From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Meaning
Attested: technical criticism (LEO §3); technical or antiquarian criticism (BOT §10); technical (GIO §§1, 2, 12). Technical criticism is the connoisseur's criticism, which judges a work by its handling and settles what a master really painted. Pater gives it its task in the Leonardo essay: after Carlo Amoretti's critique of Vasari's anecdotes, "For others remain the editing of the thirteen books of his manuscripts, and the separation by technical criticism of what in his reputed works is really his, from what is only half his, or the work of his pupils" (LEO §3; see Antiquarianism). The phrase assigns the work and steps aside from it, for "a lover of strange souls" may still analyse the impression the works make on him (LEO §3; see Impression). The Botticelli essay had drawn the same line between "mere technical or antiquarian criticism" and the general criticism that places a painter in culture (BOT §10; see General criticism). The Giorgione essay gives technical criticism a face, the "new Vasari" that scrutinises the great reputation "thread by thread" (GIO §14; see New Vasari), and sets its limits in the opening paragraphs, where pictorial charm is "neither a mere poetical thought or sentiment, on the one hand, nor a mere result of communicable technical skill in colour or design, on the other" (GIO §1). Pater's attitude is respectful and firm: technical criticism tells us what is the master's, and something else must tell us what the master is.