From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA scientific reconciliation of two faiths is one made by method, by historical and comparative study, rather than by allegory or imagination.
- In The Renaissance"It remained for a later age to conceive the true method of effecting a scientific reconciliation of Christian sentiment with the imagery, the legends, the theories about the world, of pagan poetry and philosophy" (PIC §15).
- In this editionThe note at PIC §4 speaks of "Pater's historical account of beliefs as the products of different cultures and times".
- A place to readPIC §15, with PIC §3.
Meaning
"Science" in Pater's century meant knowledge got by a method that others can follow and check. The "science of religion" was the new name, made current in England by Friedrich Max Müller, the Oxford philologist, in the 1860s and 1870s, for the comparative study of the world's religions and myths as human products with a history.1 A scientific reconciliation, in this sense, does not make the religions agree; it explains how each came to be what it is, and so removes the quarrel.
Use in the book
The phrase comes in the essay's closing argument, where Pater ranks the ways of reconciling Christianity with paganism, in the sentence quoted above (PIC §15). The fifteenth century had only the imaginative reconciliation of the artists (see Artistic reconciliation) and the feebler one of the philosophers. The true method came later.
What the method is Pater has said at the start: the modern scholar might treat the religions as natural products with common laws, judge each by its age and people, and range them as stages in the education of the human mind (PIC §3; see Natural product; Development; Historic sense). The scientific reconciliation can be read as the historic sense applied to religion. The artists of the fifteenth century did the opposite: it did not come into their minds "to ask curiously of science" where such story came from and what it first meant (PIC §15; see Artistic reconciliation). The scientific method asks exactly those questions.
The words "true method" are strong ones for Pater, and they can be read as his allegiance. The book belongs to the later age it names. Yet its admiration goes to the earlier reconciliation. The scientific one explains the old gods; the artistic one gave them a new life, the "strange flower" of a mythology "with a tone and qualities of its own" (PIC §15; see Sacred and profane). Pater praises the method and loves the flower. The Leonardo essay marks the distance between the sciences: "The science of that age was all divination, clairvoyance, unsubjected to our exact modern formulas" (LEO §13). The modern formulas are exact, and they do not divine.
Places to read
The paragraph that describes the modern scholar's method, with the paragraph in which the phrase occurs, in the order of the book.
In this edition
The note at PIC §4 calls the account of the historic sense "a Victorian judgment about the past", and speaks of "Pater's historical account of beliefs as the products of different cultures and times".
Elsewhere in Pater
Pater's own essays on Greek myth, "A Study of Dionysus" and "The Myth of Demeter and Persephone" (both 1876), can be read as attempts at the later age's method: they trace each myth from its primitive form through its growth in poetry and worship, while keeping the imaginative sympathy of the artists.2
Source note
1. F. Max Müller, Chips from a German Workshop, vol. I (London, 1867), preface; Introduction to the Science of Religion (London, 1873).
2. Walter Pater, "A Study of Dionysus", Fortnightly Review (December 1876); "The Myth of Demeter and Persephone", Fortnightly Review (January and February 1876); both reprinted in Greek Studies (London, 1895).