From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordPictorial propriety is what is fitting to a picture as a picture, above all the rule that it shows a single moment.
- In The Renaissance"Botticelli's illustrations are crowded with incident, blending, with a naïve carelessness of pictorial propriety, three phases of the same scene into one plate" (BOT §3).
- In this editionThe note at BOT §3 says that "Different surviving copies contain different numbers and placements of impressions".
- A place to readBOT §3, with GIO §20.
Meaning
Propriety is from proprius, one's own: what properly belongs to a thing. Classical criticism called it decorum, the fitting, and Horace asked that each kind hold the seemly place that has fallen to it.1 For painting, Lessing's Laocoön gave the rule its classic form: a picture shows one instant and must choose the most "pregnant" one, from which what comes before and after is most easily understood.2 To show the same figure three times in one picture, as the older painters did in telling a story, broke the rule.
Use in the book
The phrase occurs once, in the judgement on Botticelli's engravings for the Florentine Dante of 1481 quoted above (BOT §3). The method was usual in Botticelli's century: his own frescoes in the Sistine Chapel tell several episodes of one story in a single field. Pater names it as a fault and excuses it in the same breath. "Naïve" makes the carelessness innocent, the mark of an art that had not yet learned its own limits, and the word belongs with the "freshness" and "diffident promise" of the earlier Renaissance that the essay ends by praising (BOT §10; see New artistic sense).
The Giorgione essay shows what pictorial propriety becomes when it is learned. The Venetian painters, above all, conceived "the essence of what is pictorial in a picture" (GIO §11), and Giorgione's school "exercises a wonderful tact in the selecting of such matter as lends itself most readily and entirely to pictorial form" (GIO §20). Its subjects are "animated instants", single moments into which a long history has condensed (GIO §20; see Concrete terms). That can be read as Lessing's pregnant moment in Pater's words. The crowded plate that blends three phases is its opposite: a story spread across a surface rather than condensed into a moment.
"Pictorial" is a word of the later essays, and especially of the Giorgione. In the Leonardo essay it marks a lower aim: Leonardo uses his subjects "not as matter for definite pictorial realisation" but as the start of "a train of sentiment" (LEO §25; see Realisation). In the Giorgione essay it marks the highest: "true pictorial charm" (GIO §1), "the essential limitations of the pictorial art" (GIO §12). Pater's vocabulary shows the book's own development, from the poetical painter of the Botticelli essay to the pictorial poetry of Giorgione's school (see Poetical painter).
The phrase can be read as a small instance of Pater's historical tact. He holds the rule, and he does not hold it against the painter who did not know it. Botticelli's impropriety is part of the charm of an age that was still finding out what a picture could do; Giorgione's propriety is the reward of the finding out.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "pictorial" occurs, in the order of the book.
- BOT §3Botticelli's illustrations blend, with a naïve carelessness of pictorial propriety, three phases of a scene into one plate.
- MIC §18The medieval mind gave an independent traditional existence to a special pictorial conception.
- LEO §25Leonardo uses the ostensible subject not as matter for definite pictorial realisation.
- LEO §29Leonardo uses sacred story not as mere subjects for pictorial realisation.
- GIO §1Criticism must note in a picture the true pictorial charm.
- GIO §2Great painting is drawing projected from a peculiar pictorial temperament.
- GIO §4Some music seems always to be approaching to figure, to pictorial definition.
- GIO §11The Venetian school conceived most justly the essence of what is pictorial in a picture.
- GIO §12In Giorgione the old Venetian apprehension of the limits of the pictorial art is undisturbed.
- GIO §20Giorgione's school selects matter that lends itself to pictorial form.
In this edition
The note at BOT §3 says that "The Florentine printing of Dante's Commedia included Cristoforo Landino's commentary and copper engravings based on designs associated with Botticelli. Different surviving copies contain different numbers and placements of impressions."
Source note
1. Horace, Ars poetica 92.
2. Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, Laokoon (Berlin, 1766), chapters 3 and 16.