Criticism and method

General criticism

general criticism

Criticism for the cultivated reader, set above the technical and the antiquarian

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordGeneral criticism is criticism that speaks to the educated reader at large about an artist's place in culture, as distinct from criticism of technique or of documents.
  • In The RenaissancePater writes that, "over and above mere technical or antiquarian criticism, general criticism may be very well employed in that sort of interpretation which adjusts the position of these men to general culture" (BOT §10).
  • In this editionThe note at BOT §10 says that "Pater's question registers a nineteenth-century hierarchy of reputation".
  • A place to readBOT §10, with FRE §23.

Meaning

"General" is from genus, kind: what concerns the whole kind and not a part of it, as in "the general reader" and "general culture" (see General culture). Pater's phrase defines itself by two neighbours. Technical criticism is the craftsman's and the connoisseur's, concerned with handling and attribution; antiquarian criticism is the historian's, concerned with dates and documents (see Antiquarian criticism). In Pater's decade both were growing fast. Crowe and Cavalcaselle's A New History of Painting in Italy (1864–66) had set the history of Italian painting on documents and attributions,1 and the method of attributing by the painter's habits in small details, which Giovanni Morelli was soon to publish, belongs to the technical side. General criticism claims a third ground.

Use in the book

The phrase comes twice in the last paragraph of the Botticelli essay, first in its question, whether "a secondary painter" is "a proper subject for general criticism" (BOT §10; see Secondary painter), then in its answer. The work of great painters "like Michelangelo or Leonardo" has become "a force in general culture" (BOT §10; see General culture), and general criticism may adjust their position to it, as the sentence quoted above says, "whereas smaller men can be the proper subjects only of technical or antiquarian treatment" (BOT §10).

The words "adjusts the position" are a surveyor's phrase, or a judge's: general criticism, on this account, assigns rank. Pater accepts the account and then adds a class it does not foresee. Some artists have "a peculiar quality of pleasure which we cannot get elsewhere" (BOT §10; see Peculiar quality of pleasure), "and these too have their place in general culture, and must be interpreted to it by those who have felt their charm strongly, and are often the object of a special diligence and a consideration wholly affectionate, just because there is not about them the stress of a great name and authority" (BOT §10). The second task is not ranking but interpretation, and the qualification for it is not learning but feeling: "those who have felt their charm strongly". Affection, which the antiquarian and the connoisseur set aside, becomes a credential.

The first essay had drawn the same line from the other side. An old text may have "an antiquarian interest", and antiquarianism "may often add greatly to the charm", but only where there is "a real, direct, æsthetic charm in the thing itself" (FRE §23; see Æsthetic charm). There the aesthetic critic needs the antiquarian; here the antiquarian is not enough. The two passages can be read as one doctrine: knowledge serves criticism, and criticism begins where something is felt. Pater's "general criticism" is the Preface's aesthetic criticism (see Æsthetic criticism) addressed to a public, and the Botticelli essay is its demonstration, a study of a secondary painter written by one who has felt his charm strongly.

Places to read

The paragraphs in which antiquarian or technical criticism is set against general or æsthetic criticism, in the order of the book; the phrase "general criticism" occurs only in BOT §10.

  1. FRE §23No merely antiquarian effort can give a work æsthetic value unless it has a real, direct, æsthetic charm in itself.
  2. BOT §10Over and above technical or antiquarian criticism, general criticism may well adjust the position of the great painters to general culture; artists of a peculiar quality of pleasure must be interpreted to it by those who have felt their charm.
  3. LEO §3Mere antiquarianism has little more to do with Leonardo's legend, but a lover of strange souls may still analyse the impression his works make.

In this edition

The note at BOT §10 says: "Pater's question registers a nineteenth-century hierarchy of reputation. The essay's answer shifts the criterion toward an artistic faculty that produces a particular experience even when its practitioner stands outside the conventional first rank."

Source note

1. J. A. Crowe and G. B. Cavalcaselle, A New History of Painting in Italy from the Second to the Sixteenth Century, 3 vols (London, 1864–66).