Religion, myth and the sacred

Reconciliation

reconciliation; reconcile, reconciled, reconciling

The essay's theme: making the old gods and Christ agree

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordReconciliation is the bringing together again of what is at odds: two parties, two faiths, two philosophies.
  • In The Renaissance"No account of the Renaissance can be complete without some notice of the attempt made by certain Italian scholars of the fifteenth century to reconcile Christianity with the religion of ancient Greece" (PIC §1). Pico is "an early instance of those who, after following the vain hope of an impossible reconciliation from system to system, have at last fallen back unsatisfied on the simplicities of their childhood's belief" (PIC §8).
  • In this editionThe Introduction says that Pater "finds another kind of revival in Pico, who hopes to bring philosophical and religious traditions into conversation"; the Outline calls the chapter "a study of the desire to reconcile traditions".
  • A place to readPIC §§1, 8, 15.

Meaning

The Latin reconciliare is to make friends again. In the New Testament reconciliation is God's restoring of the world to himself in Christ, in Paul's account of the apostle's ministry;1 in the history of the church it is the healing of a schism, and the Council of Ferrara–Florence proclaimed in 1439 a union of the Greek and Latin Churches that did not last.2 Pater uses the word of faiths and philosophies, and of a single life.

Use in the book

The word is the Pico essay's theme. It opens the essay, as the attempt "to reconcile Christianity with the religion of ancient Greece" (PIC §1), and the next sentence widens it: "To reconcile forms of sentiment which at first sight seem incompatible" belonged to "the generous instincts of that age" (PIC §1; see Many-sided intellectual culture). The essay then sets Pico's attempt among others. The council of 1438 met "for the reconciliation of the Greek and Latin Churches" (PIC §6; see Platonic academy); Pico's "generous hope" was to reconcile the philosophers "with one another, and all alike with the Church" (PIC §8; see Erudition). And it ranks the means. The scholars of the fifteenth century could reconcile only by allegory, making the religions agree "as subsisting side by side" (PIC §4; see Allegorical interpretation); the modern scholar might reconcile them as stages of one growth (PIC §3; see Development; Historic sense); the artists reconciled them in images (PIC §15; see Artistic reconciliation); and a later age would find "the true method of effecting a scientific reconciliation" (PIC §15; see Scientific reconciliation).

The personal verdict comes in the middle, in the sentence on Pico quoted above (PIC §8). "Vain", "impossible", "unsatisfied": the reconciliation of systems fails. But Pico himself is "reconciled indeed to the new religion, but still with a tenderness for the earlier life" (PIC §13; see Natural piety), and his life is "so perfect a parallel to the attempt made in his writings to reconcile Christianity with the ideas of paganism" (PIC §13; see Analogue). The essay can be read as finding the reconciliation that the systems could not make in a person and in art. What Pico's writings attempted, his life and the painters achieved.

Outside the Pico essay the word names reconciliations that are lived rather than argued. In the Renaissance of the first essay "whatsoever things are comely" are "reconciled, for the elevation and adorning of our spirits" (FRE §33; see Whatsoever things are comely; Unity of culture). In the Winckelmann essay Winckelmann "might reflect that while Rome had reconciled itself to the Renaissance", Protestant Germany had not (WIN §12), and his friendships with young men, "bringing him into contact with the pride of human form", "perfected his reconciliation to the spirit of Greek sculpture" (WIN §14; see Beauty of living form). A Church reconciles itself to an age, a man to an art. Reconciliation in the book succeeds where it is lived.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "reconciliation" or the verb occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §33In the unity of culture whatsoever things are comely are reconciled.
  2. PIC §1No account of the Renaissance is complete without the attempt to reconcile Christianity with the religion of ancient Greece.
  3. PIC §3A modern scholar might reconcile the religions as stages in the education of the human mind.
  4. PIC §4The fifteenth-century scholars tried to reconcile the religions as subsisting side by side.
  5. PIC §5The allegorical interpretation is the feebler counterpart of the reconciliation seen in the art of the time.
  6. PIC §6The council of 1438 met for the reconciliation of the Greek and Latin Churches.
  7. PIC §8Pico's generous hope of reconciling the philosophers; the vain hope of an impossible reconciliation from system to system.
  8. PIC §13Pico, reconciled to the new religion, tried in the Heptaplus to reconcile Plato with Moses.
  9. PIC §15For that age the only possible reconciliation was an imaginative one; a later age conceived a scientific reconciliation.
  10. WIN §12Winckelmann might reflect that Rome had reconciled itself to the Renaissance.
  11. WIN §14Winckelmann's friendships with young men perfected his reconciliation to the spirit of Greek sculpture.

In this edition

The Introduction says that Pater "finds another kind of revival in Pico, who hopes to bring philosophical and religious traditions into conversation". The Outline says that in the chapter "The life of a young scholar becomes a study of the desire to reconcile traditions". The note at PIC §6 says that "Efforts to reach agreement between the Greek and Latin Churches brought Greek-speaking theologians and scholars to Italy before the fall of Constantinople".

Source note

1. 2 Corinthians 5:18–19.

2. Council of Florence, decree of union Laetentur caeli (6 July 1439).