Art and its materials

Meditative subtlety

meditative subtlety; meditative

The inward fineness of the High Renaissance, found earlier in Botticelli

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordMeditative subtlety is fineness of perception joined to a habit of inward reflection.
  • In The Renaissance"In the middle of the fifteenth century he had already anticipated much of that meditative subtlety, which is sometimes supposed peculiar to the great imaginative workmen of its close" (BOT §1).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readBOT §1.

Meaning

The Latin meditari is to ponder, and also to practise, as one rehearses a speech; meditation is the thought that turns a thing over. Subtilis is finely woven, thin, and so delicate and penetrating. The two words together describe a mind that looks long and sees fine distinctions. In the book "subtle" is a frequent word of praise, not least of Leonardo: his genius generates "a type of subtle and curious grace" (LEO §16).

Use in the book

The phrase comes in the essay's first paragraph, in the sentence quoted above, and it makes a historical claim (BOT §1). The workmen of the century's close are presumably Leonardo, Michelangelo and Giorgione, the subjects of the book's later essays. Their meditative subtlety is "sometimes supposed peculiar" to them, and Pater denies the supposition: Botticelli had it first, or much of it.

The claim is characteristic of the book's method. The first essay finds a Renaissance in twelfth-century France (see Medieval Renaissance); the Preface grants the Renaissance's "earliest phases" their own "freshness" (PRE §6; see Ascêsis); the Botticelli essay ends by praising "the freshness, the uncertain and diffident promise, which belong to the earlier Renaissance itself" (BOT §10; see New artistic sense). "Anticipated" is the verb of that history. Qualities that seem to belong to a moment are found to have been prepared, and the preparers become worth studying for themselves.

The adjective returns twice. The "prevailing tone" of Michelangelo's sonnets to Vittoria Colonna is "a calm and meditative sweetness" (MIC §12; see Meditative sweetness), and the Giorgione essay defines true poetry as "neither descriptive nor meditative merely" but the "element of song in the singing" (GIO §1). The two uses pull in different directions. In the sonnets meditation is the calm into which passion has been withdrawn; in the definition of poetry it is a mere element that song must transcend.

Botticelli's meditative subtlety can be read as the first of these, but in painting. His figures brood: the Madonna whose "choice is on her face" (BOT §7; see Middle world), the Venus who seems to think of "the whole long day of love yet to come" (BOT §8; see Goddess of pleasure). The subtlety lies in the expression, the meditation in the figures, and Pater's claim is that a painter of the middle of the fifteenth century had already anticipated much of what is supposed peculiar to the workmen of its close.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "meditative" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. BOT §1Botticelli had already anticipated much of the meditative subtlety supposed peculiar to the great workmen of the century's close.
  2. MIC §12The prevailing tone of Michelangelo's sonnets is a calm and meditative sweetness.
  3. GIO §1True poetry is neither descriptive nor meditative merely, but the element of song in the singing.

In this edition

The edition has no note on the phrase.