Religion, myth and the sacred

Spiritual sickness

spiritual sickness

Pater uses the phrase of Plato's Lysis, the dialogue on friendship that opens among young men at a wrestling school.

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Meaning

Attested: spiritual sickness (WIN §7). Pater uses the phrase of Plato's Lysis, the dialogue on friendship that opens among young men at a wrestling school. The modern student, he says, most often meets Plato on the side that seems to pass beyond him "into a world no longer pagan, and based upon the conception of a spiritual life" (WIN §7; see Spiritual). What Plato offered Winckelmann was the other side, "wholly Greek, and alien from the Christian world", the group of brilliant youths in the Lysis, "still uninfected by any spiritual sickness", who found the end of all endeavour in the aspects of the human form (WIN §7; see Affinity). The sentence can be read as making the spiritual life itself the infection. From the Greek side of the line, the conception that the soul is at odds with the body is a disease that has not yet reached these boys, and the word "still" says that it will. Pater does not mention it, but Goethe, talking with Eckermann in 1829, called the classical healthy and the romantic sick (see Romantic spirit). The essay's last pages answer the diagnosis. The modern world is "distracted by so many sorrows" (WIN §50; see Unity with one's self), and its problem can no longer be solved by perfection of bodily form (WIN §51; see Bodily form); its health, on this reading, must be won through the sickness, not by going back to a time before it.