Art and its materials

Caricature

caricature, caricatures

Feeling fixed in stone until it hardens into exaggeration: the danger every style of sculpture must escape

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA likeness that exaggerates its subject's features, usually for comic or satirical effect.
  • In The RenaissanceMichelangelo avoided "a too heavy realism, that tendency to harden into caricature which the representation of feeling in sculpture is apt to display" (ROB §10).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the word.
  • A place to readROB §§6, 10, 11.

Meaning

The Italian caricatura is a loading or overloading, from caricare, to load. The Italian word was used in English from the late seventeenth century, and "caricature" from the mid-eighteenth, for the drawn portrait that overloads a face with its own peculiarities, and it soon meant any exaggeration that makes its subject ridiculous. Pater uses it in a sense closer to the root: not a comic drawing but the overloading of a form with expression, until the expression becomes a grimace.

Use in the book

The word stands in the first sentence of the tenth paragraph of the della Robbia essay, which turns to Michelangelo's solution: "And so, in a way quite personal and peculiar to himself, which often is, and always seems, the effect of accident, he secured for his work individuality and intensity of expression, while he avoided a too heavy realism, that tendency to harden into caricature which the representation of feeling in sculpture is apt to display" (ROB §10; see Accident).

The essay names caricature three times, and each time with a verb of fixing. Sculpture's limitation includes "an individuality of expression pushed to caricature" (ROB §6; see Hard realism); feeling in sculpture tends "to harden into caricature" (ROB §10); the studied incompleteness the Tuscans share with Michelangelo relieves "that sense of intensity, passion, energy, which might otherwise have stiffened into caricature" (ROB §11; see Pure form). Pushed, harden, stiffened: caricature in sculpture is not a choice of the artist but a tendency of the material. A feeling is a passing thing; carved in stone it stays, and a feeling that stays becomes an exaggeration of itself. The seventh paragraph had said the same of the Greek case in other words: whatever "endures but for a moment" is "apt to look like a frozen thing if one arrests it" (ROB §7; see Allgemeinheit). Caricature is the frozen moment seen in the face.

The essay's three styles are three ways of escaping it. The Greeks leave the passing feeling out (see Abstraction); Michelangelo leaves the form unfinished, so that the feeling never quite sets (see Incompleteness); the Tuscan sculptors keep the feeling but soften the form, by low relief and convention (see Conventionalism; Low relief). Each sacrifices something to keep expression from becoming grimace.

Older criticism had made the same point with a story. Lessing, in the second chapter of his Laokoon (1766), recalls a law of Thebes, reported by Aelian, a Roman who wrote in Greek, which bade artists imitate their subjects toward the more beautiful and punished imitation toward the uglier; and he argued that the Greek sculptor softened the extremes of passion because beauty was his first law.1 Lessing's next chapter adds the reason Pater gives: whatever by its nature breaks out suddenly and vanishes takes on, when art prolongs it, so unnatural a look that the painted laugh of a philosopher, looked at often, becomes a grin.2 Pater's "frozen thing" can be read as that argument in a phrase, with the appeal to beauty left out.

The other use is in the Leonardo essay, and there caricature is the comic kind. In Leonardo's grotesque drawings there is "an element of mockery also; so that, whether in sorrow or scorn, he caricatures Dante even" (LEO §11). The word can be read as making the essays' two subjects meet: Leonardo draws caricatures on purpose, out of a curiosity that lingers over the strange, and the sculptor of the della Robbia essay must take every care not to make one by accident.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "caricature" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. ROB §6Sculpture tends to an individuality of expression pushed to caricature.
  2. ROB §10Michelangelo avoided the tendency of feeling in sculpture to harden into caricature.
  3. ROB §11The studied incompleteness the Tuscans share relieves an intensity that might otherwise have stiffened into caricature.
  4. LEO §11Whether in sorrow or scorn, Leonardo caricatures Dante even.

Source note

1. Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, Laokoon (Berlin, 1766), chapter 2; Aelian, Varia Historia 4.4.

2. Lessing, Laokoon (1766), chapter 3.