Art and its materials

Light and shade

light and shade

The painter's contrast, refused by the Tuscan relief and praised when it modulates rather than opposes

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe distribution of light and dark in a picture or a scene; the painter's chiaroscuro.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Tuscan sculptors are "haters of all heaviness and emphasis, of strongly-opposed light and shade" (ROB §4).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §4 says that in low relief "the strength of a shadow varies with the depth of carving and direction of light".
  • A place to readROB §4, with GIO §6.

Meaning

"Light and shade" is the English for the Italian chiaroscuro, the clear and the dark, and it names the means by which a painter models form: a body seems round because one side is lit and the other in shadow. Strong light and shade gives drama and relief; soft light and shade gives atmosphere. In sculpture the light and shade are real, cast by the projections of the carved surface, and the sculptor controls them by the depth at which he carves.

Use in the book

The phrase occurs twice, and the two uses state one taste. In the della Robbia essay it is what the Tuscan sculptors refuse: "They are haters of all heaviness and emphasis, of strongly-opposed light and shade", and draw instead with shadows almost invisible (ROB §4; see Refinements of shadow). Sculpture in the round produces strong contrasts: a deep-cut face throws heavy shadows, and the sixth paragraph names "a thing of heavy shadows" among the faults of sculpture (ROB §6; see Hard realism). Low relief, barely raised from its ground, casts only faint ones. The Tuscan sculptors chose the faint, and "heaviness and emphasis" are the qualities their choice avoids.

In the Giorgione essay the phrase is praised when it modulates. A French river-side is superior, "for most conditions of the picturesque", to a Swiss valley, because there mere topography counts for so little and mere light and shade have "such easy work in modulating it to one dominant tone" (GIO §6; see Dominant tone). The landscape that has little of its own is the one light and shade can most easily make into a picture; the strong Swiss scene resists.

The two passages can be read as one principle applied to two materials. Light and shade are good when they unify and bad when they divide: "modulating" to "one dominant tone" in the landscape, "refinements" almost invisible in the relief, against the "strongly-opposed" contrasts of heavy carving. The Giorgione essay goes further: a great picture has, "in its primary aspect", no more definite message than "an accidental play of sunlight and shadow" (GIO §2; see Abstract painting; Accident). Pater's taste in light is the taste of the whole book: for the subtle over the emphatic, the passing over the fixed, and the gradation over the contrast.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "light and shade" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. ROB §4The Tuscan sculptors are haters of strongly-opposed light and shade.
  2. GIO §6On the French river-side mere light and shade modulate the simple material to one dominant tone.

In this edition

The note at ROB §4 says that "Low relief projects only slightly from its ground. On a work like Luca's marble choir loft, the strength of a shadow varies with the depth of carving and direction of light. Pater treats that variation as a means of suggesting movement."