From the book
Meditations
Marcus Aurelius · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA δόγμα is what seems right to a man and is settled with him: a principle. A θεώρημα is a proposition of philosophy as it is taught, a doctrine. Ὑπομιμνήσκειν is to remind, and πρόχειρος is "ready to hand".
- In the MeditationsPrinciples are a few convictions about good and bad, "from which come impulses and actions" (8.1). They die only if the impressions that correspond to them are quenched, and it is in Marcus' power "perpetually to rekindle" those (7.2). They are to be brief (4.3.1), kept ready as a doctor keeps his knives (3.13), always to hand as the pancratiast, who fights with bare hands, has his hand (12.9), and called up by reminders.
- In this editionΔόγμα is always "principle", θεώρημα always "doctrine"; ὑπομιμνήσκειν is "remind" and ὑπόμνησις "reminder", ἀναμιμνήσκειν "remind yourself" and once "remember" (5.31); ὑπόμνημα is "notes" (1.7.3) and ὑπομνημάτιον "little notebooks" (3.14); πρόχειρος is "ready to hand", with "ready", "at hand" and "first to hand" by sense; ἀναζωπυρεῖν is "rekindle".
- A place to read7.2, where principles die only when their impressions are quenched, and coming back to life is seeing things again as before.
Meaning
Δόγμα (dogma), from δοκεῖν (dokein), "to seem", is what seems so to someone and has been resolved: an opinion, a decree, and in the philosophical schools a tenet. In Marcus a principle is never a passing opinion: it is a conviction about good and bad, belonging to the mind (3.16.1) and issuing in action (8.1). Θεώρημα (theōrēma), from θεωρεῖν (theōrein), "to view", is what has been viewed and set out: a theorem in geometry, a doctrine in philosophy. The words of reminding are built on μιμνήσκειν (mimnēskein), "to bring to mind": ὑπομιμνήσκειν (hypomimnēskein) is to bring back to mind what is already known, ὑπόμνησις (hypomnēsis) a reminding, ὑπόμνημα (hypomnēma) a record kept to remind, a note. Πρόχειρος (procheiros), "before the hand", is what lies ready for use.
Use in the book
Marcus gives principles their place in one line: "Body, soul, mind. Of the body, sensations; of the soul, impulses; of the mind, principles" (3.16.1). At 2.3 he sets down a handful of sentences on providence and nature and ends, "Let this be enough for you; let these be your principles. As for the thirst for books, throw it away, so that you do not die grumbling" (2.3; see Nature). At 8.1, asking how he will do what the nature of man seeks, he answers, "If you have principles from which come impulses and actions. What principles? About good things and bad". A principle can be a single sentence, to be used "at everything that leads you towards distress": "not that this is a misfortune, but that to bear it nobly is good fortune" (4.49.2). He admired Sextus of Chaeronea, Plutarch's nephew, for "finding and ordering, with a firm grasp and by method, the principles necessary for life" (1.9.2).
Doctrine is another thing. From Junius Rusticus, the Stoic, he learned not "to write treatises on doctrines" (1.7.1), and in Apollonius, another Stoic teacher, he saw a man who counted his skill "in passing on doctrines as the least of his own honourable qualities" (1.8.2). Yet he does not despise doctrine: "Let no act be done at random, nor otherwise than according to a doctrine that completes the art" (4.2), and the art of being good comes about honourably only "from doctrines, some about the nature of the whole, others about man's own constitution" (11.5). Doctrines are taught; principles are what a man lives by.
Other men too are explained by their principles. Whoever he meets, Marcus is to ask, "what principles does this man have about good things and bad?", and then remember "that he is compelled to act so" (8.14). Socrates "used to call the principles of the many Lamias, children's bugbears" (11.23). Marcus himself asks, "without a change of principles, what else is there but slavery of men groaning and making a show of obeying?" (9.29).
The centre of the matter is that principles can die. "How else can principles be put to death, unless the impressions that correspond to them are quenched, which it is in your power perpetually to rekindle?" (7.2). Distraction wears them away: "Mime, war, flutter, torpor, slavery: day by day those sacred principles of yours will be wiped away, all that you form impressions of without studying nature, and let pass" (10.9). Recovery is in his power: "It is open to you to come back to life. See things again as you used to see them; for in this lies coming back to life" (7.2). A principle can also be corrected: "who prevents you from setting right the principle?" (8.47; see Assent and judgement).
