From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordCriticism that proceeds by denial: this picture is not his, this story is not true.
- In The Renaissance"And now, finally, let me illustrate some of the characteristics of this School of Giorgione, as we may call it, which, for most of us, notwithstanding all that negative criticism of the 'new Vasari,' will still identify itself with those famous pictures at Florence, at Dresden and Paris" (GIO §19).
- In this editionThe note at GIO §14 says that the investigations of Crowe and Cavalcaselle "reshaped the catalog of Giorgione's work that Pater inherited".
- A place to readGIO §§19, 25.
Meaning
"Negative", from the Latin negare, to deny, is the quality of a statement that says no. Negative criticism is the scholarship that removes: it denies an attribution, dates a legend late, takes a picture from one name and gives it to another. Its results are real knowledge, but knowledge of a subtracting kind, and it leaves the reader with less than he thought he had.
Use in the book
The phrase stands in the opening sentence of the nineteenth paragraph, where Pater turns from the critics' verdict to the school itself. The school "for most of us, notwithstanding all that negative criticism of the 'new Vasari,' will still identify itself with those famous pictures at Florence, at Dresden and Paris" (GIO §19; see New Vasari). "Notwithstanding" admits the criticism and declines to be ruled by it. "For most of us" can be read as giving the reason: the association of the school with its pictures is a fact of the mind, and the critics' denial cannot unmake it. What it can do is change what the association means. The pictures that were Giorgione's become the pictures of the Giorgionesque (see Giorgionesque).
The essay's last paragraph returns to the critics with a plural noun. "As regards Giorgione himself, we have indeed to take note of all those negations and exceptions, by which, at first sight, a 'new Vasari' seems merely to have confused our apprehension of a delightful object, to have explained away in our inheritance from past time what seemed of high value there" (GIO §25). The sentence grants the negations their place, "we have indeed to take note", and then limits them twice: "at first sight", and "seems merely". Properly qualified, the next sentences say, the exceptions become a salt of genuineness in our knowledge (GIO §25; see Salt of genuineness; Indirect influence). The negative criticism is kept, and what it kept back is restored by another kind of knowledge.
The Leonardo essay had met the same kind of criticism earlier. Carlo Amoretti, in 1804, applied to Vasari's legend of Leonardo "a criticism which left hardly a date fixed, and not one of those anecdotes untouched" (LEO §3; see Legend), and Pater set his own analysis of impressions beside it. The Winckelmann essay gives "negative" a more surprising use. Winckelmann's serenity "is, perhaps, in great measure, a negative quality" (WIN §43; see Heiterkeit). There the negative is Winckelmann's serenity before Greek art, an absence that is a perfection. The two uses can be read together. A negation, in Pater, is not worthless because it denies: the critics' negations clear the ground, and the absence of shame in Winckelmann's serenity is itself a kind of fullness.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "negative" or "negations" occurs, in the order of the book.
- GIO §19For most of us, notwithstanding the negative criticism of the "new Vasari", the school still identifies itself with the famous pictures.
- GIO §25We have to take note of the negations and exceptions by which a "new Vasari" seems at first to have confused us.
- WIN §43Winckelmann's serenity is, perhaps, in great measure a negative quality, the absence of want, corruption or shame.