Criticism and method

Secondary painter

secondary painter

A painter below the first rank, and his claim on criticism

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA secondary painter is one of the second rank, below the masters whose work defines an age.
  • In The Renaissance"But, after all, it may be asked, is a painter like Botticelli—a secondary painter, a proper subject for general criticism?" (BOT §10).
  • In this editionThe note at BOT §1 says that Leonardo's mention of Botticelli "belongs to a discussion of landscape and the suggestive images one might discern in a stained wall or other marked surface".
  • A place to readBOT §10, with BOT §1.

Meaning

"Secondary" is from the Latin secundus, following, and so second in order or in rank. Elsewhere in the book the word measures meaning, "the supposed secondary, or still more remote meaning" (PIC §4; see Secondary meaning), and importance, "The characters themselves are always of secondary importance" (WIN §36). Of a painter it was a verdict of the history books, and Pater lets it stand as one.

Use in the book

The essay begins and ends with Botticelli's standing. It opens on a sign of rising fame: "In Leonardo's treatise on painting only one contemporary is mentioned by name—Sandro Botticelli. This pre-eminence may be due to chance only, but to some will rather appear a result of deliberate judgment; for people have begun to find out the charm of Botticelli's work, and his name, little known in the last century, is quietly becoming important" (BOT §1). The poet Algernon Charles Swinburne had praised Botticelli's drawings in the Fortnightly Review in 1868,1 two years before Pater's essay first appeared in the same review, as "A Fragment on Sandro Botticelli";2 "quietly" is exact.

It ends with the concession quoted above (BOT §10). Pater grants the rank and refuses its consequence. The great painters are a force in general culture "partly for this very reason that they have absorbed into themselves all such workmen as Sandro Botticelli" (BOT §10; see General culture), and the sentence can be read against itself: what a master absorbs is lost as itself, and the "peculiar quality of pleasure" of a lesser painter survives only in him (BOT §10; see Peculiar quality of pleasure). Botticelli belongs to the select number that general criticism must interpret (see General criticism), and his last claim is not his own but his age's: he has "the freshness, the uncertain and diffident promise" of the earlier Renaissance (BOT §10; see New artistic sense).

The defence reaches beyond Botticelli. The book's subjects include the anonymous author of an Old French tale, a Florentine maker of glazed terracotta and a poet of the Pleiad overshadowed by Ronsard, and it judges, as in the Pico essay, that the Renaissance of the fifteenth century "was, in many things, great rather by what it designed or aspired to do, than by what it actually achieved" (PIC §15; see Initiatory idea). The secondary painter can be read as the book's own chosen subject: promise rather than mastery, a quality rather than a rank. Pater's word "diffident", of the earlier Renaissance, describes the temper of his praise as well.

Places to read

Both paragraphs on Botticelli's standing, in the order of the book; the phrase "secondary painter" occurs only in the second.

  1. BOT §1Leonardo's treatise names Botticelli alone among contemporaries, and his name is quietly becoming important.
  2. BOT §10Is a secondary painter like Botticelli a proper subject for general criticism?

In this edition

The note at BOT §1 says that "Leonardo's painting precepts circulated after his death in compilations from his notebooks", and that his reference to Botticelli "belongs to a discussion of landscape and the suggestive images one might discern in a stained wall or other marked surface". The note at BOT §10 says that "Pater's question registers a nineteenth-century hierarchy of reputation".

Later readings

The critic John Ruskin, lecturing at Oxford on engraving, gave Botticelli a central place in Ariadne Florentina (1873–76),3 and within a generation the secondary painter had become one of the most loved of all. The German art historian Aby Warburg wrote his dissertation on the Birth of Venus and the Primavera (1893), and the English scholar Herbert Horne gave Botticelli a full documentary life in 1908.4

Source note

1. Algernon Charles Swinburne, "Notes on Designs of the Old Masters at Florence", Fortnightly Review, July 1868.

2. Walter Pater, "A Fragment on Sandro Botticelli", Fortnightly Review, August 1870.

3. John Ruskin, Ariadne Florentina: Six Lectures on Wood and Metal Engraving (1873–76).

4. Aby Warburg, Sandro Botticellis "Geburt der Venus" und "Frühling" (Hamburg and Leipzig, 1893); Herbert P. Horne, Alessandro Filipepi, Commonly Called Sandro Botticelli, Painter of Florence (London, 1908).