From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordWistfulness is a pensive longing for something absent; the wistfulness of exiles is the longing of those who remember a home they have lost.
- In The RenaissanceBotticelli's figures have "a sense of displacement or loss about them—the wistfulness of exiles" (BOT §5).
- In this editionThe note at BOT §5 says that the poem Pater describes "assigns human beings an unusual origin in the angels who took neither side in Lucifer's revolt", and that "Pater borrows that intermediate position to describe his impression of Botticelli's figures".
- A place to readBOT §5.
Meaning
"Wistful" is a pensive, half-hopeless longing, gentler than grief and less active than desire. The exile was a figure of Florentine memory: Dante, banished from the city in 1302, wrote in the Paradiso of learning how salt another's bread tastes and how hard it is to climb and come down another's stairs.1 Pater's phrase joins the longing to its cause. The wistful are those who remember.
Use in the book
The phrase completes the story Pater tells of a Florentine poem (see Incarnation). If human souls are the angels who took neither side in heaven's war, then every human being is a spirit out of place, and Pater finds that condition in Botticelli's faces: "True or false, the story interprets much of the peculiar sentiment with which he infuses his profane and sacred persons, comely, and in a certain sense like angels, but with a sense of displacement or loss about them—the wistfulness of exiles, conscious of a passion and energy greater than any known issue of them explains, which runs through all his varied work with a sentiment of ineffable melancholy" (BOT §5).
"True or false" is the essay's boldest move. Pater does not need the story to be true; the story "interprets" the sentiment, as a myth interprets an experience. (The edition's note gives the picture to the Florentine painter Francesco Botticini, and calls the changed attribution "consequential for his argument".) The sentiment itself is precisely defined. The figures are "comely", even angelic, so that the loss is not of beauty. They feel in themselves a passion and energy that no "known issue" explains, a capacity that no action they know of could use. Exile is the state of a power with no place to spend itself. The phrase that follows makes the condition universal across "all his varied work" (see Ineffable melancholy), and "profane and sacred" makes it cross the line between Venus and the Virgin (see Profane and sacred).
The word "wistful" returns at once in the Madonnas' children, with "that look of wistful inquiry on their irregular faces which you see in startled animals" (BOT §7; see Enfants du chœur), and then far beyond the essay. The sacristy of San Lorenzo, with Michelangelo's tombs, is a place of "wistful speculation" (MIC §20; see Wistful speculation); in Winckelmann's dreams of travel "there seems always to be rather a wistful sense of something lost to be regained, than the desire of discovering anything new" (WIN §4). Exile itself frames the book: the Pico essay turns at once to Heine's Gods in Exile (PIC §2; see Exile), and in the Du Bellay essay the poet in Rome dreams less of the real France than of "that other country" which "the fancy of the exile, and the pilgrim" builds up (BEL §22).
The phrase can be read as naming the book's master-sentiment. The Renaissance, in Pater's telling, is a return from exile, of the gods to the world and of the mind to Greece, and the returning are wistful because they half remember. Botticelli's figures stand at the first and least certain stage of the return, still displaced, and that is why Pater gives them the phrase. Winckelmann's "something lost to be regained" is the same sentiment grown conscious and turned into scholarship.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "wistful" or "wistfulness" occurs, with the two others that speak of exile, in the order of the book.
- PIC §2Heine's Gods in Exile tells how the gods of the older world fell into painful embarrassments after the triumph of Christianity.
- BOT §5Botticelli's figures have a sense of displacement or loss about them, the wistfulness of exiles.
- BOT §7The Madonna's true children have a look of wistful inquiry on their irregular faces.
- MIC §14Dante's Beatrice is a child, with the wistful, ambiguous vision of a child.
- MIC §20The sacristy of San Lorenzo, with Michelangelo's tombs, is a place of vague and wistful speculation.
- LEO §28The arabesques of Ludovico's prison room at Loches may be the fruit of a wistful after-dreaming over Leonardo's experiments.
- BEL §22Du Bellay in Rome dreams less of the real France than of that other country which the fancy of the exile and the pilgrim builds up.
- WIN §4Winckelmann's plans of travel show a wistful sense of something lost to be regained.
- WIN §21Goethe was expecting Winckelmann with wistful eagerness when the news of his murder arrived.
In this edition
The note at BOT §5 says that "The National Gallery attributes this painting, The Assumption of the Virgin, to Francesco Botticini", and that "Pater uses the story of this painting to interpret Botticelli's other figures, so the changed attribution is consequential for his argument". The next note says that "Pater borrows that intermediate position to describe his impression of Botticelli's figures".
Source note
1. Dante, Paradiso XVII.58–60.