Against that death Marcus tells himself to keep his principles ready. "As doctors always have their instruments and knives at hand for sudden cases, so do you have the principles ready for knowing things divine and human" (3.13). At 12.9 he goes further: "one must be, in the use of principles, like the pancratiast, not the gladiator; for the one lays down the sword he uses and takes it up, but the other always has the hand, and there is need of nothing else than to clench it". The things within, into which he looks when he retreats into himself, are to be "brief and elementary, the things that, as soon as they present themselves, will suffice to shut out the whole court" (4.3.1). One formula after another is to be "ready to hand": at every event (7.1), in pain (7.64), at a man's shamelessness (9.42.1), in fits of anger (11.18.5). To one "steeped in the true principles" even a line of Homer is "enough as a reminder of freedom from distress and from fear" (10.34).
Reminding is the method. Marcus puts his own falling short of the life according to nature down to "not keeping the reminders of the gods" (1.17.6). At each thing one must "remind oneself" whether it is one of the things that are not necessary (4.24), and Marcus collects reminders from other schools: a precept from the writings of the Epicureans, as Thomas Gataker, the seventeenth-century English editor, corrected the manuscripts' "Ephesians": "continually to remind oneself of one of those of old who practised virtue" (11.26), and the Pythagoreans' rule of looking at the heaven at dawn (11.27). Rusticus let him have "the notes of Epictetus" (1.7.3), the Stoic teacher whose lectures Arrian recorded. But time is short: "you are not going to read your little notebooks, nor … the extracts from writings that you were laying aside for yourself against old age" (3.14). The Meditations themselves, "the things addressed to himself" in the title of the first printed edition, can be read as the practice that 7.2 asks for: principles written out again and again, so that the impressions that keep them alive are rekindled.
Places to read
Every chapter in which δόγμα, ὁμοδογματεῖν or θεώρημα occurs, or a word of reminding (ὑπομιμνήσκειν, ὑπόμνησις, ὑπομνηστικός, παρυπόμνησις, ὑπόμνημα, ὑπομνημάτιον, ἀναμιμνήσκειν), or πρόχειρος in any of its senses, in the order of the book, by section where the chapter is divided; with 4.3.1, on the brief and elementary things. The other words of memory, μεμνῆσθαι (memnēsthai), "remember", μνήμη (mnēmē), μνημονεύειν (mnēmoneuein) and their compounds, are left out.
- 1.7.1GreekRusticus taught Marcus not to be drawn aside into sophistic ambition, nor to write treatises on doctrines.
- 1.7.3GreekThrough Rusticus Marcus came across the notes of Epictetus, which Rusticus let him have from his own house.
- 1.8.2GreekApollonius, a Stoic teacher, counted his skill in passing on doctrines as the least of his honourable qualities.
- 1.9.2GreekSextus found and ordered, with a firm grasp and by method, the principles necessary for life.
- 1.10GreekFrom Alexander the grammarian Marcus learned to correct a faulty expression not by reproach but by some tactful reminder.
- 1.16.2GreekAntoninus, Marcus' adoptive father, did not abandon an investigation early, content with the impressions that came first to hand.
- 1.17.6GreekThat Marcus still falls short of the life according to nature comes from not keeping the reminders of the gods.
- 2.3GreekA few sentences on providence and nature are to be enough and to be his principles; the thirst for books is to be thrown away.
- 3.13GreekPrinciples are to be kept ready, as doctors keep their instruments and knives at hand for sudden cases.
- 3.14GreekMarcus is not going to read his little notebooks or the extracts he was laying aside for old age; he must come to his own help now.
- 3.16.1GreekSensations belong to the body, impulses to the soul, principles to the mind.
- 4.2GreekNo act is to be done at random, nor otherwise than according to a doctrine that completes the art.
- 4.3.1GreekWhen Marcus retreats into himself, the things within into which he looks are to be brief and elementary, things that will suffice to send him back not resenting what he returns to.
- 4.3.4GreekAmong the things most ready to hand are to be two: that things do not touch the soul, and that all things change.
- 4.16GreekMarcus will seem a god within ten days if he turns back to the principles and reverence for reason.
- 4.24GreekAt each thing one must remind oneself to ask whether it is one of the things that are not necessary.
