before the Conclusion is reached. The Conclusion asks how to be present at moments that pass; the Tuscan relief shows a moment passing and does not stop it. The art that the essay praises is not an art that fixes the moment, as the Greek law feared, nor one that ignores it, as the Greek law required, but one that lets it go on going.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "smile" or its family occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §27Nicolette has smiling eyes, blue-green.
  2. ROB §4The whole essence of the Tuscan sculptors' work is expression, the passing of a smile over the face of a child.
  3. LEO §5Vasari mentions Leonardo's early models in relief of women smiling.
  4. LEO §10The smiling of women and the motion of great waters touched Leonardo most deeply.
  5. LEO §25The Saint John of the Louvre has a treacherous smile.
  6. LEO §30The unfathomable smile, with a touch of something sinister, plays over all Leonardo's work.
  7. GIO §20Dramatic poetry presents animated instants, a gesture, a look, a smile perhaps.
  8. WIN §25The pagan sentiment makes gods smiling and flower-crowned.
  9. WIN §46The religious spirit, as Hegel says, smiled through its tears; the gift of smiling was found once more.

In this edition

The note at ROB §4 says that "Low relief projects only slightly from its ground. On a work like Luca's marble choir loft, the strength of a shadow varies with the depth of carving and direction of light. Pater treats that variation as a means of suggesting movement." The Introduction says that "A relief can catch a gesture just before it passes."