From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordSpeculation is thought about what cannot be known for certain; wistful speculation is such thought touched with longing.
- In The RenaissanceThe sacristy of San Lorenzo "is a place neither of consoling nor of terrible thoughts, but of vague and wistful speculation" (MIC §20).
- In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
- A place to readMIC §20.
Meaning
The Latin speculari is to watch, to look out from a height, and speculation was first the act of looking, then the act of contemplating, and then of theorising beyond the evidence. "Wistful", a word of uncertain origin, means full of vague longing. Joined, they make a mood rather than a method: thought that looks toward what it cannot reach, and longs for it.
Use in the book
The phrase's chief passage is in the twentieth paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, after the account of the Medici figures as expressions of the vague fancies that arise when the mind thinks of the dead (see Disembodied spirit): "I suppose no one would come to the sacristy of San Lorenzo for consolation; for seriousness, for solemnity, for dignity of impression, perhaps, but not for consolation. It is a place neither of consoling nor of terrible thoughts, but of vague and wistful speculation" (MIC §20).
The two sentences place the chapel between two extremes. A church tomb is usually a place of consolation, its sculpture speaking of hope; the northern art of death, the Danse Macabre, is a place of terrible thoughts (see Danse Macabre). The Medici chapel is neither. It offers "seriousness", "solemnity", "dignity of impression", and Pater adds "perhaps" even to these; consolation it does not offer. What it gives is a mood: "vague", because nothing is known; "wistful", because the mind longs to know.
The next sentence explains the mood: here again Michelangelo is the disciple of the Platonists rather than of Dante (MIC §20; see Discipleship). Dante's belief is "formal, precise, and firm"; the Platonist's thought about the soul after death is speculation, and Michelangelo's is wistful because his hope rests only on "the consciousness of ignorance" (MIC §20; see Consciousness of ignorance). The chapel is that consciousness made into architecture and sculpture.
"Wistful" is one of Pater's words, and it recurs at his most sympathetic moments. Botticelli's persons, "in a certain sense like angels", have "the wistfulness of exiles" (BOT §5; see Wistfulness of exiles), and the Madonna's "true children" have "that look of wistful inquiry" (BOT §7); Winckelmann's dreams of travel have "a wistful sense of something lost to be regained" (WIN §4); the young Goethe awaited Winckelmann "with that wistful eagerness which marked his youth" (WIN §21); Dante's Beatrice has "the wistful, ambiguous vision of a child" (MIC §14). In each, wistfulness is longing for what is out of reach, felt without bitterness.
On one reading, this is the mood the whole book holds before ultimate things. The Conclusion, written in the same years, speaks of "a counted number of pulses" given to us (CON §4) and offers no consolation beyond the moment; its feeling about death is close to the feeling Pater finds in the Medici chapel. The sacristy of San Lorenzo, on this reading, is a place in the book where Pater's own attitude is set in stone.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "wistful" or "wistfulness" occurs, in the order of the book.
- BOT §5Botticelli's persons have the wistfulness of exiles.
- BOT §7The Madonna's true children, the poor among whom she lived, have a look of wistful inquiry.
- MIC §14Beatrice has the wistful, ambiguous vision of a child.
- MIC §20The sacristy of San Lorenzo is a place of vague and wistful speculation.
- LEO §28The painted arabesques of helmets and armour at Loches, where Ludovico Sforza was held prisoner, may be the fruit of a wistful after-dreaming over Leonardo's experiments.
- WIN §4Winckelmann's plans of travel show a wistful sense of something lost to be regained.
- WIN §21Goethe awaited Winckelmann with the wistful eagerness of his youth.