- 4.49.2GreekAt everything that leads towards distress Marcus is to use the principle that to bear it nobly is good fortune.
- 5.1.1GreekAt first light, reluctant to get up, Marcus is to have this ready: that he is rising to do the work of a man.
- 5.6.1GreekOne man is ready to reckon a favour to his account, another is not ready for this, a third does not even know what he has done.
- 5.9GreekIf acting on right principles is not thickly established in him, Marcus is to come back again, and return to philosophy as to a remedy, not a schoolmaster.
- 5.28GreekMarcus is to move the man who offends by reason, "show, remind"; if the man listens, Marcus will cure him, and there is no need for anger.
- 5.31GreekMarcus is to remember what he has come through and what he has been strong enough to endure.
- 6.48GreekThe merits of those who live alongside him are to be kept ready to hand, for nothing gladdens so much.
- 7.1GreekAt everything that happens Marcus is to have ready to hand that it is what he has seen often.
- 7.2GreekPrinciples die only if the impressions that correspond to them are quenched, and it is in Marcus' power perpetually to rekindle them.
- 7.27GreekMarcus is to reckon up the most favourable of things present, and remind himself how they would be sought after if they were not present.
- 7.64GreekIn every pain Marcus is to have ready to hand that pain is not shameful and does not make the understanding worse.
- 8.1GreekLiving well lies in doing what the nature of man seeks, and Marcus will do it if he has principles about good and bad from which come impulses and actions.
- 8.12GreekRoused from sleep with reluctance, Marcus is to remind himself that rendering social actions accords with his constitution.
- 8.14GreekWhoever he meets, Marcus is to ask what principles the man has about good and bad, and will not be astonished at what he does.
- 8.22GreekMarcus is to pay heed to the underlying thing, or the principle, or the activity, or what is meant.
- 8.36GreekMarcus is to remind himself that neither the future nor the past weighs on him, but always the present.
- 8.47GreekIf something in his own disposition distresses him, nothing prevents Marcus from setting right the principle.
- 9.3.2GreekDeath will release Marcus from men who do not share his principles; only life with those who held the same would hold him back.
- 9.29GreekWho will change men's principle? Without a change of principles there is only the slavery of men making a show of obeying.
- 9.42.1GreekAt every wrongdoer Marcus is to have ready to hand, and be reminded, that such people cannot fail to exist in the universe.
- 10.9GreekDay by day Marcus' sacred principles will be wiped away, all that he forms impressions of without studying nature.
- 10.10GreekMarcus asks whether those proud of catching flies, hares, bears or Sarmatians are not robbers, if one examines the principles.
- 10.34GreekTo one steeped in the true principles even Homer's line on the leaves is enough as a reminder of freedom from distress and from fear.
- 11.4GreekHaving done something socially, one has been benefited; this is always to meet Marcus ready to hand.
- 11.5GreekThe art of being good comes about honourably from doctrines about the nature of the whole and about man's own constitution.
- 11.6.1GreekTragedies were first brought on as reminders of what happens.
- 11.6.2GreekThe Old Comedy reminded, not uselessly, of freedom from vanity through its very plain speaking.
- 11.8GreekThe chapter on the branch cut off from the plant ends: "Grow on the same bush, but do not hold the same principles."
- 11.18.1GreekThe second of the nine heads on those who give offence: consider what compulsions of principles they have laid down.
- 11.18.5GreekIn fits of anger Marcus is to have ready to hand that it is not raging that is manly, but what is mild and gentle.
- 11.23GreekSocrates called the principles of the many Lamias, children's bugbears.
- 11.26GreekIn certain writings a precept was laid down: continually to remind oneself of one of those of old who practised virtue.
- 11.27GreekThe Pythagoreans' precept: at dawn to look up at the heaven, to be reminded of those who always do their own work, and of order, purity and nakedness.
- 12.9GreekIn the use of principles one must be like the pancratiast, who always has his hand, not the gladiator, who lays down his sword.
- 12.24GreekThree things to have ready to hand: a test for one's acts and for what happens from outside, what each thing is like until it receives a soul and until it gives it back, and into what it breaks up, and the view of human things from above.
