Criticism and method

Antiquarianism

antiquarianism, antiquarianisms; antiquarian

Historical interest, set against æsthetic value

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAntiquarianism is the study of the remains of the past, its objects, records and customs, for their historical interest.
  • In The RenaissanceIn Two Early French Stories antiquarianism "by a purely historical effort, by putting its object in perspective", can add to the charm of ancient literature, but cannot create it (FRE §23). The Botticelli essay asks for general criticism "over and above mere technical or antiquarian criticism" (BOT §10); the Leonardo essay finds that on the questions raised about his legend "mere antiquarianism has in this direction little more to do" (LEO §3).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the word; the note at LEO §3 sets the historical critic's work beside the interpreter's.
  • A place to readFRE §23, the first half of the paragraph.

Meaning

The Latin antiquarius was one devoted to antiquity. From the sixteenth century the English antiquary collected coins, inscriptions, charters and local customs; by the nineteenth the word could suggest a learned but narrow interest in facts for their own sake. Pater uses "antiquarianism" for the historical study of works of art and literature, as distinct from their criticism.

Use in the book

Pater's fullest statement comes in Two Early French Stories. Aucassin and Nicolette, he grants, "has much interest of a purely antiquarian order" for the student of manners and of Old French, though such an interest often means no æsthetic interest at all (FRE §23; see Antiquarian interest). He does not dismiss the method. "Antiquarianism, by a purely historical effort, by putting its object in perspective, and setting the reader in a certain point of view, from which what gave pleasure to the past is pleasurable for him also, may often add greatly to the charm we receive from ancient literature" (FRE §23). It is an aid, and its condition is the thing it cannot supply, a real æsthetic charm in the work (FRE §23; see Æsthetic charm). Pater distinguishes that charm from the "borrowed interest" an old work may acquire "through a true antiquarianism" (FRE §23; see Borrowed interest). The phrase "a true antiquarianism" is fair to it, and can be read as placing Pater's objection in its claims, not its work.

The later essays keep the line. Over and above "mere technical or antiquarian criticism", general criticism may relate the great painters to general culture, while "smaller men can be the proper subjects only of technical or antiquarian treatment"; Botticelli is an exception, since his peculiar quality of pleasure gives him a place in general culture (BOT §10; see General criticism). For Leonardo the questions Carlo Amoretti raised in 1804 about the dates and anecdotes of Vasari's legend have become "subjects of special study, and mere antiquarianism has in this direction little more to do"; attribution is left to "technical criticism", and the impression his works make remains for "a lover of strange souls" to analyse (LEO §3; see Impression). The essay ends where scholarship leaves off: "Two questions remain, after much busy antiquarianism, concerning Leonardo's death", his religion and whether Francis I was present, and Pater leaves them (LEO §36).

The essay on Winckelmann shows the other face of the word. His "boyish antiquarian wanderings among the ugly Brandenburg sandhills" (WIN §4) answer Goethe's eagerness "actually to handle the antique", and "from a few stray antiquarianisms, a few faces cast up sharply from the waves, Winckelmann, as his manner was, divines the temperament of the antique world" (WIN §31; see Temperament). In him antiquarianism becomes divination. The book can be read as drawing the line between the two not by subject but by temper: the same relics serve the antiquary's knowledge or the critic's sense of beauty, and Winckelmann has both.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "antiquarianism", "antiquarianisms" or "antiquarian" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §23An antiquarian interest often means no æsthetic interest; antiquarianism can add to the charm of old literature but cannot supply it.
  2. BOT §10Smaller men are proper subjects only of technical or antiquarian treatment; Botticelli belongs to general culture.
  3. LEO §3The questions raised about Leonardo's legend have become special studies, and mere antiquarianism has in this direction little more to do.
  4. LEO §36Two questions about Leonardo's death remain after much busy antiquarianism.
  5. WIN §4Winckelmann's boyish antiquarian wanderings among the Brandenburg sandhills.
  6. WIN §31From a few stray antiquarianisms Winckelmann divines the temperament of the antique world.