Criticism and method

Impression

impression, impressions

The critic's first fact and the last unit of experience

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAn impression is the mark a thing leaves by pressing on another, and so the effect an object makes on a mind. Philosophy had given the word a stricter sense: the perception in its first and liveliest form, as against the fainter idea that thought keeps of it.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Preface makes the impression the first thing the critic must know: "the first step towards seeing one's object as it really is, is to know one's own impression as it really is" (PRE §2). The essays ask what impression a painter leaves and where it comes from (LEO §3, GIO §25). In the Conclusion the word takes in experience itself: under reflexion "each object is loosed into a group of impressions" (CON §3), and the task becomes "courting new impressions" (CON §5).
  • In this editionImpression is the first of the edition's Key Words and has a Glossary entry; the note at C73 §3 sets the 1873 "swarm of impressions" beside the 1893 "group of impressions".
  • A place to readPRE §§2–3, where the critic's questions are put and the impression of pleasure is traced to its source.

Meaning

The Latin impressio is a pressing in, and the printer's impression, a sheet pulled from an inked plate, keeps the physical sense; Pater uses it in this sense in one passage only, of the Florentine Dante of 1481, a few copies of which have the blank spaces filled with "impressions of engraved plates" (BOT §3). Carried over to the mind, an impression is the effect a thing makes on someone, and in common speech an opinion not yet tested: words of Leonardo "trenchant enough to justify this impression, are not recorded" (LEO §2). Philosophy had sharpened the word. David Hume began the first book of his Treatise of Human Nature (1739) by dividing all perceptions into impressions and ideas, the impressions being the sensations, passions and emotions in their first and most forceful arrival, the ideas their fainter copies in thought.1 Pater's Conclusion uses the word close to that sense, for what remains when objects have been dissolved into "colour, odour, texture" (CON §3).

Use in the book

The Preface begins with the impression as a fact to be known. To the aim of criticism Matthew Arnold had set, to see the object as it really is, Pater adds a first step, "to know one's own impression as it really is, to discriminate it, to realise it distinctly" (PRE §2; see To see the object as in itself it really is). The questions that follow are questions about the impression: what the song or picture is "to me", what effect it really produces, whether it gives pleasure and of what sort (PRE §2; see Pleasure). Pater prints "me" in italics, and the stress carries the Preface's relativism: the critic's object is a relation. Their answers are "the original facts with which the æsthetic critic has to do", and whoever experiences impressions strongly need not ask "what beauty is in itself" (PRE §2; see Metaphysical question).

The next paragraph says what the critic does with the fact. Each object affects one "with a special, a unique, impression of pleasure"; our education "becomes complete in proportion as our susceptibility to these impressions increases in depth and variety"; and the critic must separate the virtue by which a picture or a person "produces this special impression of beauty or pleasure, to indicate what the source of that impression is, and under what conditions it is experienced" (PRE §3; see Susceptibility; Virtue). The impression is where criticism starts, not where it ends. It is felt in the viewer, but the critic follows it back to a property of the object which another reader can go and find.

The essays keep this order, and lean on it where history gives out. Many works long given to Leonardo are not his, "But a lover of strange souls may still analyse for himself the impression made on him by those works, and try to reach through it a definition of the chief elements of Leonardo's genius" (LEO §3). The Giorgionesque grew partly "out of the immediate impression he made upon his contemporaries" (GIO §18), and the truth about Giorgione lies in "those more liberal and durable impressions" which go beyond the ascertained facts, above all in "a just impression" of his indirect influence (GIO §25; see Indirect influence). In the same essay each art has "an order of impressions distinct in kind", and to grasp this "is the beginning of all true æsthetic criticism" (GIO §1; see Æsthetic criticism). Here the word names the kind of effect that belongs to an art, not one viewer's experience of one work.

The word also measures the people of the book, each defined by what impressed them most. In Botticelli's Venus there is "a record of the first impression" made by the Hellenic spirit on minds that had turned back to it (BOT §8; see First impression). Two things touched Leonardo "beyond the depth of other impressions—the smiling of women and the motion of great waters" (LEO §10), and for him "the novel impression conveyed, the exquisite effect woven, counted as an end in itself" (LEO §24; see Temperament). Greek breadth comes of a culture "rectifying and concentrating its impressions into certain pregnant types" (WIN §35). In each case the impression received shapes what is made.

The Conclusion carries the word from criticism into experience as a whole. When reflexion plays on the objects that seem to press on us, "each object is loosed into a group of impressions—colour, odour, texture—in the mind of the observer" (CON §3). These impressions are "unstable, flickering, inconsistent", they "burn and are extinguished with our consciousness of them", and they shut each mind in, so that every impression is "the impression of the individual in his isolation" (CON §3; see Solitary prisoner). Analysis then divides each impression in time, until what is real in our life "fines itself down" to "a single sharp impression" (CON §3; see Tremulous wisp). Pater does not answer the dissolution with a doctrine. What we have to do, he says, is to be "for ever curiously testing new opinions and courting new impressions" (CON §5; see Courting impressions).

