Images from nature and science

Return to nature

return to nature

The other half of the fifteenth century's movement, represented by Leonardo: nature as the painter's model and the student's book

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA going back to nature, rather than to models or rules, as the source of art and knowledge.
  • In The Renaissance"Raphael represents the return to antiquity, and Leonardo the return to nature. In this return to nature, he was seeking to satisfy a boundless curiosity by her perpetual surprises" (LEO §17).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase; the note at LEO §17 renders subtilitas naturae "The subtlety of nature" and says that "Pater invokes Bacon's contention that nature works with a subtlety that exceeds human senses and reasoning".
  • A place to readLEO §§9, 17–18.

Meaning

"Nature" is the Latin natura, from nasci, to be born: what things are by birth, and the whole order of things born. A return to nature is a recurring cry in the history of art. Every age that finds its models worn out turns from them to observation, and the cry is heard in Pater's own century as loudly as in the fifteenth. In the introduction to his volume on the Renaissance (1855) Michelet had said that the Middle Ages had no argument in their favour but their extreme duration and their "obstinate resistance to the return of nature" (résistance obstinée au retour de la nature).1 Ruskin, in the closing chapter of the first volume of Modern Painters (1843), told young painters to "go to nature in all singleness of heart", rejecting nothing and selecting nothing.2 Pater's return to nature is of another kind. It is not a rule of fidelity; it is a curiosity, and it seeks in nature what is most hidden.

Use in the book

The phrase belongs to the seventeenth paragraph of the Leonardo essay, where the movement of the fifteenth century is divided into "a return to antiquity, and a return to nature" (LEO §17; see Return to antiquity; Modern spirit). The next sentence gives the return its motive: Leonardo "was seeking to satisfy a boundless curiosity by her perpetual surprises", and a microscopic sense of finish by her finesse (LEO §17; see Finesse; Subtilitas naturae). Nature is "her", a person, and what Leonardo seeks from her is not a model but surprise and fineness. The rest of the paragraph is his science: the men of science he knew, the thirteen volumes of manuscript, the intuitions about the moon and the shells in the mountains (LEO §17; see Rapid intuition).

The essay had prepared this turn eight paragraphs earlier. His early work in Verrocchio's manner left him with "some seed of discontent", and he plunged into the study of nature (LEO §9; see The true mistress of higher intelligences). But the study he plunged into was not Ruskin's. He followed "the manner of the older students", brooding over "the hidden virtues of plants and crystals" and the lines of the stars (LEO §9; see Hidden virtues). Pater's Leonardo returns to nature by the old road of the magicians and the astrologers as well as by the new road of experiment, and the essay never separates them. The same sentence ends with "that subtilitas naturae which Bacon notices" (LEO §17), and Bacon's subtlety of nature is the warning that nature outruns the senses, as the essay's epigraph, Bacon's motto, had made man the servant and interpreter of nature (LEO §1; see Homo minister et interpres naturæ); the paragraph's first sentence had named the "modern spirit" and "its appeal to experience" (LEO §17).

The return ends in art. "He who thus penetrated into the most secret parts of nature preferred always the more to the less remote" (LEO §18; see Mixed lights), and the landscape he painted is "not of dreams or of fancy, but of places far withdrawn" (LEO §18; see Veil of sight). The return to nature, in this essay, is a return to nature's secrets, and its fruit is a landscape stranger than any dream. It can be set against what Leonardo had been before, "the cheerful, objective painter" through whose soul, "as through clear glass", the bright figures of Florentine life passed to the wall (LEO §10; see Objective painter). That painting was fidelity to the surface; Leonardo's return goes below it, and Pater counts the cost where curiosity comes in conflict with the desire of beauty and takes him too far below the outside of things (LEO §20; see Desire of beauty).

The Du Bellay essay calls the feeling modern: "The feeling for landscape is often described as a modern one" (BEL §22; see Sentiment of ruins). Leonardo, in whom "first appears the taste for what is bizarre or recherché in landscape" (LEO §18; see Bizarre), stands at its beginning.

Places to read

LEO §17, where the phrase occurs, with the paragraphs on Leonardo's turn to nature (LEO §§9–10) and on what it gave and cost his art (LEO §§18, 20), in the order of the book.

  1. LEO §9Nature was the true mistress of higher intelligences, and Leonardo plunged into the study of nature in the manner of the older students.
  2. LEO §10He was no longer the cheerful, objective painter.
  3. LEO §17Leonardo represents the return to nature, seeking to satisfy his curiosity by her perpetual surprises.
  4. LEO §18He penetrated into the most secret parts of nature and preferred the more to the less remote.
  5. LEO §20His curiosity tended to make him go too far below the outside of things.

Source note

1. Jules Michelet, Histoire de France, vol. 7, Renaissance (1855), introduction, §2.

2. John Ruskin, Modern Painters, vol. 1 (1843), part 2, section 6, chapter 3, §21.