Art and its materials

Condition of music

condition of music; law or condition of music

The state in which matter and form cannot be told apart, which music alone realises and toward which every art aspires

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe state of being like music: an art whose subject and handling are wholly one.
  • In The Renaissance"All art constantly aspires towards the condition of music" (GIO §5).
  • In this editionThe note at GIO §5 says that "Pater means the close union of a work's matter and its manner of expression", and that "A painting may approach that union through light and color, whether or not it depicts musicians".
  • A place to readGIO §§4–5, 10, 20–21.

Meaning

A condition, from the Latin condicio, an agreement or stipulation, is the state in which a thing exists and the terms on which it holds. The condition of music is the state of music at its best, and Pater defines it at once: the state in which "the end is not distinct from the means, the form from the matter, the subject from the expression" (GIO §10). The phrase does not claim that all art should sound like music or imitate its forms. It claims that every art wants what music has, a meaning that cannot be separated from its medium.

Use in the book

The doctrine is prepared by the Anders-streben of the fourth paragraph, which ends with all the arts aspiring towards the principle of music (GIO §4; see Anders-streben; Consummate art). The fifth paragraph states it: "All art constantly aspires towards the condition of music." In the other arts the understanding can always tell the matter from the form, and art's constant effort is to obliterate the distinction (GIO §5; see Matter and form). The examples follow: the "mere matter" of a poem, its incidents, or of a picture, its event or topography, "should be nothing without the form, the spirit, of the handling" (GIO §5). "Aspires" and "constant effort" make the condition a direction, not a possession: art strives to reach what only music has.

The tenth paragraph gives the reason: music alone completely realises the identification of matter and form (GIO §10; see Artistic ideal). The arts may therefore be represented as struggling after the law of music, and criticism estimates how nearly each work approaches it (GIO §10; see Musical law). The doctrine has become a measure, and the critic's task is to apply it.

Giorgione is the measure applied. In his selection of subject and his "subordination of mere subject to pictorial design", he is "typical of that aspiration of all the arts towards music, which I have endeavoured to explain,—towards the perfect identification of matter and form" (GIO §12). The twentieth paragraph names the condition again, "a condition realised absolutely only in music, as the condition to which every form of art is perpetually aspiring", and says that painting's approach to it depends "in great measure, on dexterous choice of that subject, or phase of subject" (GIO §20; see Interpenetration). The twenty-first adds a turn: "It is to the law or condition of music, as I said, that all art like this is really aspiring; and, in the school of Giorgione, the perfect moments of music itself, the making or hearing of music, song or its accompaniment, are themselves prominent as subjects" (GIO §21; see Listening). Music enters the pictures twice, as their law and as their subject.

The doctrine can be set beside the philosophy that gave music its highest place in Pater's century. Arthur Schopenhauer had held, in The World as Will and Representation (1819), that music alone among the arts is not a copy of the Ideas but a direct copy of the will itself, and so speaks of the essence where the other arts speak of the shadow.1 Pater makes no such metaphysical claim. His condition of music is a relation within the work, matter wholly absorbed into form, and it can be tested in a picture or a poem as well as in a song.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which Pater names music as the condition or goal toward which the arts aspire, in the order of the book.

  1. GIO §4All the arts aspire towards the principle of music, the typical or ideally consummate art.
  2. GIO §5All art constantly aspires towards the condition of music, striving to obliterate the distinction of matter and form.
  3. GIO §10Music most completely realises the identification of matter and form; criticism estimates how far each work approaches musical law.
  4. GIO §12Giorgione is typical of the aspiration of all the arts towards music.
  5. GIO §20The interpenetration of subject and form is a condition realised absolutely only in music.
  6. GIO §21All art like this aspires to the law or condition of music; in Giorgione's school music is also the subject.

In this edition

The Key Words entry on music says that in this essay "music is the art in which form and subject are most fully at one", and that "Pictures of people making music give him a visible instance of that relation".

Later readings

The phrase became a watchword of the Aesthetic Movement. Oscar Wilde, in the preface to The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891), wrote that from the point of view of form "the type of all the arts is the art of the musician". Whistler had come to the same analogy independently of Pater, and before the essay: his musical titles, Symphonies, Harmonies and Nocturnes, began with Symphony in White, No. 3, shown at the Royal Academy in 1867, and in his "Ten O'Clock" lecture (1885) he said that nature holds the elements of all pictures as the keyboard holds the notes of all music, and that the artist picks and chooses among them as the musician gathers his notes.2

Source note

1. Arthur Schopenhauer, Die Welt als Wille und Vorstellung (1819), vol. 1, book 3, §52.

2. Oscar Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891), preface; James McNeill Whistler, "Mr. Whistler's 'Ten O'Clock'", delivered 20 February 1885, printed 1888; Whistler, Symphony in White, No. 3 (1865–67), Barber Institute of Fine Arts, Birmingham, exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1867.