Translation in this edition
Δόγμα is "principle" at all its places, and ὁμοδογματεῖν is "share your principles" (9.3.2) and "hold the same principles" (11.8); θεώρημα is "doctrine" at all four of its places. Ὑπομιμνήσκειν is always "remind" (4.24, 5.28, 7.27, 9.42.1, 11.6.2, 11.26, 11.27), ὑπόμνησις "reminder" (1.17.6, 10.34), the adjective ὑπομνηστικαί "as reminders" (11.6.1), and παρυπόμνησις "reminder" in "tactful reminder" (1.10). Ἀναμιμνήσκειν is "remind yourself" at 8.12, in the middle, and at 8.36, in the active with σεαυτόν (seauton), "yourself", but "remember" at 5.31, where the form is the same as at 8.12. Ὑπόμνημα is "notes" (1.7.3), and its diminutive ὑπομνημάτιον "little notebooks" (3.14). Πρόχειρος is "ready to hand" (6.48, 7.1, 7.64, 9.42.1, 11.4, 11.18.5, 12.24), "most ready to hand" for the superlative (4.3.4), "ready" (5.1.1, and twice at 5.6.1 of a man prompt to reckon a favour), "at hand" for the doctors' instruments (3.13) and "first to hand" of impressions that content a man who gives up an inquiry early (1.16.2). The "ready" of the principles at 3.13 renders another word, ἕτοιμα (hetoima). Ἀναζωπυρεῖν is "rekindle" and ἀναβιῶναι "come back to life" (7.2); στοιχειώδης is "elementary" (4.3.1) and, of fire, "elemental" (9.9.1). At 4.3.1 "shut out the whole court" rests on the correction of Capel Lofft, whose edition of the Meditations appeared in 1863, which J. H. Leopold, whose Oxford text of 1908 the edition prints, adopts; P, the lost manuscript from which the first edition was printed, has "to wash it clean" (see Inner retreat and citadel). Ὑπόθεσις (hypothesis) is "supposition" (4.21.1), "station" of Marcus' place in life (8.1, 11.7) and "occasion" beside "material" (10.31).
Greek forms and English renderings
Principles kept ready to hand · Meditations
δόγμα, dogma, "principle"; ὁμοδογματεῖν, homodogmatein, "share your principles", "hold the same principles"; θεώρημα, theōrēma, "doctrine"; ὑπομιμνήσκειν, hypomimnēskein, "remind"; ὑπόμνησις, hypomnēsis, "reminder"; ὑπομνηστικός, hypomnēstikos, "as reminders"; παρυπόμνησις, parypomnēsis, "reminder"; ἀναμιμνήσκειν, anamimnēskein, "remind yourself", "remember"; ὑπόμνημα, hypomnēma, "notes"; ὑπομνημάτιον, hypomnēmation, "little notebooks"; πρόχειρος, procheiros, "ready to hand", "ready", "at hand", "first to hand"; στοιχειώδης, stoicheiōdēs, "elementary", "elemental"; ἀναζωπυρεῖν, anazōpyrein, "rekindle"; ἀναβιῶναι, anabiōnai, "come back to life"; ὑπόθεσις, hypothesis, "supposition", "station", "occasion"
Epictetus and the Stoics
Epictetus put much of his teaching into one sentence about principles: "What troubles men is not things but their principles about things"; death is nothing terrible, but the principle that death is terrible is the terrible thing.1 He taught that principles must be at hand when they are needed: "When the need of each principle is present, one must have it ready to hand: at breakfast what concerns breakfast, in the bath what concerns the bath, in bed what concerns bed", and he goes on to quote the verses, which he elsewhere calls Pythagoras', that bid a man go over each day's acts before sleep.2 The Handbook ends with sayings to be kept "ready to hand in everything", in the phrase that Marcus uses (6.48, 12.24): a prayer to be led by Zeus and Destiny, verses on yielding to necessity, and two sayings of Socrates. It also sets the use of doctrines, such as not lying, before their proof, and complains that men lie while having the proof that one must not lie "ready to hand".3 Arrian, who recorded the lectures, says that he wrote down what he heard Epictetus say, as far as he could in his very words, to keep for himself as notes (ὑπομνήματα) of his thought and frankness; this is the word of 1.7.3.4 Seneca, the Roman Stoic of the first century, gives the word its weight in Latin: every art of contemplation has its own "decrees, which the Greeks call dogmata", and the decrees of philosophy, decreta, stand to its precepts as elements to limbs; a conviction that bears on the whole of life must be fixed in a man: "such as the conviction is, such will be what is done and what is thought".5 Marcus' "principles from which come impulses and actions" (8.1) can be read as saying the same.
