Art and its materials

Refinements of shadow

refinements of shadow; refinement, refinements

The faint shadows of low relief, almost invisible, by which the Tuscan sculptors draw

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA refinement is a subtle distinction or improvement, a gradation made finer; refinements of shadow are the faintest gradations of dark on a surface.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Tuscan sculptors "seek their means of delineation among those last refinements of shadow, which are almost invisible except in a strong light, and which the finest pencil can hardly follow" (ROB §4).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §4 says that Pater treats the variation of shadow in low relief "as a means of suggesting movement".
  • A place to readROB §4.

Meaning

To refine is to make fine, to purify by removing what is coarse, as metal is refined in the fire. A refinement is either the process or its product: a subtlety, a delicacy, a nicety of distinction. In the plural the word often carries a hint of excess, refinements upon refinements, and Pater's uses keep that hint.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the first sentence of the fourth paragraph of the della Robbia essay: "They are haters of all heaviness and emphasis, of strongly-opposed light and shade, and seek their means of delineation among those last refinements of shadow, which are almost invisible except in a strong light, and which the finest pencil can hardly follow" (ROB §4; see Light and shade; Delineation).

The sentence describes the physics of low relief with an observer's care. A surface raised a fraction from its ground casts shadows so faint that they appear only "in a strong light". "Last" means the finest possible, the end of the scale. "The finest pencil can hardly follow" sets them beyond the draughtsman: the sculptor draws with gradations that a drawing could not record. The next sentence names what they serve, expression, "the passing of a smile over the face of a child" (ROB §4; see Passing of a smile). A smile and a ripple are both faint movements of a surface; low relief, which works by faint changes of surface, is fitted to show them.

The noun "refinement" elsewhere in the book often leans toward death. The Tuscan tombs have "a kind of sacred grace and refinement" (ROB §11; see Sepulchral portrait); Leonardo painted a young woman "full of the refinement of the dead" (LEO §19); Angelico's Mary is "corpse-like in her refinement" (WIN §27); and the abstraction of the Greek gods foreshadows "the fleshless, consumptive refinements of the pale, medieval artists" (WIN §45; see Abstraction). The Pleiad's poetry has "the grace which comes of long study and reiterated refinements" and "a certain premature agedness" (BEL §17). In other places refinement is simply a grace: the Provençal poets wrote for "people of much leisure and great refinement" (FRE §24), and the painters of the French Renaissance, working on glass, "felt their way to refinements on colour never dreamed of" (BEL §1).

The two leanings of the word can be read as Pater's warning to himself. Refinement is the quality he most admires and practises, the last gradation that the coarse eye misses; it is also the road to the bloodless, the over-subtle, the dead. The Tuscan relief is refinement in the service of life, a smile made visible; the medieval Madonna is refinement past life's edge.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "refinement" or "refinements" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. PRE §4Pater asks where the refinement of an age's sentiment found its receptacle.
  2. FRE §10The twin cups, kept constantly before the eye, give an air of refinement to every scene they enter.
  3. FRE §22Fauriel was surprised by the mixture of simplicity and refinement in Aucassin and Nicolette.
  4. FRE §24The Provençal poets wrote for people of much leisure and great refinement.
  5. ROB §4The Tuscan sculptors draw with the last refinements of shadow.
  6. ROB §11The Tuscan tombs have a kind of sacred grace and refinement.
  7. LEO §19Leonardo painted a young woman full of the refinement of the dead.
  8. GIO §24An elusive refinement is felt about the park scenery of the school of Giorgione.
  9. BEL §1Painters working on glass in France felt their way to refinements on colour never dreamed of before.
  10. BEL §17The Pleiad's poetry has the grace of long study and reiterated refinements.
  11. WIN §26Greek mythology brought to the ritual the power of the wing, an element of refinement and ascension.
  12. WIN §27Angelico's Mary is corpse-like in her refinement.
  13. WIN §45The abstraction of the gods foreshadows the consumptive refinements of medieval artists.

In this edition

The note at ROB §4 says that "Low relief projects only slightly from its ground. On a work like Luca's marble choir loft, the strength of a shadow varies with the depth of carving and direction of light. Pater treats that variation as a means of suggesting movement."