From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA realist is an artist who represents things as they are, including their imperfections, rather than as they ought to be.
- In The RenaissanceBotticelli's sympathy "makes him, visionary as he is, so forcible a realist" (BOT §6).
- In this editionThe note at BOT §6 says that Pater "turns a category that Dante judges severely into a place from which a painter can observe human uncertainty sympathetically".
- A place to readBOT §6, with ROB §6.
Meaning
In philosophy a realist held that universals are real; in the painting of Pater's own generation the word had become a banner. In 1855, when the jury of the Exposition Universelle refused his Burial at Ornans and The Painter's Studio, the French painter Gustave Courbet showed forty of his paintings in a pavilion of his own under the sign "Du Réalisme", and "realism" came to mean an art of ordinary subjects painted without idealisation.1 Pater's book uses the word in both an older and a newer way, as a danger in sculpture and as a virtue in a painter who sees men truly.
Use in the book
The noun appears in four paragraphs, and in three of them realism is a weight. Sculpture tends "to a hard realism" (ROB §6; see Hard realism). Michelangelo's unfinished surfaces avoid "a too heavy realism" and relieve pure form of "its stiff realism" (ROB §10; see Incompleteness). Greek sculpture's colour, more or less conventional, never permitted "more than a very limited realism" (WIN §34). In sculpture realism is the stone's own tendency, toward the heavy and the fixed, and art must lighten it. In the Leonardo essay the word belongs to history: the fifteenth century's movement was partly the Renaissance and partly "the coming of what is called the 'modern spirit,' with its realism, its appeal to experience" (LEO §17).
The one use of "realist" reverses the value. At the end of the paragraph on the middle world Pater says that Botticelli's sympathy "makes him, visionary as he is, so forcible a realist" (BOT §6; see Sympathy). "Visionary as he is" grants the paradox. The visionary paints his mood, not the scene (see Visionary painter); yet this visionary is a realist, and "forcible" makes him a strong one.
The paradox dissolves when one sees what Botticelli is realist about. Not about surfaces: his flesh is grey, his colour cold, his Venus framed in medieval ornament. About people: "men and women, in their mixed and uncertain condition" (BOT §6; see Complexion of humanity). Botticelli's figures are true to the mixture of which most of humanity is made (see Complexion of humanity; Untempered). His realism is of the moral complexion, and its instrument is sympathy (see Sympathy).
The word can be read as Pater's quiet answer to the realism of his own day. Courbet's realism was of subject and surface, the stone-breakers and the burial at Ornans; Pater finds a deeper realism in a fifteenth-century visionary whose surfaces are anything but literal. The truth that counts, on this reading, is the truth of feeling about human beings, and a painter who sees through a mood may see it better than one who only looks.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "realist" or "realism" occurs, in the order of the book.
- BOT §6Botticelli's sympathy makes him, visionary as he is, so forcible a realist.
- ROB §6Sculpture tends to a hard realism, a one-sided presentment of mere form.
- ROB §10Michelangelo's incompleteness relieves the stiff realism of pure form.
- LEO §17The fifteenth century saw the coming of the modern spirit, with its realism, its appeal to experience.
- WIN §34The colour of Greek sculpture never permitted more than a very limited realism.
In this edition
The note at BOT §6, on "make great refusals", reads: "An echo of the anonymous figure associated with the 'great refusal' in Inferno III. Pater turns a category that Dante judges severely into a place from which a painter can observe human uncertainty sympathetically."
Source note
1. Gustave Courbet, Exhibition et vente de 40 tableaux et 4 dessins de l'œuvre de M. Gustave Courbet (Paris, 1855), with his statement on realism.