History, culture and the Renaissance

Sentiment of ruins

the sentiment of ruins; ruins; ruined

The feeling for antiquity as ruin, which Pater calls modern and finds already in Du Bellay at Rome

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe feeling that ruins awake: melancholy, wonder and thought at the remains of the past.
  • In The RenaissanceThe feeling for antiquity, "the sentiment of ruins", is still more often called modern than the feeling for landscape, and Du Bellay has it (BEL §22).
  • In this editionThe note at BEL §22 says that Pater "takes Du Bellay's feeling for Roman ruins as something stronger than regret for lost grandeur".
  • A place to readBEL §22.

Meaning

A sentiment is a feeling with thought in it, more settled than an emotion; the sentiment of ruins is the feeling that the remains of the past awake, and the thought they give rise to, of time, loss and the end of things. The feeling had its vogue in the eighteenth century, when ruins became a favourite subject of painting, and Pater uses the phrase as the name of a modern feeling.

Use in the book

The twenty-second paragraph opens with a claim about history and turns it on Du Bellay. "The feeling for landscape is often described as a modern one; still more so is that for antiquity, the sentiment of ruins" (BEL §22). Pater reports the common view, "often described", and then corrects its chronology in one short sentence: "Du Bellay has this sentiment" (BEL §22). The poet of the sixteenth century has a feeling that is commonly called modern. The essay has already reported Sainte-Beuve's ranking of the Antiquités de Rome and the Regrets as poésie intime, "that intensely modern sort of poetry" (BEL §21; see Poésie intime), and the sentiment of ruins is a second modernity in the same poet.

What the sentiment is in him the next sentence says, and it is not what the reader expects. The ruins do not make Du Bellay mourn the greatness of Rome; the "duration of the hard, sharp outlines of things" grieves him, and he is consoled "by the thought that all must one day end" (BEL §22; see La grandeur du rien). The sentiment of ruins is in him a longing for the end, and it goes so far as the thought that the great whole "ought itself sometimes to perish and pass away" (BEL §22; see Le grand tout). It is the sentiment of a weary man, "passing his wearisome days among the ruins of ancient Rome" (BEL §22; see La grandeur du rien), and it can be read as the sentiment of ruins turned inside out: not grief that things pass, but grief that they last.

Pater does not mention it, but the French critic Denis Diderot, in his account of the paintings of ruins by the French painter Hubert Robert at the Salon of 1767, had given the modern sentiment its classic form: the ideas that ruins wake in him are great; everything is annihilated, everything perishes, everything passes; only the world remains, only time endures.1 Diderot's ruins teach that the world outlasts its works; Du Bellay's, as Pater reads them, make him think that the great whole itself ought sometimes to perish. The comparison shows how far Pater's Du Bellay goes beyond the sentiment that the eighteenth century made fashionable, and why Pater calls his mysticism "far-off" (BEL §22; see Mysticism).

The book's other ruins are smaller and nearer to romance. Aucassin and Nicolette keeps the eye on pleasant objects, "a garden, a ruined tower" (FRE §23; see Eye of the fancy), and Nicolette, escaping, comes to "a chink of the tower, which was old and ruined" and hears Aucassin weeping within (FRE §28). There the ruin is a setting for a story of love; in Rome it is the world's history and the poet's weariness at once. The Du Bellay essay can be read as giving the book's one account of ruins as a sentiment, and as making that sentiment modern by finding it, already complete, in the sixteenth century.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "ruins" or "ruined" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §23The story of Aucassin and Nicolette keeps the eye on pleasant objects, a garden, a ruined tower.
  2. FRE §28Nicolette, at a chink of the old and ruined tower, hears Aucassin weeping.
  3. BEL §22Du Bellay has the sentiment of ruins, and among the ruins of Rome is consoled by the thought that all must end.

Source note

1. Denis Diderot, Salon de 1767, on Hubert Robert: Les idées que les ruines réveillent en moi sont grandes. Tout s'anéantit, tout périt, tout passe. Il n'y a que le monde qui reste. Il n'y a que le temps qui dure.