From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe phrase names the particular kind of pleasure a work gives, a pleasure that belongs to it and cannot be had from anything else.
- In The Renaissance"What is the peculiar sensation, what is the peculiar quality of pleasure, which his work has the property of exciting in us, and which we cannot get elsewhere?" (BOT §1).
- In this editionThe note on the Preface's questions (PRE §2) says that "In 'Sandro Botticelli,' Pater repeats it almost verbatim before turning to the distinctive quality he feels in the painter's work".
- A place to readBOT §1 and BOT §10, with PRE §§2–3.
Meaning
"Peculiar" comes from the Latin peculium, the property a son or a slave held as his own, and so means "one's own, belonging to one thing only". The sense "odd" grew from it, but Pater uses the older one. "Quality" is Cicero's coinage: he made qualitas, "what-kind-ness", to render the Greek philosophers' poiotēs, and gave the word to Varro in the Academica.1 The phrase asks of what kind a pleasure is, on the assumption that the kind belongs to one artist alone.
Use in the book
The phrase opens and closes the Botticelli essay. At the opening Pater puts the Preface's question to a painter, in the words quoted above, and adds: "For this, especially when he has to speak of a comparatively unknown artist, is always the chief question which a critic has to answer" (BOT §1). The Preface had asked of every object whether it gives pleasure, and "what sort or degree of pleasure" (PRE §2; see Pleasure), and had valued each work for "a special, a unique, impression of pleasure" (PRE §3). The essay can be read as narrowing the question in two steps. "Peculiar sensation" comes first, the bare effect felt; "peculiar quality of pleasure" follows, the effect discriminated and named. The order is the Preface's method in small: to know one's impression, then to analyse it.
At the close the phrase becomes a principle of rank. Besides the great painters "there is a certain number of artists who have a distinct faculty of their own by which they convey to us a peculiar quality of pleasure which we cannot get elsewhere" (BOT §10), and such artists have their own claim on criticism (see General criticism). The words "which we cannot get elsewhere" can be read as the language of the market, of a good that is scarce because it has no substitute, and it joins the Preface's comparison of works to "a herb, a wine, a gem" (PRE §3; see Virtue). A master may be greater; he cannot give this.
Between the question and the principle stands the essay's answer, and it is a surprise. The peculiar pleasure of Botticelli can be read as a pleasure in sadness: the wistfulness of figures "conscious of a passion and energy greater than any known issue of them explains" (BOT §5; see Wistfulness of exiles), the Madonnas who attract "more and more" though "conformed to no acknowledged or obvious type of beauty" (BOT §7; see Abject), the goddess of pleasure herself conceived with sadness (BOT §8; see Goddess of pleasure). The phrase that seemed to promise delight discovers melancholy, and Pater does not treat that as a contradiction. A quality of pleasure is defined by its difference from other pleasures, and the difference of Botticelli's is its shadow.
The question has a plain weakness: the critic who asks what a work does to him may find only himself. Pater's answer is the essay itself. It does not stop at "I feel"; it traces the feeling through a run of pictures and a philosophical legend until it can be named, and it ends by giving the name a place in culture.
Places to read
Both paragraphs in which the phrase occurs, in the order of the book.
In this edition
The note on the Preface's questions (PRE §2) says: "This question supplies a practical test for the ensuing essays. In 'Sandro Botticelli,' Pater repeats it almost verbatim before turning to the distinctive quality he feels in the painter's work." The note at BOT §10 says that the essay's answer "shifts the criterion toward an artistic faculty that produces a particular experience even when its practitioner stands outside the conventional first rank".
Source note
1. Cicero, Academica I.25.