From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe historic sense is the power to understand the past in its own terms, judging each belief or work of art by the age and people that produced it.
- In The RenaissanceThe scholars of the fifteenth century "lacked the very rudiments of the historic sense, which, by an imaginative act, throws itself back into a world unlike one's own, and estimates every intellectual creation in its connexion with the age from which it proceeded" (PIC §4).
- In this editionThe note at PIC §4 calls the sentence "a Victorian judgment about the past", marking "a difference between Pico's search for truths he believed traditions shared and Pater's historical account of beliefs as the products of different cultures and times".
- A place to readPIC §§3–4.
Meaning
"Historic" is from the Greek historia, inquiry, and so a narrative of what has been learned; a "sense" is a faculty of perception. The phrase treats the understanding of history as a kind of perception, quick and immediate, like a sense for colour or music. It belongs to the nineteenth century, which made the historical method the key to religion, law, language and art, and which prided itself, against earlier ages, on having it.
Use in the book
Pater defines the phrase by contrast. A "modern scholar" occupied with the reconciliation of the religions "might observe that all religions may be regarded as natural products", that "they arise spontaneously out of the human mind, as expressions of the varying phases of its sentiment concerning the unseen world; that every intellectual product must be judged from the point of view of the age and the people in which it was produced" (PIC §3). He might range them "as so many stages in the gradual education of the human mind" (PIC §3; see Development). "Far different was the method followed by the scholars of the fifteenth century", who "lacked the very rudiments of the historic sense" (PIC §4; see Imaginative act).
The definition joins two things not always joined: imagination and judgement. The historic sense first "throws itself back", an act of sympathy, and then "estimates", an act of criticism. Without it, Pater says, Pico's age had no choice but to make the religions agree by force: they "were thus thrown back upon the quicksand of allegorical interpretation", and "Plato and Homer must be made to speak agreeably to Moses" (PIC §4; see Allegorical interpretation). The lack of the historic sense is the cause of the allegorist's method.
The book can be read as written with the faculty Pico lacked, and as aware of its cost. The Preface's critic asks what a work is "to me" (PRE §2), and the essays set each artist in his age, as the historic sense requires. Yet Pater does not despise the age without it. The allegorical method "has its interest" as "an element in the local colour of a great age" (PIC §5; see Local colour), and the Renaissance's share was "the leading instinct, the curiosity, the initiatory idea" which later ages, with better method, carried out (PIC §3; see Initiatory idea). The historic sense of the nineteenth century is the fulfilment of what the fifteenth designed; it can also be read as the relative spirit that, in his first essay on Coleridge, Pater made the mark of modern thought (see Relative).1
Places to read
The one paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with the paragraph that describes the modern scholar's method.
- PIC §3A modern scholar would judge every religion from the point of view of its age and people, as a stage in the education of the human mind.
- PIC §4The scholars of the fifteenth century lacked the historic sense, which by an imaginative act throws itself back into a world unlike one's own; they fell back on allegorical interpretation.
In this edition
The note at PIC §4 reads the sentence as "a Victorian judgment about the past", and says that it "marks a difference between Pico's search for truths he believed traditions shared and Pater's historical account of beliefs as the products of different cultures and times".
Later readings
The phrase had a long life in criticism after Pater. The poet and critic T. S. Eliot, in "Tradition and the Individual Talent" (1919), made the historical sense the condition of a poet's tradition: it "involves a perception, not only of the pastness of the past, but of its presence".2 Eliot asks the sense to make the past present; Pater asks it to keep the past different.
Source note
1. Walter Pater, "Coleridge's Writings", Westminster Review (January 1866); revised as "Coleridge" in Appreciations (London, 1889).
2. T. S. Eliot, "Tradition and the Individual Talent", The Egoist (1919), part I.