Religion, myth and the sacred

Artistic reconciliation

artistic reconciliation; an imaginative one

The truce of Christian and pagan made by artists, not philosophers

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe artistic reconciliation is the agreement between Christianity and the religion of ancient Greece reached in works of art, when painters and sculptors trained in Christian schools took up pagan subjects.
  • In The Renaissance"For that age the only possible reconciliation was an imaginative one, and resulted from the efforts of artists, trained in Christian schools, to handle pagan subjects; and of this artistic reconciliation work like Pico's was but the feebler counterpart" (PIC §15).
  • In this editionThe note at PIC §15 says of the background figures of the Doni Tondo that "Pater's description of them as fauns is an interpretation that serves his account of pagan forms surviving within Christian art".
  • A place to readPIC §15, with PIC §5.

Meaning

To reconcile, from the Latin reconciliare, is to bring together again those who have been at odds; in Christian language it is the restoring of man to God. Pater applies the word to two religions, and the adjective names the means. The reconciliation is not argued, as a philosopher's would be, nor explained, as a historian's would be; it is made, in paint and marble.

Use in the book

The phrase comes in the essay's closing argument, where Pater returns to his opening judgement that the Renaissance of the fifteenth century was, "in many things, great rather by what it designed or aspired to do, than by what it actually achieved" (PIC §15; see Initiatory idea). A later age, Pater says, would "conceive the true method of effecting a scientific reconciliation" (PIC §15; see Scientific reconciliation). The fifteenth century had only one way open: for that age the only possible reconciliation was "an imaginative one", the work of artists trained in Christian schools, and Pico's was "but the feebler counterpart" (PIC §15). The essay had said the same near its start: the allegorical interpretation is "the counterpart, though certainly the feebler counterpart, of that practical truce and reconciliation of the gods of Greece with the Christian religion, which is seen in the art of the time" (PIC §5; see Allegorical interpretation). Three reconciliations can be read as ranked: the scientific, which belongs to a later age; the imaginative, which the artists achieved; and the philosophical, Pico's, "the feebler counterpart" of the artists'.

What the artists did is described next. Whatever the philosophers said, the imagery and story of the Greek religion "were by artists valued and cultivated for their own sake" (PIC §15; see For their own sake), and "Hence a new sort of mythology, with a tone and qualities of its own", a strange flower grown from "the mixture of two traditions, two sentiments, the sacred and the profane" (PIC §15; see Anemone; Sacred and profane). "Classical story was regarded as so much imaginative material to be received and assimilated. It did not come into men's minds to ask curiously of science, concerning the origin of such story, its primary form and import, its meaning for those who projected it. The thing sank into their minds, to issue forth again with all the tangle about it of medieval sentiment and ideas" (PIC §15). The artists' reconciliation can be read as succeeding where Pico failed for the same reason that the historian later succeeds: neither forces the old stories to mean what Moses means. The artist assimilates them; the historian sets them in their age (see Historic sense).

The example is a single picture. "In the Doni Madonna in the Tribune of the Uffizii, Michelangelo actually brings the pagan religion, and with it the unveiled human form, the sleepy-looking fauns of a Dionysiac revel, into the presence of the Madonna, as simpler painters had introduced there other products of the earth, birds or flowers, while he has given to that Madonna herself much of the uncouth energy of the older and more primitive 'Mighty Mother.'" (PIC §15; see Faun; Mighty Mother; Unveiled human form). The reconciliation is in the composition. The fauns stand behind the Holy Family as birds and flowers stand in simpler pictures, as things of the earth; and the old religion enters the Madonna herself, in the energy of the Mother of the Gods.

The rest of the book shows the same reconciliation in other hands. Botticelli infuses "his profane and sacred persons" with one sentiment (BOT §5; see Profane and sacred). The Michelangelo essay looks back on Pico's way as one no longer open: Michelangelo might once have been for "adjusting the dreams of Plato and Homer with the words of Christ, like Pico of Mirandola. But things had moved onward, and such adjustments were no longer possible" (MIC §16). What remained to Michelangelo, Pater says, was a divine ideal above the creeds (MIC §16; see Divine ideal).

Places to read

The paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with the paragraph that first compares Pico's work with the reconciliation in the art of the time.

  1. PIC §5The allegorical interpretation is the feebler counterpart of the truce between the gods of Greece and the Christian religion seen in the art of the time.
  2. PIC §15For that age the only possible reconciliation was an imaginative one, the work of artists handling pagan subjects; Michelangelo's Doni Madonna is the example.

In this edition

The note at PIC §15 describes the Doni Tondo as "a round painting of the Holy Family" whose "background nudes have prompted different readings", and says that Pater's calling them fauns "is an interpretation that serves his account of pagan forms surviving within Christian art".