Other ancient sources
Some of Marcus' reminders come from other schools, and their sources can be traced. The precept of 11.26, which Marcus assigns to the Epicureans in Gataker's correction of the manuscripts' "Ephesians", is known from Seneca, who closes his eleventh letter with it: one must choose some good man and keep him always before one's eyes, so as to live as if he were watching and do everything as if he saw; this, Seneca says, Epicurus prescribed.6 The Lamias of 11.23 are not in Plato, but the image is Socratic. In Plato's Crito Socrates will not yield even if the power of the many frightens them like children with bogeys, sending bonds, deaths and confiscations (46c); in the Phaedo Cebes, one of the Theban friends with him on his last day, asks him to persuade the child within them not to fear death as a bogey, and Socrates answers that one must sing charms to it every day (77e).7 Epictetus says that Socrates did well to call such things bogeys, since they seem terrible to us as masks do to children, through inexperience, and asks, "What is death? A bogey".8
ἀναβιόω
Attested: ἀναβιῶναι (anabiōnai; 7.2 twice). To live again, come back to life. Principles are not dead while their impressions can be rekindled: "It is open to you to come back to life. See things again as you used to see them; for in this lies coming back to life" (7.2). Lemma: ἀναβιόω.
ἀναζωπυρέω
Attested: ἀναζωπυρεῖν (anazōpyrein; 7.2). To kindle into flame again, from ζώπυρον (zōpyron), a live coal. Principles die only if the impressions that correspond to them are quenched, impressions which "it is in your power perpetually to rekindle" (7.2). Lemma: ἀναζωπυρέω.
ἀναμιμνήσκω
Attested: ἀναμιμνῄσκου (anamimnēiskou; 5.31, 8.12), ἀναμίμνῃσκε (anamimnēiske; 8.36). To remind, and in the middle to call to mind. Marcus tells himself, "remember too what you have come through, and what you have been strong enough to endure" (5.31); "remind yourself that it accords with your constitution and with human nature to render social actions" (8.12); "remind yourself that neither the future nor the past weighs on you, but always the present" (8.36). Lemma: ἀναμιμνήσκω.
δόγμα
Attested: δογμάτων (dogmatōn; 1.9.2, 5.9, 9.29, 10.34, 11.18.1, 12.9), δόγματα (dogmata; 2.3, 3.13, 3.16.1, 4.16, 7.2, 8.1 twice, 8.14 twice, 9.3.2, 10.9, 10.10, 11.23), δόγματι (dogmati; 4.49.2, 8.22), δόγμα (dogma; 8.47, 9.29). A principle, a settled conviction by which a man lives. Principles belong to the mind (3.16.1); from them "come impulses and actions" (8.1); they die only if the impressions that correspond to them are quenched (7.2); and they must be ready like a doctor's knives (3.13) and always to hand as the pancratiast has his hand (12.9). Of others: "what principles does this man have about good things and bad?" (8.14). Lemma: δόγμα.
θεώρημα
Attested: θεωρημάτων (theōrēmatōn; 1.7.1, 11.5), θεωρήματα (theōrēmata; 1.8.2), θεώρημα (theōrēma; 4.2). A doctrine, a proposition of philosophy as it is taught. Marcus learned not "to write treatises on doctrines" (1.7.1), yet no act is to be done "otherwise than according to a doctrine that completes the art" (4.2), and the art of being good comes "from doctrines" (11.5). Lemma: θεώρημα.
ὁμοδογματέω
Attested: ὁμοδογματούντων (homodogmatountōn; 9.3.2), ὁμοδογματεῖν (homodogmatein; 11.8). To hold the same principles as another. Death will not be a release "from men who share your principles" (9.3.2); "Grow on the same bush, but do not hold the same principles" (11.8). Lemma: ὁμοδογματέω.
παρυπόμνησις
Attested: παρυπομνήσεως (parypomnēseōs; 1.10). A reminder given in passing. Alexander the grammarian corrected a faulty expression by giving the right one "by some other such tactful reminder" (1.10). Lemma: παρυπόμνησις.
