Religion, myth and the sacred

Religion and culture

religion and culture

Named beside philosophy in 1873 as powers that startle the spirit into observation: the revision kept philosophy and let religion go

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordFaith and the cultivation of the mind, taken together as services to the human spirit.
  • In The Renaissance"The service of philosophy, and of religion and culture as well, to the human spirit, is to startle it into a sharp and eager observation" (C73 §5).
  • In this editionThe notes at C73 §5 say that the first edition "explicitly extends that service to religion and culture as well as philosophy", and that "the express inclusion of religion gives the catalogue of ways to sharpen attention a wider reach".
  • A place to readC73 §5.

Meaning

In the England of 1873 the pair can be read as an echo of Matthew Arnold, whose phrase on criticism the Preface quotes without naming him (PRE §2; see To see the object as in itself it really is). His Culture and Anarchy (1869) had set culture, the study of perfection, beside religion, which it calls "the greatest and most important of the efforts by which the human race has manifested its impulse to perfect itself", and found that the two come to the same conclusion about what perfection is.1 In the year of The Renaissance Arnold went further. Literature and Dogma (1873) read the Bible as literature rather than as dogma and defined religion as "morality touched by emotion".2 For Arnold religion has conduct for its object, and culture, though "bent on seeing things as they are", moves also by "the moral and social passion for doing good": both are to make men better.

Use in the book

Pater's sentence gives the pair another service. Philosophy, religion and culture are to "startle" the spirit "into a sharp and eager observation" (C73 §5; see Sharp and eager observation), and the sentences that follow say what the observation is to catch: a form grown perfect in hand or face, a tone on the hills or sea, a mood that is real "for that moment only" (C73 §5; see Moment). Set beside Arnold, the sentence can be read as turning religion from conduct to perception: its service becomes the one that a poem or a picture gives, to wake the attention. When the 1873 Conclusion comes back to religion it asks nothing different: "religious or philosophical ideas" are instruments of criticism (C73 §6; see Religious or philosophical ideas), and "political or religious enthusiasm" is one of the high passions that give "this quickened sense of life" (C73 §7; see Political or religious enthusiasm).

The essays had prepared the claim. The Pico essay imagines a modern scholar for whom all religions "arise spontaneously out of the human mind, as expressions of the varying phases of its sentiment concerning the unseen world" (PIC §3; see Religious sense), and the Winckelmann essay, while calling the view "only a partial one", grants that "we are accustomed to think of Greek religion as the religion of art and beauty" (WIN §24; see Religion of art and beauty). A religion valued for the sentiment it expresses and the beauty it makes is close to one valued for the observation it rouses.

The revised text makes the service that "of philosophy, of speculative culture", and the observation "a life of constant and eager observation" (CON §4; see Speculative culture). Religion is gone. The change can also be read as a retreat from a provocation. To say that religion's service is to startle the spirit into observation is to make religion one more instrument of sensation, and the objection of Pater's Brasenose colleague John Wordsworth, that the Conclusion taught that "no fixed principles either of religion or morality can be regarded as certain" (see Abstract morality), shows how the Conclusion was heard. The revised text leaves the claim unsaid.

Places to read

The paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with the revised sentence, in the order of the book.

  1. CON §4The service of philosophy, of speculative culture, is to startle the human spirit to a life of constant and eager observation.
  2. C73 §5In 1873 the service is that of philosophy, "and of religion and culture as well".

Source note

1. Matthew Arnold, Culture and Anarchy (London, 1869), chapter I (titled "Sweetness and Light" in later editions).

2. Matthew Arnold, Literature and Dogma (London, 1873), chapter I, §2.