From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA limitation is a restriction, a boundary; a special limitation is the one belonging to a particular art or material.
- In The RenaissanceLow relief "is the means by which they meet and overcome the special limitation of sculpture" (ROB §5).
- In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
- A place to readROB §§1, 5, with WIN §34 and GIO §1.
Meaning
The Latin limes is a boundary, a path between fields, and to limit is to set bounds. "Special" here has its old sense of particular, belonging to one kind (see Special manifestation). A special limitation is the bound that belongs to an art because of its material: sculpture cannot move, painting cannot be walked round, poetry cannot be seen.
Use in the book
The della Robbia essay begins with the idea before it names it. Its first sentence states it: "The Italian sculptors of the earlier half of the fifteenth century are more than mere forerunners of the great masters of its close, and often reach perfection, within the narrow limits which they chose to impose on their work" (ROB §1). The limits are chosen. The Tuscan sculptors are not lesser Michelangelos who could not do more; they set themselves bounds and reached perfection inside them. The fifth paragraph, where the phrase stands, names the limitation of the art itself, "the special limitation of sculpture", which low relief meets and overcomes (ROB §5; see Low relief), and the sixth describes it: "That limitation results from the material, and other necessary conditions, of all sculptured work" (ROB §6; see Hard realism). The essay thus distinguishes two limits, the art's, which is imposed, and the school's, which is chosen to answer it.
The Giorgione essay makes limitation the business of criticism. "One of the functions of æsthetic criticism is to define these limitations" (GIO §1), the sensuous conditions of each art; yet each art passes at times into the condition of another, by "a partial alienation from its own limitations" (GIO §3; see Anders-streben), and "sculpture aspires out of the hard limitation of pure form towards colour, or its equivalent" (GIO §4; see Pure form). The Venetians apprehended the necessary limitations of painting "unerringly though instinctively" (GIO §11; see Venetian school), and Giorgione kept the old Venetian clearness in apprehending them (GIO §12; see Pictorial design).
The Winckelmann essay turns limitation into pride. Sculpture limits itself to pure form, "Because, by this limitation, it becomes a perfect medium of expression"; "the limitation of its resources is part of its pride"; it "gains more than it loses by this limitation"; and the Greeks "apprehended and remained true to these exquisite limitations" (WIN §34). Sculpture is "excluded by the proper limitation of its material from the development of exquisite situations" (WIN §37; see Situation). The same essay knows the cost: Winckelmann's insight into Greek repose "seems to have involved limitation in another direction" (WIN §45), and Goethe found in Kant "a severe limitation to the concrete" (WIN §7; see Limitation to the concrete).
The phrase can be read as the book's account of how art becomes excellent. The Preface asks for beauty in its "special manifestation" (PRE §1); the della Robbia essay finds excellence in the "special limitation" accepted and used. The two "specials" belong together: each beauty is particular because each art is bounded, and the critic's task, in the Giorgione essay's words, is "to define these limitations" and to see what each art makes of its own.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "limitation" or "limitations" occurs, with the "narrow limits" of ROB §1, in the order of the book.
- ROB §1The Tuscan sculptors often reach perfection within the narrow limits which they chose to impose.
- ROB §5Low relief is the means by which they overcome the special limitation of sculpture.
- ROB §6That limitation results from the material and other necessary conditions of sculptured work.
- GIO §1One function of æsthetic criticism is to define the limitations of each art.
- GIO §3Each art passes into another by a partial alienation from its own limitations.
- GIO §4Sculpture aspires out of the hard limitation of pure form.
- GIO §11The Venetians apprehended the necessary limitations of painting.
- GIO §12Giorgione keeps the Venetian justice in the apprehension of the essential limitations of the pictorial art.
- WIN §7Goethe found in Kant a severe limitation to the concrete.
- WIN §32One form of art, by the very limitations of its material, may be more adequate than another.
- WIN §34The limitation of sculpture's resources is part of its pride.
- WIN §37Sculpture is excluded by the proper limitation of its material from exquisite situations.
- WIN §45Winckelmann's insight into Greek repose involved limitation in another direction.