Criticism and method

Intellectual integrity

intellectual integrity; integrity

Goethe's word for the secret of Winckelmann's influence, which Pater reads as the truth of a single force to its own type

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordWholeness and soundness of mind: a mind undivided, true to itself.
  • In The RenaissanceGoethe names the secret of Winckelmann's influence "wholeness, unity with one's self, intellectual integrity" (WIN §10).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readWIN §10.

Meaning

Integrity is from the Latin integritas, wholeness, from integer, untouched, entire. The English word kept both senses, the material, a thing whole and unbroken, and the moral, a person sound and honest. "Intellectual integrity" now usually means honesty in argument. Pater uses it in the older sense, nearer to the Latin: a mind that is whole, not divided among motives, and in which nothing is wasted.

Use in the book

The phrase is Goethe's, as Pater reports him in the tenth paragraph. Winckelmann's influence runs through Goethe's culture "as the strong, regulative under-current of a clear, antique motive" (WIN §10), "One learns nothing from him," Goethe says to his secretary Johann Peter Eckermann, "but one becomes something" (WIN §10).1 What then was the secret? "Goethe himself will tell us—wholeness, unity with one's self, intellectual integrity" (WIN §10).

Pater at once finds a difficulty. "And yet these expressions, because they fit Goethe, with his universal culture, so well, seem hardly to describe the narrow, exclusive interest of Winckelmann" (WIN §10). Wholeness belongs to the many-sided man; Winckelmann was a man of one passion (see Narrow perfection). Pater resolves the difficulty by shifting the meaning of the word. "But what affected Goethe, what instructed him and ministered to his culture, was the integrity, the truth to its type, of the given force. The development of this force was the single interest of Winckelmann, unembarrassed by anything else in him. Other interests, practical or intellectual, those slighter talents and motives not supreme, which in most men are the waste part of nature, and drain away their vitality, he plucked out and cast from him" (WIN §10). Integrity is no longer the wholeness of a life that contains everything but the purity of a force that contains nothing foreign. It is a quality of direction, not of range.

The distinction is the hinge of the essay. Goethe, who had integrity in the first sense, learned it in the second from Winckelmann, and the essay's last paragraphs show him putting the two together, keeping Winckelmann's truth to type within a culture that takes in the whole (WIN §§50–51; see Im Ganzen). The same paragraph adds the sign of the single force: "The protracted longing of his youth is not a vague, romantic longing: he knows what he longs for, what he wills" (WIN §10), and within its limits "his enthusiasm burns like lava" (WIN §10; see Enthusiasm). Integrity, on this reading, is not calm. It is the concentration that lets a narrow passion burn without waste, and the essay can be read as preferring it, in a critic, to a breadth without heat.

The phrase also gives the essay its test of judgement. At the bar of criticism Savonarola and Winckelmann are both types of success, "because each is true to itself" (WIN §12; see Higher life). Truth to type, in a man as in a statue, is what criticism honours.

Places to read

The paragraph in which the word occurs.

  1. WIN §10Goethe names the secret of Winckelmann's influence wholeness, unity with one's self, intellectual integrity: the truth to its type of a single force.

Source note

1. Johann Peter Eckermann, Gespräche mit Goethe in den letzten Jahren seines Lebens (Leipzig, 1836), 16 February 1827: Man lernt nichts, wenn man ihn lieset, aber man wird etwas.