Art and its materials

Theme or motive

theme or motive; theme; motive, motives

The governing idea of a work, which survives when its accessories are changed and which in Greek art saturates the form

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe subject or leading idea of a work of art, which variations may treat in many ways.
  • In The Renaissance"At other times the original remains, but has been a mere theme or motive, a type of which the accessories might be modified or changed; and these variations have but brought out the more the purpose, or expression of the original" (LEO §25).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readLEO §25, with WIN §28.

Meaning

"Theme" is the Greek thema, a thing laid down, a proposition; "motive" is the Medieval Latin motivus, moving, and in English first meant what moves a person to act. In the criticism of art Pater's century gave "motive" the sense of the French motif and the Italian motivo: the subject or leading idea of a design, the element a work is built round. Both words belong also to music, where a theme is the tune that variations elaborate and a motive the short figure that recurs. Pater's "theme or motive" can be read in the musical sense: a type on which variations are made.

Use in the book

Pater reaches for the phrase when he sorts the copies made by Leonardo's pupils. Some copies rough out "some fine hint or sketch of his"; some re-echo lost originals; "At other times the original remains, but has been a mere theme or motive, a type of which the accessories might be modified or changed; and these variations have but brought out the more the purpose, or expression of the original" (LEO §25). "Mere" can be read as the pupils' view. For them the original was only a theme to be varied, and Pater's sentence turns their indifference into evidence: by changing the accessories they showed what did not change. The example follows at once. In the Saint John of the Louvre the reed cross fades in one copy and disappears in another, and the figure is left with its likeness to Bacchus (LEO §25; see Symbolical invention; Decayed gods). The accessories were the saint's; the motive can be taken as something else, the "treacherous smile" (LEO §25), and the variations bring it out.

The word "motive" has this artistic sense through much of the book. The ideal intensity of love is "the motive which really unites together the fragments" of Aucassin and Nicolette (FRE §29; see Ideal intensity of love); comradeship is "especially a classical motive" (FRE §7; see Classical motive); the creation of life, "coming always as relief or recovery", is "in various ways the motive of all his work" in Michelangelo (MIC §4; see Relief or recovery). The Pleiad made of the ancient mythology, which the Italians had found "a motive so weighty and severe", "a mere toy" (BEL §16). And Giorgione, for all his small surviving work, expresses "in elementary motive and principle" the spirit that Titian spreads over his whole life (GIO §13).

The Winckelmann essay gives the word its theory. Greek sculpture is "a perfect medium of expression for one peculiar motive of the imaginative intellect", and it "renounces all those attributes of its material which do not forward that motive" (WIN §34; see Plastic art). Its motive is not attached from outside, as a meaning is attached to an allegory; it "saturates and is identical with" the sensuous form (WIN §28; see Sensuous form). In sculpture, spirituality "takes up the whole given material, and penetrates it with an imaginative motive" (WIN §33; see Spiritual). Set beside the Leonardo essay, the doctrine divides the arts. In Greek sculpture the motive is the form, and nothing can be taken away without loss. In Leonardo's painting the motive survives the loss of its accessories, and the variations of his pupils make it visible. The Giorgione essay joins the two in its ideal instant: the highest dramatic poetry, and the painting of Giorgione's school that selects such instants, give "some brief and wholly concrete moment" into which "all the motives, all the interests and effects of a long history, have condensed themselves" (GIO §20; see Ideal instant).

Places to read

The paragraph in which "theme" occurs, and every paragraph in which "motive" names the subject or governing idea of a work of art or literature, in the order of the book; the motives of a life or a culture (PRE §§6, 9; WIN §§10, 12, 16, 25, 38, 42) are not listed.

  1. FRE §7Comradeship is especially a classical motive.
  2. FRE §29The ideal intensity of love is the motive that unites the fragments of Aucassin and Nicolette.
  3. MIC §4The creation of life is in various ways the motive of all Michelangelo's work.
  4. LEO §25The original has been a mere theme or motive, whose accessories might be changed.
  5. GIO §13Giorgione expresses in elementary motive and principle the spirit of Venetian art.
  6. GIO §20In the ideal instants of dramatic poetry and of Giorgione's school, all the motives of a long history are condensed.
  7. BEL §16The Pleiad made the ancient mythology, a motive so weighty to the Italians, a mere toy.
  8. WIN §28The motive saturates and is identical with the sensuous form.
  9. WIN §33In sculpture spirituality penetrates the whole material with an imaginative motive.
  10. WIN §34Sculpture is a perfect medium for one peculiar motive of the imaginative intellect.
  11. WIN §36Browning's poem has the clear ring of a central motive.