Criticism and method

New organ

a new organ; a new sense; new senses

Hegel's praise of Winckelmann, which Pater makes the highest that can be said of any criticism: to open a new sense in the human spirit

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA new faculty or instrument of perception: in Hegel's phrase, an organ for the human spirit.
  • In The RenaissanceTo have given a new sense, to have laid open a new organ, "is the highest that can be said of any critical effort" (WIN §2).
  • In this editionThe note at WIN §2 says that an organ "here is a capacity for apprehending something".
  • A place to readWIN §2.

Meaning

Organ comes through Latin from the Greek organon, a tool or instrument, and in the body an organ is the instrument of a function: the eye of sight, the ear of hearing. A new organ for the spirit is a new power of perception, as if the mind grew a sense it did not have. The word had a famous philosophical use before Hegel's: Aristotle's logical works were gathered as the Organon, the instrument of thought, and the English philosopher Francis Bacon called his new method the Novum Organum (1620). Pater does not connect either with Hegel's phrase, though the motto of the Leonardo essay is the first aphorism of the Novum Organum (LEO §1) and he cites Bacon twice more (PIC §9; LEO §17); Hegel's phrase is of another kind; it is not a method but a faculty, opened by contemplation.

Use in the book

The phrase is Hegel's, quoted in the second paragraph of the Winckelmann essay from the lectures on the philosophy of art: "Winckelmann, by contemplation of the ideal works of the ancients, received a sort of inspiration, through which he opened a new sense for the study of art. He is to be regarded as one of those who, in the sphere of art, have known how to initiate a new organ for the human spirit" (WIN §2).1 Pater adopts it at once as his own measure: "That it has given a new sense, that it has laid open a new organ, is the highest that can be said of any critical effort. It is interesting then to ask what kind of man it was who thus laid open a new organ. Under what conditions was that effected?" (WIN §2). The rest of the essay is the answer to that question, and its form follows from it: a life, because the organ was made in a man.

The phrase returns in the twelfth paragraph as one side of a choice. "Which is better?—to lay open a new sense, to initiate a new organ for the human spirit, or to cultivate many types of perfection up to a point which leaves us still beyond the range of their transforming power?" (WIN §12). The question sets Winckelmann's single passion against a culture of many perfections none of them mastered, and Pater does not rank them: he names two types of success, Savonarola and Winckelmann, neither of which criticism can reject (WIN §12; see Higher life). The organ is the reward of the narrow life: it is often opened only by one who has given himself wholly to one thing (see Narrow perfection).

The nineteenth paragraph shows the organ at work. The Greek world, in which others "had moved with so much embarrassment, seems to call out in Winckelmann new senses fitted to deal with it" (WIN §19). The senses are literal: he apprehends the Hellenic manner, not through the understanding, but "by instinct or touch" (WIN §19; see Instinct), and "catches the thread of a whole sequence of laws in some hollowing of the hand, or dividing of the hair" (WIN §19). The new organ, on this account, is a refined eye and hand, trained by love on its objects until it sees what others miss.

The phrase can be read as Pater's definition of criticism at its height. The Preface asks of the critic a "certain kind of temperament, the power of being deeply moved by the presence of beautiful objects" (PRE §4; see Temperament); the Winckelmann essay names the result when such a temperament meets its proper object. The critic does not add a theory to the stock of knowledge; he adds a way of seeing to the stock of human powers. That is a large claim for criticism, and Pater makes it for a critic whose perfection he himself calls narrow (WIN §10; see Narrow perfection).

Places to read

Every paragraph in which Pater speaks of a new organ or new sense, in the order of the book.

  1. WIN §2Hegel says that Winckelmann opened a new sense, a new organ for the human spirit; this is the highest that can be said of any criticism.
  2. WIN §12Is it better to initiate a new organ for the human spirit, or to cultivate many types of perfection?
  3. WIN §19The Greek world seems to call out in Winckelmann new senses fitted to deal with it.

Source note

1. Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik, ed. H. G. Hotho (Berlin, 1835), Introduction.