From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe circumstances in which a person stands at a given moment; in drama and fiction, the combination of circumstances that makes a scene.
- In The RenaissancePainting and poetry lift a character by "some special situation"; sculpture, which cannot, presents the type (WIN §§36–37).
- In this editionThe note at WIN §36 identifies Le Byron de nos Jours as the subtitle of Browning's Dîs Aliter Visum and says that Pater's concern is "the carefully staged moment in which the characters briefly become interesting".
- A place to readGIO §§5, 7; WIN §§36–37, 39, 53.
Meaning
Situation is from the medieval Latin situatio, from situs, site: first the place where a thing stands, then the state of affairs in which a person stands. In the criticism of drama it came to mean the moment of a plot in which the characters are so placed as to bring out passion, and that is Pater's sense. Behind the word lies an old question about poetry. Aristotle had argued in the Poetics that tragedy represents not people but actions and a life, and that there could be a tragedy without character but not without action.1 Pater divides the arts by the same question and gives different answers for each.
Use in the book
The word's chief place is the thirty-sixth paragraph. Painting and poetry can make any character interesting, because they can develop "some special situation, which lifts or glorifies a character" (WIN §36; see Character). To realise such a situation the artist may need "the most cunning detail" (WIN §36; see Realise). Then the example, from the poems of Robert Browning. "His poetry is pre-eminently the poetry of situations. The characters themselves are always of secondary importance; often they are characters in themselves of little interest; they seem to come to him by strange accidents from the ends of the world" (WIN §36). Browning throws such a character into some situation, or apprehends it in some delicate pause of life (WIN §36; see Pause in time), and the poem Pater chooses is "Le Byron de nos Jours" ("The Byron of our day"), the subtitle of "Dîs Aliter Visum" ("The gods saw it otherwise") in Dramatis Personae (1864), a monologue in which a woman recalls, ten years later, the moment when a man held back from speaking. "Those two jaded Parisians are not intrinsically interesting: they begin to interest us only when thrown into a choice situation" (WIN §36). To make the moment appreciable takes a cobweb of allusions and an artificial light "constructed and broken over the chosen situation" (WIN §36; see Discriminate), and yet the poem has the clear ring of a central motive, and gives the impression of a single creative act (WIN §36; see Creative act).
The thirty-seventh paragraph draws the law. Painting needs all its resources to produce such effects at all, with "subordinate but significant detail" (WIN §37; see Subordinate but significant detail), and poetry all of its to produce them "in a pre-eminent degree", "language in its most purged form, its remote associations and suggestions, its double and treble lights" (WIN §37; see Purge). "These appliances sculpture cannot command" (WIN §37), and in it "not the special situation, but the type" is all-important (WIN §37; see Type). In poetry and painting "the situation predominates over the character", and in sculpture the reverse (WIN §37; see Character). Of sculpture: "Excluded by the proper limitation of its material from the development of exquisite situations, it has to choose from a select number of types intrinsically interesting—interesting, that is, independently of any special situation into which they may be thrown" (WIN §37). The thirty-ninth paragraph adds the corollary. "Endless as are the attitudes of Greek sculpture, exquisite as is the invention of the Greeks in this direction, the actions or situations it permits are simple and few" (WIN §39).
The word has a wider life in the book. The Giorgione essay calls the "given incidents or situation" of a poem its "mere matter", which all art strives to make nothing without the form (GIO §5; see Matter and form), and says that poetry deals "most often, with a definite subject or situation" (GIO §7; see Lyrical poetry). The Winckelmann essay itself opens Winckelmann's Roman years with the word: "Winckelmann's first years in Rome present all the elements of an intellectual situation of the highest interest" (WIN §14). It ends with the modern novel, in which the network of natural law "becomes the tragic situation, in which certain groups of noble men and women work out for themselves a supreme dénouement" (WIN §53; see Dénouement). And the Conclusion keeps the word: only "the roughness of the eye" makes any two persons, things, situations seem alike (CON §5; see Discriminate).
The uses can be read as one argument. Sculpture shows the type and needs no situation; the modern arts, and the modern life they serve, have only situations. Pater's own essays can be read as written in the modern way: each begins from a character and finds the situation that lifts it: Winckelmann in Rome, Michelangelo in old age, Leonardo at the court of Milan. The phrase "intellectual situation" in the fourteenth paragraph can be read as Pater's name for his method, which treats a life as Browning treats his Parisians and a poem as a moment of passion thrown into relief.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "situation" or "situations" occurs, in the order of the book.
- FRE §23The charm of Aucassin and Nicolette is in a turn of peculiar lightness and grace given to the situations and traits of sentiment.
- PIC §2The pagan gods, in exile, fell into embarrassments that resembled tragical situations of their earlier life.
- GIO §5The mere matter of a poem, its given incidents or situation, should be nothing without the form.
- GIO §7Poetry deals, most often, with a definite subject or situation.
- WIN §14Winckelmann's first years in Rome present all the elements of an intellectual situation of the highest interest.
- WIN §36Painting and poetry lift a character by some special situation; Browning's poetry is pre-eminently the poetry of situations.
- WIN §37Painting and poetry need all their resources for the situation; in sculpture the character predominates over the situation.
- WIN §39The actions or situations Greek sculpture permits are simple and few.
- WIN §53The network of law becomes the tragic situation, in which noble men and women work out a supreme dénouement.
- CON §5Only the roughness of the eye makes any two persons, things, situations, seem alike.
- C73 §6Only the roughness of the eye makes any two persons, things, situations, seem alike.
Pater's sources
Pater does not cite it, but Browning himself, dedicating the reissue of Sordello in 1863, said that his stress lay on "the incidents in the development of a soul", and that little else was worth study.2 Pater's "situations" and Browning's "incidents" describe the same art from two sides: the poet's from the soul that develops, the critic's from the moment in which it is caught.
Source note
1. Aristotle, Poetics 6, 1450a15–25.
2. Robert Browning, dedication of Sordello to Joseph Milsand, in The Poetical Works of Robert Browning (London, 1863).