People

Alexander the Platonist

Ἀλέξανδρος; ἀσχολέω; ἀσχολία; ἄσχολος

He is named once, for a single rule: "not often, nor without necessity", to say or write "I am busy", nor by this means "continually to excuse myself from the duties that arise from relations with those who live alongside us" (1.12).

From the book

Meditations

Marcus Aurelius · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAlexander the Platonist is usually identified, as the edition's note says, with Alexander of Seleucia, the sophist nicknamed "Clay-Plato", Marcus' secretary for Greek letters, whose life Philostratus tells in his Lives of the Sophists.
  • In the MeditationsHe is named once, for a single rule: "not often, nor without necessity", to say or write "I am busy", nor by this means "continually to excuse myself from the duties that arise from relations with those who live alongside us" (1.12).
  • In this editionἈλεξάνδρου τοῦ Πλατωνικοῦ (Alexandrou tou Platōnikou) is "Alexander the Platonist", kept apart by its epithet from "Alexander the grammarian" (1.10), Marcus' teacher of Greek, and from Alexander of Macedon, the conqueror (3.3, 6.24, 8.3, 9.29, 10.27); ἄσχολός εἰμι (ascholos eimi) is "I am busy".
  • A place to read1.12, where Marcus learns not to say "I am busy" often or without necessity, nor to make business a standing excuse from his duties to the people around him.

Meaning

Ἀλέξανδρος (Alexandros) was a common Greek name, and Book I tells its two Alexanders apart by their callings: the grammarian, Alexander of Cotiaeum as the edition's note at 1.10 names him, and the Platonist. Πλατωνικός (Platōnikos), "of Plato", is said of a man who follows Plato; Marcus uses it once more, of "Demetrius the Platonist" among the "sharp men" long dead (8.25; see Death).

The edition's note gives the usual identification, with Alexander of Seleucia. Philostratus says that most people called him Πηλοπλάτων (Pēloplatōn), "Clay-Plato", that his city was Seleucia in Cilicia, and that he was on his way to the Paeonian peoples, summoned by the emperor Marcus, who was campaigning there and had given him the office of writing letters to the Greeks.1 Philostratus nowhere in the Lives calls him a Platonist; the nickname, and an office spent on letters, can be read as what ties him to 1.12.

Use in the book

The rule is qualified, not a ban. Its first words, "not often, nor without necessity" (1.12), allow the plea "I am busy" when it is necessary and rare. What is refused is a habit and a use, "continually to excuse myself from the duties that arise from relations with those who live alongside us, pleading the business in hand" (1.12; see Duty and fitting action). The duties are owed to the people a man lives among, and business is not to be made a standing defence against them. If Alexander is the secretary of Philostratus, the rule about letters came from a man whose office was the emperor's Greek correspondence, and can be read as a courtesy of that trade turned into a duty.

Busyness returns in Marcus' self-examination, and there the fault is placed in the man himself. Among the things to look at bare is "who is the cause of his own busyness" (12.8; see Cause and matter), and the man who has put off the body "has let go all busyness and serious pursuits" (10.11; see Contentment and self-sufficiency). Beside these, 1.12 can be read as the first step of the same thought: business is first an excuse to others, and then something a man makes for himself.

The Platonist of Book I teaches no Plato. As Alexander the grammarian is remembered for correcting another's faulty expression without reproof (1.10; see Kindness and correction), the Platonist is remembered for a rule of courtesy. What Marcus keeps of both is a manner towards other people, not a doctrine.

Places to read

The one place where Alexander the Platonist is named; the other places of the name Alexander, and the places of ἀσχολία (ascholia) and ἀσχολεῖσθαι (ascholeisthai), are given in the sub-entries.

  1. 1.12GreekFrom Alexander the Platonist Marcus learned not to say or write "I am busy" often or without necessity, nor by this means continually to excuse himself from the duties that arise from relations with those who live alongside him.

Translation in this edition

Ἀλεξάνδρου τοῦ Πλατωνικοῦ is "Alexander the Platonist" (1.12), and Πλατωνικός is "the Platonist" at both its places (1.12, 8.25; see Philosophy). Ἄσχολός εἰμι is "I am busy", given in quotation marks as words said or written; the verb ἀσχολεῖσθαι (ascholeisthai) is "overbusy" (8.51) and "be busied" (12.2), and ἀσχολία (ascholia) "busyness" (10.11, 12.8). Παραιτεῖσθαι (paraiteisthai) is "excuse myself", προβαλλόμενον τὰ περιεστῶτα πράγματα (proballomenon ta periestōta pragmata) "pleading the business in hand", τὰ καθήκοντα (ta kathēkonta) "the duties" (see Duty and fitting action), σχέσεις (scheseis) "relations" and τοὺς συμβιοῦντας (tous symbiountas) "those who live alongside us" (see Duty and fitting action); ἐπιστολή (epistolē) is "a letter" (see Speech and silence). J. H. Leopold, whose Oxford text of 1908 the edition prints, reports τοιούτου τρόπου (toioutou tropou), "such a means", for τούτου τοῦ τρόπου (toutou tou tropou), "this means", in P, the lost manuscript from which the first edition was printed, and in the Suda, the lexicon that Leopold's testimonia, the notes under his text on ancient authors who quote or parallel it, cite for the passage under ἄσχολος; A, the Vatican manuscript, has the aorist προβαλόμενον (probalomenon) for "pleading".

