Criticism and method

Instruments of criticism

instruments of criticism; instrument, instruments

Theories held not as truths to rest in but as tools for seeing: the Conclusion's place for philosophy

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAn instrument is a tool, a means to an end other than itself.
  • In The Renaissance"Philosophical theories or ideas, as points of view, instruments of criticism, may help us to gather up what might otherwise pass unregarded by us" (CON §5).
  • In this editionThe note at CON §5 says that "The instrument metaphor gives a use for theory consistent with the Preface: it can bring an overlooked feature of experience into view".
  • A place to readCON §5.

Meaning

Instrumentum is from instruere, to build or equip: an instrument is equipment, a thing one works with. The Greek organon had the same sense (see New organ). To call a theory an instrument is to deny that it is a result. It is held not because it is true but because it helps.

Use in the book

The phrase stands among the sentences of the fifth paragraph that make room for thought in a life of impressions. Having refused "a facile orthodoxy, of Comte, or of Hegel, or of our own" (CON §5; see Facile orthodoxy), Pater says what theories may still be: "Philosophical theories or ideas, as points of view, instruments of criticism, may help us to gather up what might otherwise pass unregarded by us" (CON §5). The two appositions define each other. A point of view is a place to stand, and an instrument a means to look; neither is a doctrine. The verb is modest too. Theories "may help", and what they help to do is "gather up" what would "pass unregarded", the stray particulars of experience that a mind without them would miss. The next sentence, "Philosophy is the microscope of thought" (CON §5; see Microscope of thought), gives the instrument its image, and the one after limits it: any theory that asks the sacrifice of part of our experience "has no real claim upon us" (CON §5; see Conventional orthodoxy).

The phrase can be read as the Conclusion's version of the Preface's method. There the critic regarded works of art "as powers or forces" and asked what they did to him (PRE §3; see Powers or forces); questions about beauty in the abstract were dismissed as unprofitable (PRE §2; see Metaphysical question). The Conclusion makes the same demand of philosophy itself. A system becomes an object of criticism, judged by what it lets us see, and so ceases to be a system.

The book's other instruments make the figure concrete. Leonardo's women are "the clairvoyants, through whom, as through delicate instruments, one becomes aware of the subtler forces of nature" (LEO §23; see Clairvoyant): persons used as instruments of perception. The Giorgione essay's paintings are to be used "as one might a poem in manuscript, or a musical instrument", at will, as a means of self-education and stimulus (GIO §12; see Animated presence), and its pictures are full of the tuning and touching of instruments of music (GIO §21; see Pure effect). The hireling ministers of the medieval system, by contrast, would hear of no service to the higher needs of humanity "with instruments not of their forging" (FRE §6). In these the instrument is a means of finer sense, and the Conclusion asks theory to be one.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "instrument" or "instruments" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §6The hireling ministers of the medieval system would hear of no service to the higher needs of humanity with instruments not of their forging.
  2. LEO §5Leonardo's master was a designer of all things for sacred or household use, instruments of music among them.
  3. LEO §23Leonardo's women are clairvoyants, through whom, as through delicate instruments, one becomes aware of subtler forces.
  4. GIO §12Pictures are to be used as one might a poem in manuscript, or a musical instrument, as a means of self-education.
  5. GIO §21The school of Giorgione paints the tuning of instruments and a momentary touch of an instrument in the twilight.
  6. CON §5Philosophical theories or ideas, as points of view, instruments of criticism, may help us to gather up what might pass unregarded.
  7. C73 §6In 1873: "Theories, religious or philosophical ideas".

In this edition

The 1873 text had "Theories, religious or philosophical ideas" (C73 §6; see Religious or philosophical ideas), and the revision dropped "religious", as it dropped religion from the service of philosophy in the paragraph before (CON §4; see Religion and culture).

Elsewhere in Pater

Marius the Epicurean (1885) draws a consequence from the maxim that life is the end of life (see Fruit of experience): it follows "the desirableness of refining all the instruments of inward and outward intuition", until one's whole nature becomes "one complex medium of reception".1

Source note

1. Walter Pater, Marius the Epicurean (London, 1885), chapter VIII, "Animula Vagula".