The two ends of the book can be read as one word under two lights. In the Preface the impression is a datum, held still long enough to be discriminated and traced to its source; in the Conclusion analysis shows that it never stands still. The discipline asked for is the same in both: to discriminate (see Discriminate).

Places to read

Every paragraph in which the word occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. PRE §2The first step in æsthetic criticism is to know one's own impression as it really is; whoever experiences impressions strongly need not ask what beauty is in itself.
  2. PRE §3Each object gives a special, unique impression of pleasure; education becomes complete as susceptibility to impressions increases; the critic shows the source of the impression and its conditions.
  3. BOT §3In a few copies of the 1481 Dante the spaces left for the illuminator hold impressions of engraved plates; in the Bodleian copy one of the three is printed upside down.
  4. BOT §5Botticelli's picture may be one of the compositions in which religious reverie recorded its impressions of the forms of beatified existence.
  5. BOT §8Botticelli's Venus is a record of the first impression made by the Hellenic spirit on minds turned back towards it.
  6. MIC §14Michelangelo's pressing from outward to unseen beauty gives the impression of something flitting and unfixed.
  7. MIC §20No one, Pater supposes, would come to the sacristy of San Lorenzo for consolation; for dignity of impression, perhaps.
  8. LEO §2No words of Leonardo are recorded that would justify the impression, given in Vasari's first edition, that he set philosophy above Christianity.
  9. LEO §3A lover of strange souls may analyse the impression made on him by the works given to Leonardo and reach through it a definition of his genius.
  10. LEO §10The smiling of women and the motion of great waters touched Leonardo beyond the depth of other impressions.
  11. LEO §13To think of Leonardo as a mere reasoner is to miss the impression he made on those around him.
  12. LEO §14Ludovico Sforza was susceptible of religious impressions and blended earthly passion with religious sentimentalism.
  13. LEO §24For Leonardo the novel impression conveyed counted as an end in itself.
  14. GIO §1The sensuous material of each art brings an order of impressions distinct in kind, and to grasp this is the beginning of æsthetic criticism.
  15. GIO §3Each art has its own specific order of impressions, yet passes into the condition of another.
  16. GIO §10Each art has its untranslatable order of impressions, yet all struggle after the law of music.
  17. GIO §18The Giorgionesque grew out of the immediate impression Giorgione made on his contemporaries.
  18. GIO §25The essential truth about Giorgione lies in the liberal and durable impressions that go beyond the ascertained facts.
  19. WIN §6Voltaire's impression on Winckelmann was never effaced.
  20. WIN §19Winckelmann's literary life gave those about him the impression of excitement, intuition and inspiration.
  21. WIN §35Greek breadth comes of a culture that concentrates its impressions into pregnant types.
  22. WIN §36Browning's poem gives the impression of one imaginative tone, a single creative act.
  23. CON §3Objects are loosed into a group of impressions; each is the impression of the individual in his isolation; analysis fines experience down to a single sharp impression.
  24. CON §5What we have to do is to be for ever testing new opinions and courting new impressions.
  25. C73 §3In 1873 experience is reduced to "a swarm of impressions".
  26. C73 §4Analysis tells us that the impressions of the individual are in perpetual flight and infinitely divisible, and leaves off with their passage and dissolution.
  27. C73 §6The 1873 text has the same call to be for ever courting new impressions.

In this edition

The edition makes Impression the first of its Key Words. In the Preface, it says, the impression is "the particular effect of a work on a particular person", which the critic must distinguish precisely; in the Conclusion the word "has a wider reach", impressions being "what experience resolves into when the apparent permanence of things falls away". The Glossary has "A felt effect to be discriminated and examined. In the Conclusion, an element of ever-changing experience." The note at CON §3 reads "personality" there as "the boundary of an individual point of view", the condition under which "every impression must be received and distinguished"; the note at C73 §3 sets the 1873 "swarm of impressions" beside the 1893 "group of impressions", the earlier word making the sensations "more visibly active and unstable". The 1873 text also has "tells us that those impressions of the individual" (C73 §4) where 1893 has "assures us that those impressions of the individual mind" (CON §3), and gives analysis a paragraph of its own.

Source note

1. David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature 1.1.1: the perceptions of the mind fall into two kinds, impressions and ideas, which differ in force and liveliness; under impressions Hume ranks sensations, passions and emotions as they first appear in the soul, and calls ideas their faint images in thinking.