Criticism and method

Universality

universality; universal

What holds for all: the Greek ideal, and the law that binds the modern mind

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe quality of holding for all cases, persons or times.
  • In The RenaissanceAllgemeinheit is glossed "breadth, generality, universality" (ROB §7).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §7 glosses Allgemeinheit as "Universality".
  • A place to readROB §§7–8, with WIN §§52–53.

Meaning

Latin universus, "turned into one", is the whole taken together, and the universal is what belongs to every member of a kind. The logicians set it against the particular. Pater uses the noun three times, and the uses fall at two points of the book: at its centre, in the account of Greek sculpture, and at its end, in the account of the modern mind.

Use in the book

The first use is the last term of Pater's gloss on Allgemeinheit, "breadth, generality, universality" (ROB §7; see Allgemeinheit). The order of the three words moves from the visible to the abstract: breadth is a quality of form, seen in the large planes of a statue; generality a quality of the type; universality a quality of its reach. The next paragraph says what the universality achieves: the Greek works gained "universal acceptance" (ROB §8; see Breadth of humanity). A work that leaves out what belongs only to one moment belongs to every moment; that is the reward of the Greek law.

The Winckelmann essay ends on a question that uses the word in the same sense. For Goethe "the problem came to be:—Can the blitheness and universality of the antique ideal be communicated to artistic productions, which shall contain the fulness of the experience of the modern world?" (WIN §52; see Blitheness). The question is the della Robbia essay's question at a larger scale: can the general be joined to the particular, repose to expression? Luca della Robbia's system, "midway between" the Greek and Michelangelo's, was one answer in sculpture (ROB §11; see Pure form).

The last use reverses the value. "The chief factor in the thoughts of the modern mind concerning itself is the intricacy, the universality of natural law, even in the moral order" (WIN §53). Here universality is not a gift of art but a fact of science, and it binds: natural law reaches into every act, and the modern mind feels itself entangled in it. The paragraph asks whether art can give "the spirit at least an equivalent for the sense of freedom" (WIN §53; see Equivalent of colour).

The adjective keeps the same sense, from the Preface's refusal of "some universal formula" for beauty (PRE §1; see Universal formula) to "the universal problem" that low relief answers (ROB §5; see Low relief).

Read across the book, the word traces a shift from art to science. The universality Pater admires is the Greek one, reached by leaving out; the universality he fears is the modern one, which leaves nothing out. Greek sculpture won its universal acceptance by purging the accidents of the moment; the modern law of nature claims every accident, and the question of the Winckelmann essay's last pages is whether art can still make, within that law, a world of repose.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "universality" or "universal" occurs, in the order of the book; the Italian universale at MIC §14 is not listed.

  1. PRE §1Writers have sought some universal formula for beauty; the student of æsthetics seeks not its universal formula but its special manifestation.
  2. ROB §5Luca's school has before it the universal problem of its art, and meets the special limitation of sculpture by low relief.
  3. ROB §7Allgemeinheit means breadth, generality, universality.
  4. ROB §8The breadth of humanity in the Greek works insured them universal acceptance.
  5. WIN §10Goethe's universal culture is set against Winckelmann's narrow interest.
  6. WIN §24A universal pagan sentiment lies beneath the religions of the greatest number.
  7. WIN §52Goethe asked whether the blitheness and universality of the antique ideal could be communicated to modern art.
  8. WIN §53The chief factor in the modern mind's thought of itself is the universality of natural law.

In this edition

The note at ROB §7 glosses Allgemeinheit as "Universality". The note at WIN §35 gives "Generality or universality".