Religion, myth and the sacred

Middle world

that middle world

The place of those who take no side, which Dante scorns and Botticelli accepts

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe middle world is the region between heaven and hell, the place of those who in life took no side.
  • In The Renaissance"So just what Dante scorns as unworthy alike of heaven and hell, Botticelli accepts, that middle world in which men take no side in great conflicts, and decide no great causes, and make great refusals" (BOT §6).
  • In this editionThe note at BOT §6 says that Pater "turns a category that Dante judges severely into a place from which a painter can observe human uncertainty sympathetically".
  • A place to readBOT §6, with BOT §§5, 7.

Meaning

Pater's phrase has no single source. In Dante the neutrals are kept in the vestibule of hell, outside both heaven and the pit, because they lived without infamy and without praise; Virgil tells Dante that the world lets no fame of them remain, and will not spend a word on them.1 Older English had called the world of men itself "middle-earth", the realm between heaven above and hell beneath. Pater's "middle world" can be read as joining the two: Dante's despised region becomes the ordinary world where most men live.

Use in the book

The phrase opens the sixth paragraph, and the paragraph turns a sentence of judgement into a principle of art. Dante scorns these people; "Botticelli accepts" them (BOT §6). They take no side and "make great refusals" (BOT §6; see Great refusals), and the paragraph goes on to make their world the place where art "does its most sincere and surest work" (BOT §6; see Moral ambition). His interest is in men and women "in their mixed and uncertain condition, always attractive, clothed sometimes by passion with a character of loveliness and energy, but saddened perpetually by the shadow upon them of the great things from which they shrink" (BOT §6).

The middle world has its population in the essay. The angels who were "neither for Jehovah nor for His enemies" became, in the Palmieri story, the human race (BOT §5; see Incarnation). The Madonna is "one of those who are neither for Jehovah nor for His enemies; and her choice is on her face" (BOT §7; see Intolerable honour). Venus, Judith and Truth wear the same look (BOT §9). The phrase gathers all of Botticelli's figures into one country.

Pater's acceptance does not set Dante's verdict wholly aside. The figures are saddened by the shadow of what they refuse (BOT §6): the great things remain great, and the refusal is felt as a loss. What Pater rejects is the contempt (see Sympathy). Botticelli's "morality is all sympathy", and it conveys into his work "somewhat more than is usual of the true complexion of humanity" (BOT §6; see Complexion of humanity).

The phrase can be read with an irony Pater does not state. Dante's neutrals are forgotten: the world lets no fame of them remain. Botticelli, the painter of the middle world, suffered their fate, "little known in the last century" (BOT §1; see Secondary painter), and the essay is the act of remembrance that Dante refused them. The book's own country is a middle world as well: the Renaissance as Pater studies it is a region free of "rigidly defined opposites" (FRE §33; see Sympathy), and its critic, like its painter, takes no side in the great conflicts in order to feel with all of them.

Places to read

The one paragraph in which the phrase occurs.

  1. BOT §6Botticelli accepts the middle world, unworthy in Dante's eyes of heaven and hell, in which men take no side in great conflicts.

In this edition

The note at BOT §6, on "make great refusals", reads: "An echo of the anonymous figure associated with the 'great refusal' in Inferno III. Pater turns a category that Dante judges severely into a place from which a painter can observe human uncertainty sympathetically."

Source note

1. Dante, Inferno III.34–51.