Art and its materials

Incompleteness

incompleteness; incomplete

Michelangelo's unfinished sculpture read as design: what time did for the Venus of Melos

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe state of being unfinished, of lacking some part.
  • In The RenaissanceMichelangelo gains his effect "by leaving nearly all his sculpture in a puzzling sort of incompleteness, which suggests rather than realises actual form" (ROB §10).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §10 says that the quality is "Often discussed under the Italian term non finito, 'unfinished.'"
  • A place to readROB §10, with MIC §4.

Meaning

The Late Latin incompletus is unfilled, unfinished. Michelangelo's many sculptures left with parts still in the rough block, the slaves for the tomb of Pope Julius II, the late Pietàs, the figures of the Medici Chapel, were explained by his first biographers as the result of circumstance or of his own exacting standard; Vasari says that he gave up a work if he found the smallest error in it.1 Later criticism named the quality non finito, the unfinished, and asked whether it was intended. Pater's answer is that it does not matter: the incompleteness works.

Use in the book

The word stands in the long second sentence of the tenth paragraph of the della Robbia essay, which compares Michelangelo with an accident of time: "What time and accident, its centuries of darkness under the furrows of the 'little Melian farm,' have done with singular felicity of touch for the Venus of Melos, fraying its surface and softening its lines, so that some spirit in the thing seems always on the point of breaking out, as though in it classical sculpture had advanced already one step into the mystical Christian age, its expression being in the whole range of ancient work most like that of Michelangelo's own:—this effect Michelangelo gains by leaving nearly all his sculpture in a puzzling sort of incompleteness, which suggests rather than realises actual form" (ROB §10; see Accident).

The comparison makes the ruin an artist. Burial and weather frayed the Venus's surface and softened its lines; the result is "some spirit in the thing" that "seems always on the point of breaking out". The spirit is the effect of the incompleteness, and what time did by chance Michelangelo did by leaving his work unfinished. "Suggests rather than realises" names the method (see Realise): a form fully realised states everything and leaves nothing for the spirit to break out of. The phrase "one step into the mystical Christian age" makes the Venus a bridge between the Greek and the modern, and so places Michelangelo, whose expression is most like hers, on the same bridge (see Mystic).

The paragraph gives two further accounts and holds them together. Incompleteness is "Michelangelo's equivalent for colour in sculpture", his way "of etherealising pure form" (ROB §10; see Equivalent of colour). And "It was a characteristic too which fell in with his peculiar temper and mode of living, his disappointments and hesitations" (ROB §10). The first account is formal, the second biographical; Pater does not choose between them, and the "too" lets the man's troubles and the art's solution be one. Near its end the paragraph turns to paradox, "it was in reality perfect finish" (ROB §10; see Perfect finish), and the next calls it "the studied incompleteness of Michelangelo" (ROB §11; see Pure form).

The Michelangelo essay repeats the claim with a hedge: Michelangelo secures ideality of expression by "an incompleteness, which is surely not always undesigned" (MIC §4; see Ideality of expression; Half-emergent form). "Surely not always undesigned" concedes that some of the incompleteness was accident; "no one regrets" can be read as saying that accident and design have the same effect. The Botticelli essay uses the word of a limit, not a gift: "it was partly an incompleteness of resources, inseparable from the art of that time," that subdued and chilled his Venus (BOT §8; see Minor tones). And the Michelangelo essay ends its account of his thoughts of death with the new body imagined after death as "a dream that lingers a moment, retreating in the dawn, incomplete, aimless, helpless" (MIC §20).

The word can be read as one of the book's central aesthetic claims, and its boldest. Vasari explained the unfinished works by circumstance and by Michelangelo's severity with himself; the della Robbia essay makes them the summit of his art. The claim belongs with the Conclusion's preference for what passes over what is fixed: a finished form is a moment arrested, and an incomplete one is a moment still happening.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "incompleteness" or "incomplete" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. BOT §8An incompleteness of resources, inseparable from the art of that time, subdued Botticelli's imagery.
  2. ROB §10Michelangelo leaves nearly all his sculpture in a puzzling incompleteness, which is his equivalent for colour.
  3. ROB §11The Tuscan sculptors partake of the studied incompleteness of Michelangelo.
  4. MIC §4Michelangelo secures ideality of expression by an incompleteness surely not always undesigned.
  5. MIC §20In Michelangelo's thoughts of death the new body is a dream retreating in the dawn, incomplete, aimless, helpless.

In this edition

The note at ROB §10 says that the quality is "Often discussed under the Italian term non finito, 'unfinished.' What Pater takes to be a recurring expressive quality should be distinguished from the separate historical question of why a given sculpture remained unfinished." The note on the Venus of Melos at ROB §10 says that "Pater imagines its burial and weathered surface as collaborators in an expressive effect that he compares with Michelangelo's unfinished marble".

Source note

1. Giorgio Vasari, Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors and Architects (1568), "Life of Michelangelo".