From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA poetical painter is one whose pictures carry the charms proper to poetry, story and sentiment, together with those proper to painting.
- In The Renaissance"He is before all things a poetical painter, blending the charm of story and sentiment, the medium of the art of poetry, with the charm of line and colour, the medium of abstract painting" (BOT §3).
- In this editionThe note at BOT §3 says that the Florentine printing of Dante "included Cristoforo Landino's commentary and copper engravings based on designs associated with Botticelli".
- A place to readBOT §3, with GIO §2.
Meaning
The kinship of the two arts is one of the oldest commonplaces of criticism. It had its classical formulas in Simonides and Horace (see Pictorial poetry). Lessing's Laocoön (1766) attacked the commonplace, arguing that the two arts have different means and must not borrow each other's effects. Pater's phrase can be read as standing between the commonplace and its critic: it accepts that a painter may be poetical, but it names the two media and calls the result a blend.
Use in the book
The phrase opens the essay's third paragraph and governs it; the sentence quoted above goes on: "So he becomes the illustrator of Dante" (BOT §3; see Abstract painting; Line and colour). The second sentence follows from the first: a painter who blends poetry with painting is the natural illustrator of a poet. Pater then explains why Dante had to wait for him. "Giotto, and the followers of Giotto, with their almost childish religious aim, had not learned to put that weight of meaning into outward things, light, colour, everyday gesture, which the poetry of the Divine Comedy involves, and before the fifteenth century Dante could hardly have found an illustrator" (BOT §3; see Outward image). Dante's poetry lays meaning on light and gesture; only a painter who could do the same could answer it.
The rest of the paragraph tests the claim and qualifies it. The illustrations are crowded (see Pictorial propriety), the grotesques too strong (see Lower in key), but the simoniacs' burning feet and the dainty Centaurs show "a true painter's vision" (BOT §3; see Painter's vision). The poetical painter is best when he is most a painter.
The Giorgione essay returns to the word with a warning. It is "the way of most spectators, and of many critics" to see in a picture either technical skill "or a merely poetical, or what may be called literary interest, addressed also to the pure intelligence" (GIO §2). There the poetical is a misreading, the spectator's attention to the story rather than to the picture. The two essays can be read as a correction. Botticelli is a poetical painter in the good sense, because his story and sentiment are blended with the charm of line and colour, and reach the viewer through the cold light and the wan faces as much as through the subject. The spectator who reads only the story is poetical in the bad sense. Giorgione's school makes "pictorial poetry" (GIO §20), in which the poetry has been wholly absorbed into the painting (see Anders-streben).
The phrase can be read as Pater's own position in the quarrel between the commonplace and Lessing. He grants Lessing that the arts have different media and different responsibilities; he keeps from the commonplace the belief that a painter's best work may still be poetry. The poetical painter is the one who has found poetry in painting's own means.
Places to read
The one paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with the two paragraphs of the Giorgione essay on the poetical in painting, in the order of the book.
In this edition
The note at GIO §1 says that "Pater opens with a theory he rejects. Color, sound and rhythm are part of the work's meaning and pleasure. A paraphrase of a subject therefore leaves something specific to its medium behind." The note at BOT §3 says that the Florentine printing of Dante "included Cristoforo Landino's commentary and copper engravings based on designs associated with Botticelli".