History, culture and the Renaissance

Romantic spirit

the Romantic spirit; romantic; Romanticists; the romantic temper

The modern temper of adventure, variety and subjectivity, whose marriage with Hellenism Goethe illustrates and Winckelmann prepared

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe temper of the modern world, as against the classical: inward, restless, drawn to the strange and the remote.
  • In The RenaissanceGoethe illustrates "a union of the Romantic spirit, in its adventure, its variety, its profound subjectivity of soul, with Hellenism" (WIN §48).
  • In this editionThe note at WIN §48 says that Pater uses the episode of Euphorion "to imagine a modern art born from both Romantic restlessness and Greek form".
  • A place to readBEL §13; WIN §§33, 45, 48.

Meaning

Romantic first meant "like a romance", the medieval tale of chivalry and wonder written in the Romance tongues, and in the eighteenth century it came to describe wild landscape and the feelings it stirs. Around 1800 the German critics of Jena made it the name of an age and a principle. For them the romantic was the art of the Christian and modern world, as the classical was the art of antiquity, and G. W. F. Hegel's lectures on aesthetics gave the pair a history: the classical art form, in which spirit and sensuous shape are in balance, is followed by the romantic, in which inwardness outruns every shape (see Romantic arts). Goethe, who had worked on both sides, kept the distinction and judged it. "I call the classical the healthy, and the romantic the sick," he told Eckermann in 1829.1 Pater uses the word in all these senses, and he gives it a capital for the French school and its writers (FRE §32; BEL §13) and for the spirit that Goethe married to Hellenism (WIN §48).

Use in the book

The phrase comes in the forty-eighth paragraph, where Pater sets Winckelmann in his place. "The aim of a right criticism is to place Winckelmann in an intellectual perspective, of which Goethe is the foreground. For, after all, he is infinitely less than Goethe; and it is chiefly because at certain points he comes in contact with Goethe, that criticism entertains consideration of him" (WIN §48). Winckelmann's relation to modern culture is "a peculiar one". "He is not of the modern world; nor is he wholly of the eighteenth century, although so much of his outer life is characteristic of it. But that note of revolt against the eighteenth century, which we detect in Goethe, was struck by Winckelmann" (WIN §48). Then Goethe's achievement: "a union of the Romantic spirit, in its adventure, its variety, its profound subjectivity of soul, with Hellenism, in its transparency, its rationality, its desire of beauty", the marriage of Faust and Helena (WIN §48; see Marriage of Faust and Helena). The two lists answer each other term for term: adventure against transparency, variety against rationality, subjectivity of soul against the desire of beauty.

Winckelmann's part in the marriage is a paradox the paragraph does not hide. He struck the note of revolt against the eighteenth century, which can be read as the first note of the Romantic spirit, but what he gave Goethe was the other partner, "the Hellenic element", "in its true essence" (WIN §48; see Marriage of Faust and Helena). The revolt was romantic; its object was Greek. The paragraph can be read as describing the Romantic movement itself, which in Germany began, with Winckelmann, as a turn toward Greece.

The rest of the book gives the Romantic spirit its features. The romantic arts of painting, music and poetry translate every delicacy of "a consciousness brooding with delight over itself" (WIN §33; see Brooding spirit of life; Romantic arts), and sculpture is set against them as "not self-analytical" (WIN §33; see Self-analytical). The French Romanticists of the nineteenth century, "in their eagerness for excitement, for strange music and imagery", went back to the middle age and took up the Pleiad with it (BEL §13; see Pleiad). Winckelmann's own longing is "not a vague, romantic longing" (WIN §10; see Intellectual integrity). Even Greece has the romantic in it: Theocritus strikes "a note of romantic sadness" (WIN §44; see Blithe poise), and within the Greek ideal there is "a sort of preparation for the romantic temper", which Winckelmann failed to see (WIN §45; see Hellenic ideal).

The phrase can be read as the essay's answer to the opposition it inherited. For the Jena critics classical and romantic were two ages; for Goethe in his late judgement, health and sickness. Pater makes them two elements that can be married, and finds each in the other's country: the romantic in the mournful mysteries of Greek religion (WIN §45; see Mournful mysteries), the classical in "the clear ring of a central motive" in a poem of Browning's (WIN §36; see Creative act). The book as a whole can be read in the same way: its subject, the Renaissance, is an earlier marriage of the two (see Romantic love).

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "romantic" or "Romanticists" occurs, except those on romantic love (FRE §1), on a romantic circumstance in a tale (FRE §10) and on the romantic landscape of Castelfranco (GIO §17), in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §32The writers of the Romantic school in France have delineated the middle age.
  2. BEL §13The Romanticists, in their eagerness for excitement, for strange music and imagery, went back to the middle age and accepted the Pleiad.
  3. WIN §10Winckelmann's longing is not a vague, romantic longing: he knows what he wills.
  4. WIN §14Winckelmann's romantic, fervent friendships with young men prove that temperament was inwoven in his Hellenism.
  5. WIN §33Painting, music and poetry are the special arts of the romantic and modern ages.
  6. WIN §44Theocritus strikes often a note of romantic sadness.
  7. WIN §45A preparation for the romantic temper is noticeable within the limits of the Greek ideal itself.
  8. WIN §48Goethe illustrates a union of the Romantic spirit with Hellenism.

Elsewhere in Pater

Pater returned to the subject in the essay "Romanticism" (1876), reprinted as the "Postscript" to Appreciations (1889), where the romantic is not an age but a temper present in every age. "The essential elements, then, of the romantic spirit are curiosity and the love of beauty", he writes there, and the romantic character in art is the addition of strangeness to beauty (see Strangeness).2

Source note

1. Johann Peter Eckermann, Gespräche mit Goethe in den letzten Jahren seines Lebens (Leipzig, 1836), 2 April 1829: Das Klassische nenne ich das Gesunde, und das Romantische das Kranke.

2. Walter Pater, "Romanticism", Macmillan's Magazine (November 1876); as "Postscript" in Appreciations (London, 1889); Library Edition (London, 1910), pp. 246–248.