From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA mystery made fine and pleasing: something withheld that charms rather than baffles.
- In The RenaissanceTrenchant words "would have been out of keeping with a genius of which one characteristic is the tendency to lose itself in a refined and graceful mystery" (LEO §2).
- In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
- A place to readLEO §2, with LEO §§21, 30.
Meaning
"Mystery" comes from the Greek mystērion, a secret rite into which one is initiated, and so a thing hidden from the uninitiated (see Mystery). Pater's adjectives change its nature. "Refined" is purified, brought to fineness, as metal is refined; "graceful" is pleasing, the quality that charms without effort (see Abstract grace); "subdued" is softened, kept low. A refined and graceful mystery is not a puzzle or a doctrine. It is a quality of effect, the sense that something is withheld, made beautiful in itself.
Use in the book
Pater first uses the phrase as evidence in an argument. Vasari's first edition made Leonardo a bold speculator who set philosophy above Christianity (LEO §2; see Bold speculator). Pater answers: "Words of his, trenchant enough to justify this impression, are not recorded, and would have been out of keeping with a genius of which one characteristic is the tendency to lose itself in a refined and graceful mystery" (LEO §2). The argument sets "trenchant", cutting, sharp, against "mystery". A genius that loses itself in mystery does not make sharp declarations, and so the charge of unbelief rests on nothing he said. The phrase becomes evidence of character.
The same paragraph turns from the man to the work, where it is by "a certain mystery" that he "fascinates, or perhaps half repels" (LEO §2; see Fascination). The phrase then returns twice in a changed form. At the moment of bien-être, well-being, "a cloudy mysticism is refined to a subdued and graceful mystery" (LEO §21; see Bien-être; Mysticism). And of La Gioconda, "no crude symbolism disturbs the effect of its subdued and graceful mystery" (LEO §30; see Crude symbolism). The three uses can be read as a sequence. In the second paragraph the refined mystery is a tendency of the man; in the twenty-first it is what his art makes, and "refined" has become a verb, the action that turns mysticism into mystery; in the thirtieth it is the effect of the masterpiece, protected by the absence of any crude sign.
"Graceful" keeps the mystery on the side of pleasure. The mystery Pater values belongs to a painting that "pleases the eye while it satisfies the soul", and its opposite is twofold: the "cloudy" mysticism that the eye cannot take, and the "crude symbolism" that tells the eye too plainly. The phrase can be taken as the essay's account of its own method as well as Leonardo's. Pater does not explain the mystery; he describes it, and his best-known paragraph is a description of a face whose meaning stays withheld.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "graceful mystery" occurs, in the order of the book.