Art and its materials

Pictorial charm

pictorial charm

The charm proper to a picture, neither a poetical thought nor a technical skill, which criticism must learn to note

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe delight that a picture gives as a picture, by its colour and line, and not by its story or its skill.
  • In The RenaissanceOne of the functions of æsthetic criticism is "to note in a picture that true pictorial charm, which is neither a mere poetical thought or sentiment, on the one hand, nor a mere result of communicable technical skill in colour or design, on the other" (GIO §1).
  • In this editionThe note at GIO §1 says that for Pater color, sound and rhythm "are part of the work's meaning and pleasure".
  • A place to readGIO §1, with GIO §16.

Meaning

Charm is the power to delight that cannot be accounted for by listing the parts that delight. "Pictorial" restricts it to pictures: a pictorial charm is one that a picture has and that a poem or a piece of music describing the same scene would not have. "True" in Pater's phrase sets it against counterfeits, the charm of a story told in paint or of a skill displayed.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the sentence that closes the first paragraph of the Giorgione essay and sets out the duties of criticism. "One of the functions of æsthetic criticism is to define these limitations; to estimate the degree in which a given work of art fulfils its responsibilities to its special material; to note in a picture that true pictorial charm, which is neither a mere poetical thought or sentiment, on the one hand, nor a mere result of communicable technical skill in colour or design, on the other; to define in a poem that true poetical quality, which is neither descriptive nor meditative merely, but comes of an inventive handling of rhythmical language, the element of song in the singing; to note in music the musical charm, that essential music, which presents no words, no matter of sentiment or thought, separable from the special form in which it is conveyed to us" (GIO §1; see Poetical quality; Musical charm). Each art's charm is defined by two exclusions, and the picture's are the most exact. On one side is the poetical thought or sentiment, which could be put in words; on the other the technical skill, which is "communicable", that is, teachable. The charm lies between, in what can be neither said nor taught.

The second paragraph gives the same region its fuller name, "that true pictorial quality which lies between" technical acquirement and literary interest (GIO §2; see Pictorial quality; Literary interest), and its examples follow: the drawing that is a temperament's vision, the colouring that weaves light through dress and flesh (GIO §2; see Drawing; Colouring). Pictorial charm is felt before it is analysed, and the analysis finds it in these two things.

The phrase has a consequence that the rest of the essay draws out. A charm that belongs to colour and line does not depend on a name. When the critics take the Holy Family of the Louvre from Giorgione for "certain points where it comes short of this standard", such shortcoming "will hardly diminish the spectator's enjoyment of a singular charm of liquid air" (GIO §16; see Liquid air), and the Ordeal and the Finding of Moses are given up "whatever their charm" (GIO §16; see New Vasari). Pictorial charm survives reattribution. That can be read as the ground of the Giorgionesque, a type of art whose charm outlived the catalogue of authentic works (see Giorgionesque).

Places to read

The paragraph in which "pictorial charm" occurs, with the paragraph of the Giorgione essay in which a picture's charm survives its reattribution, in the order of the book.

  1. GIO §1Criticism is to note in a picture that true pictorial charm, neither a poetical thought nor a communicable skill.
  2. GIO §16A singular charm of liquid air fills the Holy Family; other pictures are given up whatever their charm.