From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe particular delight of music, which belongs to its sound and cannot be stated in other terms.
- In The RenaissanceOne of the functions of æsthetic criticism is "to note in music the musical charm, that essential music, which presents no words, no matter of sentiment or thought, separable from the special form in which it is conveyed to us" (GIO §1).
- In this editionThe note at GIO §1 says that "Pater opens with a theory he rejects", and that a paraphrase of a subject "therefore leaves something specific to its medium behind".
- A place to readGIO §1.
Meaning
Charm comes, through the French charme, from the Latin carmen, a song or an incantation; a charm was first a sung spell. Pater's phrase gives the word back its first object. "Essential music" is music in its essence: what remains when everything that could be said in words is taken away, and what makes a piece of music music rather than a setting of a sentiment.
Use in the book
The phrase ends the first paragraph of the Giorgione essay, which sets out the three charms that criticism must learn to tell apart: the pictorial charm, the poetical quality, and "the musical charm, that essential music, which presents no words, no matter of sentiment or thought, separable from the special form in which it is conveyed to us" (GIO §1; see Pictorial charm; Poetical quality). Each charm is defined against what could be detached from it, the picture's against thought and skill, the poem's against description and meditation. Music's definition is the purest of the three: it presents nothing at all that can be separated from its form.
The paragraph opened with the error this definition answers. Popular criticism regards the arts "as but translations into different languages of one and the same fixed quantity of imaginative thought", with "certain technical qualities" added, "of sound, in music" (GIO §1; see Untranslatable charm). On that view music would be a thought with sound laid over it, and its charm a matter of technique. Pater's definition reverses the order: the sound is not added to the music, it is the music, and no thought stands behind it to be translated.
The first paragraph thus states, of one art, what the rest of the essay claims for all. Music is the art in which matter cannot be separated from form, and so all art aspires towards "the condition of music" (GIO §5; see Condition of music); in its consummate moments "the end is not distinct from the means" (GIO §10; see Artistic ideal). The musical charm of the first paragraph can be read as the condition of music before it has been named. The essay later finds the same charm in pictures of music, which catch "the waves of wandering sound" (GIO §15; see Wandering sound) and show people listening, "ear and finger refining themselves infinitely, in the appetite for sweet sound" (GIO §21; see Listening).
The definition has a close parallel in the criticism of music itself. The Viennese critic Eduard Hanslick had argued, in On the Musically Beautiful (1854), that music cannot represent definite feelings, only their motion, and that its content is forms moved in sound, the musical ideas themselves and nothing behind them.1 Twenty-three years before the Giorgione essay, and from within the art, Hanslick reached the conclusion that the essay draws from outside it: that in music there is no matter to be separated from the form, and that this is music's charm, not its poverty. Pater does not name him, and the parallel is one of conclusion, not of source.
Places to read
The paragraph in which "musical charm" and "essential music" occur, with four paragraphs of the Giorgione essay on music as the measure of the arts and on pictures of music, in the order of the book.
- GIO §1Criticism is to note in music the musical charm, that essential music, which presents nothing separable from its form.
- GIO §5All art aspires towards the condition of music.
- GIO §10In music's consummate moments the end is not distinct from the means.
- GIO §15The Concert has caught the waves of wandering sound and fixed them on the lips and hands.
- GIO §21In the school's pictures of listening, ear and finger refine themselves infinitely in the appetite for sweet sound.
Source note
1. Eduard Hanslick, Vom Musikalisch-Schönen (Leipzig, 1854), chapters 2–3.