From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
Meaning
To brood is first a bird's action, to sit on eggs and hatch them, and then to hover over, and then to think long and darkly. The first sense has a famous religious use. The second verse of Genesis, in the King James Version, says that "the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters", and the Hebrew verb, used elsewhere of an eagle over its young, was read by many commentators as brooding. Milton made the reading English poetry: the Spirit "Dove-like satst brooding on the vast Abyss / And mad'st it pregnant".1 A brooding spirit of life is thus a life-giving power that sits over matter and quickens it.
Use in the book
The phrase stands at the end of the fifth paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, which answers the question of where his sweetness lies. The secret of the sweetness, it says, is "this penetrative suggestion of life", in figures that have no lovely natural objects or draperies, only "the austere truths of human nature" (MIC §5; see Suggestion of life; Austere dignity). Then the turn: "but he penetrates us with a feeling of that power which we associate with all the warmth and fulness of the world, the sense of which brings into one's thoughts a swarm of birds and flowers and insects. The brooding spirit of life itself is there; and the summer may burst out in a moment" (MIC §5).
The passage solves the puzzle of the second paragraph. Michelangelo has no flowers, no forests, no lovely accessories; the world of natural things, the second paragraph says, has almost no existence for him (MIC §2; see Life in natural things). Yet the feeling of nature's fulness is there, not in what he shows but in what his figures hold. The "swarm of birds and flowers and insects" is brought "into one's thoughts", not onto the canvas. The spirit of life is "brooding", not yet hatched; "the summer may burst out in a moment", but it has not. The sweetness of Michelangelo lies in this held power, the life that warms the stone without breaking it.
The image gives, on this reading, the essay's whole argument in a figure. The creation of life, "off-hand and immediately, in the cold and lifeless stone" (MIC §3; see Creation of life), the Adam waiting for "a touch of the finger-tips" (MIC §3; see Expectancy and reception), the rocks that "have but to cast away the dust and scurf that they may rise" (MIC §4; see Master of live stone): all are moments before life breaks out, and the brooding spirit is what fills them. The comparison with Genesis, which the words invite, makes Michelangelo's art a repetition of the first creation, the spirit brooding over the waters before the world.
"Brood" has its other senses elsewhere in the book. In the passage of Heine's Gods in Exile that opens the Pico essay, the monks who broke the temples are "the black brood of monks" (PIC §2); the mystic, by one derivation, is one who shuts his lips, "brooding on what cannot be uttered" (PIC §7; see Mystic); Leonardo "brooded over the hidden virtues of plants and crystals" (LEO §9); into painting, music and poetry, the arts of the romantic and modern ages, "may be translated every delicacy of thought and feeling, incidental to a consciousness brooding with delight over itself" (WIN §33). In the Leonardo and Winckelmann sentences the brooding is long thought; in the Michelangelo it is the warmth that hatches life. Read together, they set Leonardo, who broods over nature to know it, beside Michelangelo, whose figures carry nature's brooding in themselves.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "brood", "brooding" or "brooded" occurs, in the order of the book.
- PIC §2In Heine's account, the black brood of monks broke down the temples and pursued the gods.
- PIC §7The mystic, by one derivation, shuts his lips, brooding on what cannot be uttered.
- MIC §5In Michelangelo the brooding spirit of life itself is there, and the summer may burst out in a moment.
- LEO §9Leonardo brooded over the hidden virtues of plants and crystals.
- WIN §33Into painting, music and poetry, the modern arts, may be translated every delicacy of a consciousness brooding with delight over itself.
Source note
1. Genesis 1:2; the eagle, Deuteronomy 32:11; John Milton, Paradise Lost I.21–22.