From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe power of calling up ideas and feelings beyond what is shown or said.
- In The Renaissance"In suggestiveness, only the Melancholia of Dürer is comparable to it; and no crude symbolism disturbs the effect of its subdued and graceful mystery" (LEO §30).
- In this editionThe note at BOT §1 says that Leonardo's mention of Botticelli belongs to "a discussion of landscape and the suggestive images one might discern in a stained wall or other marked surface".
- A place to readLEO §30, with WIN §§28, 34.
Meaning
"Suggest" is the Latin suggerere, to bring up from below, to supply, and in later Latin to prompt. What is suggested is put into the mind from beneath, without being stated. Suggestiveness is the power to do this, and in the criticism of Pater's century it became a term of praise for art that leaves the beholder something to supply. Its opposite is statement: the emblem that names its meaning, the allegory that can be read off.
Use in the book
The word's chief place is the opening of Pater's paragraph on La Gioconda. The picture is "the revealing instance of his mode of thought and work. In suggestiveness, only the Melancholia of Dürer is comparable to it" (LEO §30), and the sentence goes on to the crude symbolism that does not disturb it (see Crude symbolism; Refined and graceful mystery). The comparison can be read as double-edged. Albrecht Dürer's engraving Melencolia I (1514) is crowded with emblems that ask to be decoded, and it rivals La Gioconda in what it calls up; but the clause that follows separates them, for the portrait suggests as much without any sign at all. On this reading suggestiveness is independent of symbols and better without them.
The Winckelmann essay explains why the quality belongs to some arts more than others. The Venus of Melos "is in no sense a symbol, a suggestion, of anything beyond its own victorious fairness" (WIN §28; see Symbol): Greek sculpture means what it shows, and its meaning is used up in its form. Sculpture "has no backgrounds, no sky or atmosphere, to suggest and interpret a train of feeling" (WIN §34; see Pure form). Painting has them, and Leonardo's backgrounds of rock and water can be read as the means of his suggestion (see Veil of sight). On this account suggestiveness is a modern and a painterly quality, the gift of a "train of sentiment", as Pater calls what the Saint John of the Louvre sets going, "subtle and vague as a piece of music" (LEO §25; see Ostensible subject). The Giorgione essay draws the line to music: in that school "the presence of water" is "as characteristic, and almost as suggestive, as that of music itself" (GIO §23).
The quality is also the critic's opportunity. The Preface finds the value of earlier attempts to define beauty "in the suggestive and penetrating things said by the way" (PRE §1; see Universal formula), and the Winckelmann essay opens with Goethe classing Winckelmann himself "with certain works of art, possessing an inexhaustible gift of suggestion, to which criticism may return again and again with renewed freshness" (WIN §2; see Suggestion of life). What is suggestive cannot be exhausted, and so criticism of it never ends. The other uses keep the word near feeling and the romantic: Victor Hugo's medieval Paris is "so suggestive and exciting" (FRE §32), Botticelli's Calumnia has "the suggestiveness of an accident which identifies the image of Truth with the person of Venus" (BOT §9; see Veritas), and home-sickness is "that pre-eminently childish, but so suggestive sorrow" (BEL §21; see Home-sickness).
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "suggestiveness" or "suggestive" occurs, with WIN §§2, 28 and 34, in the order of the book.
- PRE §1Earlier attempts to define beauty are valued for the suggestive and penetrating things said by the way.
- FRE §32The Romantic school's medieval world, in Hugo's Notre-Dame de Paris, is so suggestive and exciting.
- BOT §9The suggestiveness of an accident identifies Truth with Venus.
- LEO §30In suggestiveness only the Melancholia of Dürer is comparable to La Gioconda.
- GIO §23In Giorgione's school the presence of water is almost as suggestive as music.
- BEL §21Home-sickness is a childish but so suggestive sorrow.
- WIN §2Goethe classes Winckelmann with works of art possessing an inexhaustible gift of suggestion.
- WIN §28The Venus of Melos is in no sense a symbol, a suggestion, of anything beyond its own fairness.
- WIN §34Sculpture has no backgrounds to suggest and interpret a train of feeling.
Later readings
Independently of Pater, the French poet Stéphane Mallarmé gave the doctrine its most famous form in 1891: to name an object, he told the journalist Jules Huret, is to suppress three quarters of the pleasure of a poem, which is made of guessing little by little; to suggest it, that is the dream.1
Source note
1. Stéphane Mallarmé, reply to Jules Huret, in Huret, Enquête sur l'évolution littéraire (Paris, 1891).