Greek forms and English renderings

The Platonist remembered for a rule of courtesy · Meditations

Ἀλέξανδρος, Alexandros, "Alexander"; Πλατωνικός, Platōnikos, "the Platonist"; ἄσχολος, ascholos, "busy"; ἀσχολία, ascholia, "busyness"; ἀσχολεῖσθαι, ascholeisthai, "overbusy", "be busied"

Other ancient sources

Philostratus' Alexander is a sophist of the display speech, handsome and rich. His father bore the same name and was most able in the speeches of the law courts; he himself had a curled beard, large soft eyes and very white teeth, and spent his wealth on pleasures no one could blame. As a grown man he went on an embassy for Seleucia to the emperor Antoninus, and, thinking that the emperor was not attending, raised his voice: "Attend to me, Caesar." Antoninus, nettled, answered that he was attending and understood him: "you are the one who dresses his hair, brightens his teeth, pares his nails and is always breathing of perfume".2 His working life was spent mostly at Antioch, Rome and Tarsus and all over Egypt. On his way to Marcus he stopped at Athens and declaimed there, and Herodes Atticus, the Athenian sophist and consul, Marcus' teacher of Greek oratory, came to hear him;3 afterwards, when Herodes asked his pupils what they thought of the sophist, Sceptus of Corinth said that he had found the clay but was looking for the Plato, and Herodes told him to say that to no one else, and to think of Alexander rather as a sober Scopelian, after the sophist of that name.4 One of his speeches, urging the sick of the plains to move into the mountains, makes the craftsman of the universe throw the plains down as the baser matter and raise up the mountains as dignities, which the sun greets first and leaves last.5 His teachers were Favorinus of Arelate, the philosopher and orator, and Dionysius, and Philostratus records his end without deciding it: some said he died among the Celts still writing the emperor's letters, others in Italy after giving them up, some at sixty and some younger.6 Beyond the nickname, the craftsman of the universe can be read as the nearest the life comes to Plato; of the rule Marcus remembers, the life gives no trace but the letters.

Ἀλέξανδρος

Attested: Ἀλεξάνδρου (Alexandrou; 1.10, 1.12, 10.27), Ἀλέξανδρος (Alexandros; 3.3, 6.24, 8.3), Ἀλέξανδρον (Alexandron; 9.29). A man's name, borne in the Meditations by three men. Alexander the grammarian, Alexander of Cotiaeum, Marcus' teacher of Greek, taught him not to pounce reproachfully on a faulty expression but to introduce the right one tactfully (1.10; see Kindness and correction). Alexander the Platonist taught him not to plead "I am busy" often or without necessity (1.12). Alexander of Macedon, the conqueror, stands among the dead: with Pompey, the Roman general, and Gaius, that is Julius Caesar, "after so often destroying whole cities root and branch … themselves at last departed from life" (3.3; see Death); he and his muleteer "came, in death, to the same state" (6.24; see Providence and atoms); with Gaius and Pompey, "what are they beside Diogenes and Heraclitus and Socrates?" (8.3; see Cause and matter); with Philip, his father, and Demetrius of Phalerum, who governed Athens for Cassander, "They will see to it, if they saw what the common nature wanted and schooled themselves; but if they played the tragic part, no one has condemned me to imitate" (9.29; see Exemplary lives); and his court is one of the "whole dramas and scenes of one form" that come round again (10.27; see Drama and role). Lemma: Ἀλέξανδρος.

ἀσχολέω

Attested: ἀσχολεῖσθαι (ascholeisthai; 8.51), ἀσχολήσεται (ascholēsetai; 12.2). To be without leisure, to be busy or taken up with something. Among the faults Marcus forbids himself, to be "overbusy in life" (8.51); and "he who does not look at the bits of flesh that lie around him, still less, surely, will he be busied with gazing at clothing and house and fame …" (12.2). Lemma: ἀσχολέω.

ἀσχολία

Attested: ἀσχολίας (ascholias; 10.11, 12.8). Want of leisure, busyness. The man who has put off the body "has let go all busyness and serious pursuits" (10.11; see Contentment and self-sufficiency); among the things to look at bare, "who is the cause of his own busyness" (12.8; see Cause and matter). At 4.18 P has ἀσχολίαν (ascholian), "lack of leisure", where Leopold prints εὐσχολίαν (euscholian), "leisure", the correction of Thomas Gataker, the seventeenth-century English editor (see Attention and self-examination). Lemma: ἀσχολία.

ἄσχολος

Attested: ἄσχολος (ascholos; 1.12). Without leisure, busy. From Alexander the Platonist, "not often, nor without necessity, to say to anyone or write in a letter 'I am busy'" (1.12), a passage that the Suda cites under the word. Lemma: ἄσχολος.

Source note

1. Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists 2.5.1 and 2.5.3 (570–571 Olearius).

2. Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists 2.5.1–2 (570–571 Olearius).

3. Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists 2.5.3 (571–572 Olearius); for Herodes as Marcus' teacher, Historia Augusta, Marcus 2.4.

4. Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists 2.5.3 (573 Olearius).

5. Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists 2.5.4 (575 Olearius).

6. Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists 2.5.4 (576 Olearius).