From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordRealism is the faithful imitation of things as they are; a hard realism is one that imitates without softening or selection.
- In The RenaissanceSculpture's limitation "consists in the tendency of such work to a hard realism, a one-sided presentment of mere form" (ROB §6).
- In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
- A place to readROB §6, with ROB §10.
Meaning
"Realism" entered English criticism in the 1850s, from French, as the name of a programme: the faithful rendering of ordinary things without idealisation (see Realist). Pater uses the word more often of a tendency than of a programme, and in sculpture he means by it the material's own pull toward literalness. "Hard" is both a judgement and a description: the realism is harsh, and it belongs to a hard material.
Use in the book
The first sentence of the sixth paragraph of the della Robbia essay is the phrase's chief passage: "That limitation results from the material, and other necessary conditions, of all sculptured work, and consists in the tendency of such work to a hard realism, a one-sided presentment of mere form, that solid material frame which only motion can relieve, a thing of heavy shadows, and an individuality of expression pushed to caricature" (ROB §6; see Special limitation; Presentment; Caricature).
The sentence lists five symptoms of one condition. Hard realism, mere form, a solid frame, heavy shadows, expression pushed to caricature: each names a way in which a statue is too much a thing. The next sentence restates the tendency: "this tendency to the hard presentment of mere form trying vainly to compete with the reality of nature itself" (ROB §6). The reason can be read in the material. A painted figure is plainly an image, flat on its canvas; a carved figure stands in the same space as the viewer, with the same three dimensions as a body, and so invites comparison with a body and always loses. "Only motion can relieve" the solid frame, and the statue cannot move. Sculpture's danger, on this account, is that it is too real.
The rest of the essay gives the ways out (see Equivalent of colour). Michelangelo "avoided a too heavy realism" by leaving his sculpture incomplete, his way "of relieving its stiff realism" (ROB §10; see Incompleteness). The Tuscan sculptors repressed "all such curves as indicate solid form" (ROB §11; see Conventionalism). The Greek colour "never permitting more than a very limited realism" (WIN §34) belongs to the same discipline.
The word's other use in the book is historical and carries no blame. The movement of the fifteenth century was "partly also the coming of what is called the 'modern spirit,' with its realism, its appeal to experience" (LEO §17). Realism here is the method of Leonardo's science, the appeal to experience and the return to nature.
The two uses can be read as Pater's double attitude to the real. In the study of nature he welcomes realism as the appeal to experience; in sculpture he fears it as the death of the image. The difference is between knowing a thing and making one: the student of nature should be as literal as he can, but the artist who is literal in stone makes a corpse, "its stiffness, its heaviness, and death" (ROB §6; see Etherealise).
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "realism" occurs, in the order of the book.
- ROB §6Sculpture tends to a hard realism, a one-sided presentment of mere form trying vainly to compete with nature.
- ROB §10Michelangelo avoided a too heavy realism; incompleteness relieves the stiff realism of pure form.
- LEO §17The modern spirit came with its realism, its appeal to experience.
- WIN §34The colour of Greek sculpture never permitted more than a very limited realism.