Criticism and method

Fruit of experience

the fruit of experience; fruit

What experience leaves behind when it is over: the reward that the Conclusion sets aside for the having of experience itself

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe fruit of a thing is its yield, what it produces and what is left of it when the work is done.
  • In The Renaissance"Not the fruit of experience, but experience itself, is the end" (CON §4).
  • In this editionThe note at CON §4 says that "fruit" means "the result or reward that survives an activity", and that Pater puts weight "on the activity of perception while it is happening".
  • A place to readCON §4.

Meaning

Fruit is the Latin fructus, from frui, to enjoy: the fruit of a thing was first what one has the use and enjoyment of, and only then the produce of a tree. The figure of life as a tree known by its fruits is old (Matthew 7:16–20), and the sentence that the Conclusion denies is the common one: that what an experience leaves, a lesson, a character, a work or a merit, is worth more than the experience. Wisdom, on this view, is the fruit of experience, and so are virtue, skill and the reward of a good life. Pater's sentence reverses the order. The tree is not for the fruit; the fruit is incidental to the tree.

Use in the book

The sentence stands in the middle of the fourth paragraph of the Conclusion, between the form, tone and mood that are real "for that moment only" (CON §4; see Moment) and the "counted number of pulses" given to us (CON §4; see Pulsation). "Not the fruit of experience, but experience itself, is the end" (CON §4). Its position explains it. If every form, tone and mood is real "for that moment only", nothing can be kept from it, and to live for what is kept is to live for what does not exist. And if the pulses are counted, what matters is how many are lived, not what they yield. The sentence is the hinge on which the Conclusion turns from analysis to ethics.

The word "fruit" returns at the end, changed. Great passions may give us a quickened sense of life, and Pater adds a condition: be sure that the passion yields "this fruit of a quickened, multiplied consciousness" (CON §6; see Quickened, multiplied consciousness). The fruit has moved inside the experience. It is no longer what remains when the experience is over but what the experience is while it lasts: consciousness raised and multiplied. The last paragraph can be read as answering the objection that the fourth paragraph invites. Pater does not say that experience bears no fruit, but that its only fruit worth having is more experience.

Elsewhere the book uses the word in its ordinary senses, and some of them stand near the doctrine. Winckelmann is "the last fruit of the Renaissance" (PRE §9; see Hellenism), the yield of an age. Out of a unique temperament Leonardo brought "strange blossoms and fruits hitherto unknown", and for him the novel impression conveyed counted as an end in itself (LEO §24; see Novel impression; End in itself), which is already the Conclusion's doctrine in one life. Du Bellay's genius yielded its best fruits in the years of homesick service at Rome (BEL §12), and Winckelmann gathered the "first-fruits" of Pompeii (WIN §20). In the others the fruit is a work or a person, and the Conclusion's sentence sets aside the kind of fruit that the rest of the book praises.

The sentence is the one most easily misread. It does not counsel the collection of sensations, and the next sentences ask how we may see in our pulses "all that is to be seen in them by the finest senses" (CON §4; see Pulsation), which is a discipline. The end is the having, in number and in quality: the Conclusion asks that we get "as many pulsations as possible into the given time", and its last sentence names art as the thing that gives "the highest quality to your moments as they pass" (CON §6; see Art for its own sake).

Places to read

The paragraph in which "the fruit of experience" occurs, with its 1873 text and the paragraph of the fruit of a quickened consciousness, in the order of the book.

  1. CON §4Not the fruit of experience, but experience itself, is the end.
  2. CON §6Be sure it is passion, that it does yield this fruit of a quickened, multiplied consciousness.
  3. C73 §5In 1873, without the comma: "experience itself is the end".

Elsewhere in Pater

Marius the Epicurean (1885), which Pater's note names as the fuller treatment of the Conclusion's thoughts (CON §1), gives the sentence its philosophical setting. In the chapter "Animula Vagula" Marius takes from the teaching of the Greek philosopher Aristippus of Cyrene, a pupil of Socrates, the maxim of "Life as the end of life", and the practical ideal it points to is not pleasure but "a general completeness of life".1

Later readings

The Irish writer Oscar Wilde gave the sentence to Dorian Gray. The "new Hedonism" of the eleventh chapter of The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891) was "never to accept any theory or system that would involve the sacrifice of any mode of passionate experience", and its aim, indeed, "was to be experience itself, and not the fruits of experience, sweet or bitter as they might be".2 Wilde's novel lets the doctrine end in ruin, and the use it makes of Pater's words can be read as the misreading that Pater's note of 1888 feared (CON §1).

Source note

1. Walter Pater, Marius the Epicurean (London, 1885), chapter VIII, "Animula Vagula".

2. Oscar Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray (London, 1891), chapter XI.