Criticism and method

Limitation to the concrete

a severe limitation to the concrete; that limitation

The discipline Goethe owed to Kant, and Winckelmann to the constant handling of ancient works: a mind kept to what can be seen and touched

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA restriction of thought to particular, perceptible things, as against abstraction and speculation.
  • In The RenaissanceKant's influence on Goethe "consisted in a severe limitation to the concrete" (WIN §7).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readWIN §7.

Meaning

The concrete, from the Latin concretus, grown together, is what exists in a particular thing, as against the abstract, which is drawn off from things by the mind. To limit thought to the concrete is to refuse to go beyond what experience can verify. That was the sense in which Kant's critical philosophy could be called a limitation: it drew the boundary of knowledge at possible experience, and denied the mind its claims to know what lies beyond. Pater reports Goethe's version of that lesson and finds in Winckelmann the same discipline reached by another road.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the seventh paragraph, where Winckelmann, under "this purely literary influence", that of Voltaire and French letters (WIN §6; see Artificial classicism), "protests against Christian Wolff and the philosophers" (WIN §7). The German rationalist philosopher Christian Wolff (1679–1754), who systematised German philosophy in the generation before Kant, stands for the abstract system Winckelmann despised. Goethe, Pater says, "alludes to his own obligations to Emmanuel Kant. Kant's influence over the culture of Goethe, which he tells us could not have been resisted by him without loss, consisted in a severe limitation to the concrete" (WIN §7). The irony can be read as deliberate: a philosopher taught the poet to distrust philosophy's reach. Then Goethe's further claim: "But he adds, that in born antiquaries, like Winckelmann, a constant handling of the antique, with its eternal outline, maintains that limitation as effectually as a critical philosophy" (WIN §7).

The sentence puts two disciplines side by side. Goethe reached the concrete through a critique of reason; Winckelmann reached it through the hand. The antique, "with its eternal outline" (WIN §7), does for him what the critical philosophy did for Goethe: it holds the mind to a form that cannot be argued away (see Antique). The essay comes back to the point at once. At Dresden Winckelmann shows "the native tendency" to escape "from abstract theory to intuition, to the exercise of sight and touch" (WIN §9; see Realisation), and by "a happy, unperplexed dexterity" he solves the question "in the concrete" (WIN §9; see Concrete terms). At the end the same discipline returns as a renunciation: a taste for metaphysics may have to be renounced by one who would mould his life to artistic perfection (WIN §51; see Im Ganzen).

The phrase can be read as the method of the whole book. The Preface asks the critic to define beauty "in the most concrete terms possible" (PRE §1; see Concrete terms), and to deal only with the impression a work makes, leaving metaphysical questions aside as "unprofitable" (PRE §2; see Metaphysical question). The Winckelmann essay gives that method a pedigree: Kant's limitation in Goethe, the antiquary's hand in Winckelmann, and the critic's impression in Pater are three forms of one refusal. Pater's own debt to Kant is not stated, and the book takes the lesson from its effect on Goethe rather than from the philosophy itself.

Places to read

The paragraphs in which Pater speaks of Winckelmann's or Goethe's limitation to the concrete, in the order of the book.

  1. WIN §7Kant's influence on Goethe consisted in a severe limitation to the concrete; in Winckelmann a constant handling of the antique maintains that limitation.
  2. WIN §9Winckelmann escapes from abstract theory to intuition, and solves the question of Greek art in the concrete.