Criticism and method

Æsthetic philosopher

æsthetic philosopher; philosopher, philosophers

The student of art for whom the tradition of a name is as real as the authentic works, and the Giorgionesque as real as Giorgione

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA thinker about beauty and art: here, one who studies their effects and influences, not only their facts.
  • In The Renaissance"For the æsthetic philosopher, therefore, over and above the real Giorgione and his authentic extant works, there remains the Giorgionesque also—an influence, a spirit or type in art, active in men so different as those to whom many of his supposed works are really assignable" (GIO §18).
  • In this editionThe note at GIO §18 says that Pater's category of the Giorgionesque "includes work by other painters, copies, attributions, and enduring habits of seeing", and that "The difference between influence and authorship is what lets his argument survive changes to the list of works by Giorgione".
  • A place to readGIO §18, with GIO §25.

Meaning

"Æsthetic" comes from the Greek aisthētikos, belonging to perception by the senses; the word became the name of the philosophy of beauty in eighteenth-century Germany (see Æsthetics). An æsthetic philosopher, in Pater's century, was one who theorised about beauty and art. Pater's use is narrower and more practical. His æsthetic philosopher asks what a body of work does to the mind, and counts as part of an artist's reality the effect his name has had.

Use in the book

The phrase comes at the turn of the Giorgione essay, after Pater has given up most of the master's pictures to the critics. The "new Vasari", the English critic Joseph Archer Crowe and the Italian connoisseur Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle's A History of Painting in North Italy (1871), has left "only one" of the six or eight famous pictures "certainly from Giorgione's hand" (GIO §14; see Authentic works). "But, although the number of Giorgione's extant works has been thus limited by recent criticism, all is not done when the real and the traditional elements in what concerns him have been discriminated; for, in what is connected with a great name, much that is not real is often very stimulating" (GIO §18; see Discriminate). The æsthetic philosopher is the one for whom this matters. For him "there remains the Giorgionesque also—an influence, a spirit or type in art" (GIO §18; see Giorgionesque).

The phrase sets two kinds of knowledge side by side and ranks them. The antiquarian, or "the accomplished science of the subject" (GIO §14), separates the real from the traditional and keeps the real. The æsthetic philosopher keeps both, because the traditional has worked on men's minds as surely as the real. A "veritable school" grew out of true and false attributions, copies and traditions alike (GIO §18; see Giorgionesque). Giorgione becomes "a sort of impersonation of Venice itself" (GIO §18; see Impersonation). For the philosopher this impersonation is a fact, and a more interesting one than a date.

The essay's last paragraph names the method. Beyond "the narrower range of the strictly ascertained facts" lies the vraie vérité, the real truth, of "those more liberal and durable impressions" which supplement them (GIO §25; see Ascertained facts), and with it the indirect influence by which an artist "really makes himself felt in our culture" (GIO §25; see Indirect influence). The æsthetic philosopher can be read as the Preface's æsthetic critic, asking his question of a reputation (PRE §2; see Æsthetic criticism). The answer, for Giorgione, is a type of art more durable than his pictures.

Elsewhere in the book "philosopher" is mostly a word for the schools, the philosophers whom Pico hoped to reconcile (PIC §8) or those against whom Winckelmann protested (WIN §7). Only in the Giorgione essay is the word joined to the æsthetic, and there it can be read as describing Pater himself.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "philosopher" or "philosophers" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. PRE §8In the age of Lorenzo artists and philosophers do not live in isolation.
  2. PIC §8The generous hope of reconciling the philosophers with one another and with the Church.
  3. PIC §13In Pico's Heptaplus the ancient philosophers either did not speak of divine things or spoke of them dissemblingly.
  4. PIC §15Whatever philosophers said of reconciling the old faith with the new, artists valued the Greek imagery.
  5. BOT §5Botticelli, like other artists so entire, would usually care little for a philosopher's theories, even in a poem in terza rima.
  6. GIO §18For the æsthetic philosopher there remains the Giorgionesque, over and above the real Giorgione.
  7. BEL §8If anywhere the Renaissance became conscious, as a German philosopher might say, it is in Du Bellay's little book.
  8. WIN §7Winckelmann protests against Christian Wolff and the philosophers.
  9. WIN §19Winckelmann's knowledge was as if recalled by one who had been lover and philosopher at once.
  10. WIN §41The poets, orators, historians and philosophers of Greece.