πρόχειρος
Attested: προχείροις (procheirois; 1.16.2), πρόχειρα (procheira; 3.13, 6.48, 12.24), προχειροτάτοις (procheirotatois; 4.3.4), πρόχειρον (procheiron; 5.1.1, 7.1, 7.64, 9.42.1, 11.4, 11.18.5), πρόχειρος (procheiros; 5.6.1 twice). Ready to hand. Of the doctors' instruments, "at hand" (3.13); of the sayings Marcus keeps for use, "ready to hand": "These three things one must have ready to hand" (12.24). At 1.16.2 the impressions "that came first to hand" are those that content a man who gives up an investigation early, and at 5.6.1 a man is "ready" to reckon a favour to his account. Lemma: πρόχειρος.
στοιχειώδης
Attested: στοιχειώδη (stoicheiōdē; 4.3.1), στοιχειῶδες (stoicheiōdes; 9.9.1). Elementary, of the nature of an element. When Marcus retreats into himself, the things within into which he looks are to be "brief and elementary" (4.3.1); at 9.9.1 fire is carried upward "because of the elemental fire". Lemma: στοιχειώδης.
ὑπόθεσις
Attested: ὑποθέσει (hypothesei; 4.21.1), ὑπόθεσις (hypothesis; 8.1), ὑπόθεσιν (hypothesin; 10.31, 11.7). What is set down beneath: a supposition laid down for argument, and so the situation in which a man is placed. In argument, "This is what one might answer on the supposition that souls live on" (4.21.1; see Soul); of Marcus' own situation, probably his position as emperor, as the edition's note says, "and the station too works against it" (8.1) and "there is no other station of life so fitted for philosophy as this in which you now happen to be!" (11.7; see Philosophy); beside "material", of the things of life as exercises for reason, "What material and what occasion you flee!" (10.31). Lemma: ὑπόθεσις.
ὑπομιμνήσκω
Attested: ὑπομιμνῄσκειν (hypomimnēiskein; 4.24), ὑπόμνησον (hypomnēson; 5.28), ὑπομιμνῄσκεσθαι (hypomimnēiskesthai; 7.27, 11.26), ὑπομνησθῆναι (hypomnēsthēnai; 9.42.1), ὑπομιμνῄσκουσα (hypomimnēiskousa; 11.6.2), ὑπομιμνῃσκώμεθα (hypomimnēiskōmetha; 11.27). To remind, to bring back to mind. Marcus reminds himself (4.24, 7.27), is told to "show, remind" the man who offends (5.28), and records the reminders of the Old Comedy (11.6.2), of a precept of the Epicureans (11.26) and of the Pythagoreans' dawn (11.27). Lemma: ὑπομιμνήσκω.
ὑπόμνημα
Attested: ὑπομνήμασιν (hypomnēmasin; 1.7.3). A note or memorandum, a record kept to remind. Through Rusticus Marcus came across "the notes of Epictetus" (1.7.3). Lemma: ὑπόμνημα.
ὑπομνημάτιον
Attested: ὑπομνημάτια (hypomnēmatia; 3.14). A little note, the diminutive of ὑπόμνημα. Marcus tells himself, "you are not going to read your little notebooks" (3.14). Lemma: ὑπομνημάτιον.
ὑπόμνησις
Attested: ὑπομνήσεις (hypomnēseis; 1.17.6), ὑπόμνησιν (hypomnēsin; 10.34). A reminding, a reminder. Marcus' falling short of the life according to nature comes "from not keeping the reminders of the gods, and all but their instructions" (1.17.6); to one steeped in the true principles even the briefest saying is "enough as a reminder of freedom from distress and from fear" (10.34). Lemma: ὑπόμνησις.
ὑπομνηστικός
Attested: ὑπομνηστικαί (hypomnēstikai; 11.6.1). Serving to remind. "First, tragedies were brought on as reminders of what happens" (11.6.1). Lemma: ὑπομνηστικός.
Source note
1. Epictetus, Handbook 5.
2. Epictetus, Discourses 3.10.1–3; the verses are "that of Pythagoras" at 4.6.32.
3. Epictetus, Handbook 53 and 52.
4. Arrian, letter to Lucius Gellius, prefaced to Epictetus' Discourses, 2.
5. Seneca, Letters 95.10, 95.12 and 95.44.
6. Seneca, Letters 11.8–9 (Epicurus fr. 210 Usener).
7. Plato, Crito 46c; Phaedo 77e.
8. Epictetus, Discourses 2.1.15–17.