From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA new standard history of Italian painting, as Vasari's Lives had been the old one.
- In The Renaissance"And now, in the 'new Vasari,' the great traditional reputation, woven with so profuse demand on men's admiration, has been scrutinised thread by thread; and what remains of the most vivid and stimulating of Venetian masters, a live flame, as it seemed, in those old shadowy times, has been reduced almost to a name by his most recent critics" (GIO §14).
- In this editionThe note at GIO §14 says that Pater's "new Vasari" is "the history of North Italian painting by Joseph Archer Crowe and Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle, named in his own note".
- A place to readGIO §§14, 16.
Meaning
Giorgio Vasari's Lives of the Italian artists (1550, enlarged 1568) was for three centuries the standard history of Italian art, the source of its dates, attributions and legends. A "new Vasari" is the book that takes its place. Pater puts the phrase in quotation marks and names the book in a note of his own: Crowe and Cavalcaselle's A History of Painting in North Italy (1871), the work of documents and connoisseurship that tested the old attributions one by one.
Use in the book
The phrase first stands in the fourteenth paragraph, at the end of Pater's account of how Giorgione's fame grew and was lost. The great reputation "has been scrutinised thread by thread" (GIO §14). The figure belongs to the essay's weaving: the reputation was "woven with so profuse demand on men's admiration", and the critics unpick it one thread at a time, as the paragraph's earlier sentence says the science of the subject "has not made the past more real for us, but assured us only that we possess less of it than we seemed to possess" (GIO §14; see Traditional reputation). What remains "has been reduced almost to a name" (GIO §14; see Il fuoco Giorgionesco).
The sixteenth paragraph shows the new Vasari at work. Its standard is the Concert of the Pitti, whose "distinction", its "sustained evenness of perfection", becomes "the standard of Giorgione's genuine work" (GIO §16; see Distinction). The verdicts follow, the first going to the Friulian painter Pellegrino da San Daniele. "Finding here sufficient to explain his influence, and the true seal of mastery, its authors assign to Pellegrino da San Daniele the Holy Family in the Louvre, in consideration of certain points where it comes short of this standard" (GIO §16; see Liquid air). The Fête Champêtre goes to an imitator of Sebastiano del Piombo, the Venetian painter who later worked in Rome, the Tempest to Paris Bordone, a pupil of Titian, or perhaps to "some advanced craftsman of the sixteenth century", the Knight embracing a Lady to "a Brescian hand", Jacob meeting Rachel to a pupil of the Venetian painter Palma Vecchio. "And then, whatever their charm, we are called on to give up the Ordeal, and the Finding of Moses with its jewel-like pools of water, perhaps to Bellini" (GIO §16), Bellini being Giovanni Bellini, the Venetian master under whom Titian trained. The list is long and the tone patient; "whatever their charm" is the one sign of what the giving up costs.
Pater answers the new Vasari without disputing it. Its "negations and exceptions" are granted their place and then qualified into a salt of genuineness (GIO §25; see Negative criticism; Salt of genuineness). The new Vasari establishes the real Giorgione; the æsthetic philosopher keeps the Giorgionesque (GIO §18; see Æsthetic philosopher). The two kinds of knowledge are set side by side, and the essay's argument is that both are true.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "new Vasari" occurs, in the order of the book.
- GIO §14In the "new Vasari" Giorgione's great traditional reputation has been scrutinised thread by thread.
- GIO §16For the "new Vasari" the distinction of the Concert becomes the standard of Giorgione's genuine work.
- GIO §19For most of us, notwithstanding the negative criticism of the "new Vasari", the school still identifies itself with the famous pictures.
- GIO §25A "new Vasari" seems at first sight merely to have confused our apprehension of a delightful object.
In this edition
The edition's notes record how the new Vasari's verdicts have themselves been revised. The Concert, its standard of Giorgione's genuine work, is now attributed by the Uffizi to Titian (note at GIO §15). The Fête Champêtre, which it gave to an imitator of Sebastiano, the Louvre now catalogues as Titian's (note at GIO §16). The note on the Fête Champêtre says that the canvas "illustrates how dramatically attributions have shifted since the nineteenth-century debate Pater reports". The note on the Tempest takes Pater's picture for Giorgione's La tempesta, which the Gallerie dell'Accademia now holds. That picture entered the gallery only in 1932; the "Tempest, in the Academy at Venice" that the critics gave to Paris Bordone was the Storm at Sea painted for the Scuola Grande di San Marco, now given to Palma Vecchio and Paris Bordone.1
Source note
1. Gallerie dell'Accademia, Venice, catalogue entry for La tempesta (bought from Prince Giovanelli, 1932); J. A. Crowe and G. B. Cavalcaselle, A History of Painting in North Italy (London, 1871), vol. 2, chapter 3, on the storm picture of the Scuola di San Marco.