Criticism and method

Authentic works

authentic works, authentic extant works; authenticity; authenticating, authenticates

"Authentic" comes through the Latin from the Greek authentēs, one who acts on his own authority; an authentic work is one truly by the artist whose name it bears.

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Meaning

Attested: authentic works (LEO §§25, 29; GIO §17, twice); authentic extant works (GIO §18); authenticity (GIO §14); authenticating (GIO §19); authenticates (WIN §22). "Authentic" comes through the Latin from the Greek authentēs, one who acts on his own authority; an authentic work is one truly by the artist whose name it bears. The question was a live one in Pater's time, when connoisseurs were reassigning the old attributions picture by picture. For Leonardo the answer is severe: "the number of Leonardo's authentic works is very small indeed", and yet "there is a multitude of other men's pictures through which we undoubtedly see him, and come very near to his genius" (LEO §25). The pictures of the Louvre are "his most authentic works, which came there straight from the cabinet of Francis the First" (LEO §29): the provenance is the proof. The Giorgione essay meets the same problem more boldly. Criticism "so freely diminishes the number of his authentic works" (GIO §17), yet "over and above the real Giorgione and his authentic extant works, there remains the Giorgionesque also" (GIO §18; see Giorgionesque). The two essays can be read as one argument: technical criticism separates what in his reputed works is "really his" (LEO §3; see Antiquarianism), and the æsthetic critic learns from all the works through which the artist's genius is seen. The edition's notes record later judgements, among them the Louvre's present assignment of the Bacchus to Leonardo's workshop (note at LEO §25).